3 ms·
The Shenzhen special sauce is the high density of complimentary industries and specialized workforce. It's certainly possible to replicate, but history has sho
by mywittyname 8y ago
The Shenzhen special sauce is the high density of complimentary industries and specialized workforce.
It's certainly possible to replicate, but history has shown that it can be difficult. It would be like trying to supplant Hollywood.
- 394549 8y ago> The Shenzhen special sauce is the high density of complimentary industries and specialized workforce. > It's certainly possible to replicate, but history has shown that it can be difficult. It would be like trying to supplant Hollywood. There's now motivation to take on that difficult job, and the motivation grows the longer the trade war drags on. Companies may even rediscover the benefits of diversification. Right now Shenzhen is unique, but I'm sure there'd be much less anxiety right now if there was a Shenzhen II in Vietnam, Mexico, or even the US where production could be shifted too in times of crisis.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoSZ's special sauce used to just be its proximity to Hong Kong. To think that the role SZ plays has changed so completely in less than 30 years is evidence that it might not be that difficult to replicate.
- doctorpangloss 8y agoThat’s the worst possible example, because they truly don’t make cultural products like movies and music almost anywhere but Los Angeles. If it was about market forces, writers would get paid a bajillion times more. On the contrary, they’re paid terribly, relative to the value their product provides. Same with visual effects artists, just not as bad. Or music: an ecosystem unmatched anywhere but in LA. Even all those Swedish pop artists wind up there. Before you google counterexamples, just ask someone who actually works in film or music. You can’t just throw money at “it.” What seems to make good writers and musicians concentrate in LA doesn’t seem to be 100% governed by conventional market forces. Yes, it’s been difficult to replicate Hollywood! I think experiments with subsidies like for VFX in Vancouver, documentaries in Massachusetts and everything in Savannah, Georgia are interesting and nurture communities at different rates of success. In contrast, Wisconsin gives a $3 billion handout to Foxconn, Wisconsin gets a Foxconn factory. Because it will save money, things adjacent to the plant will be built. Writers cost nothing! There’s no money to save by locating them in LA, the savings on airfare and lodging and communications for a literal single human being is de minimus compared to the budget of a feature film. The scary thing about Shenzhen is all the applause for abstract things like skilled workforces and no appreciation for how different that “IP” is in comparison to e.g. Disney IP, like Mickey Mouse. They are not at all the same knowledge economies, electrical engineering and films.