7 ms·
China hasn't net added much to its treasury holdings in 15 years (it hit around $1 trillion back in 2003, it's now at ~$1.2 trillion). In that time they've prob
by adventured 8y ago
China hasn't net added much to its treasury holdings in 15 years (it hit around $1 trillion back in 2003, it's now at ~$1.2 trillion). In that time they've probably run a $4 trillion trade surplus. Clearly that isn't how it works at this point, they're intentionally avoiding buying more US paper.
In that time US debt has gone from $6.7t to $21t. Their share has gone from 15% or so, to 5.7%. They're no longer a funding source for new US debt, and are no longer a critical funding source of existing debt (although hey, it's nice to have them squatting on that trillion dollars and not liquidating it).
- rsj_hn 8y agoThe Rest of the World has never been a funding source for the U.S. It's impossible, because to purchase a treasury, the Rest of the World must first obtain dollar from an American, which decreases our income. Then, they purchase the treasury instead of the american. If someone grabs your wallet and then buys a share of stock with the money inside, they aren't funding the stock market and you don't need to be grateful to them.
- gonvaled 8y agoYou are giving the dollars to foreigners, in exchange of goods. Nobody is forcing you to do that. If you feel those products are not worth your dollars, do not buy them.
- rsj_hn 8y agoNobody is forcing you, but the forex rate adjusts so that the appropriate amount of goods is bought voluntarily. If country A bans foreign capital inflows and purchases $10 of foreign assets, then that forces a trade surplus of $10. Yes, that $10 transaction will be voluntary because it's currency will adjust so that the transaction is made. But from the macro point of view, the foreign capital flows drive the "voluntary" transactions.
- gonvaled 8y agoWell, that is how much the dollars are worth then.
- rsj_hn 8y agoThe dollars are worth whatever the relative foreign policies set. If China has a policy to depreciate against the dollar, by printing Yuan and buying dollars with them (what happens now) then the dollars end up being "worth" more, but the underlying capacity to produce of the U.S. hasn't increased, indeed it starts to decrease as people start to buy cheaper foreign output. So it's a bit disingenuous to say "well, people like these cheap goods" -- I mean, of course they do, but the story here is the foreign capital inflows which create an excessively expensive currency leading to a preference for certain types of goods. The whole ground is moving underneath you as a result of international policies and you don't see it, you just see people "choosing" to act.
- gonvaled 8y agoThe US manipulates the currency market in other, more powerful and more fundamental ways, by controlling the global currency. You do not need to hold foreign reserves, you do not need to pay exchange commissions, you are not blocked to do business with third parties by having capital flows stopped ...
- rsj_hn 8y agoI don't think you understand what you are saying here. Yes, the U.S. has the world's reserve currency _because_ it allows unrestricted foreign capital inflows and has a long respect for property rights and rule of law. Try, as a foreigner, buying a house in China. It's illegal. Try, as a foreigner, to buy a house in the U.S. -- no problem. The U.S. opens it's markets to the rest of the world to purchase American assets while the rest of the world closes its markets. If you are a foreigner, you can buy all the corporate and government bonds you want. You can repatriate money out of the U.S. in unlimited amounts. In China, this is illegal. They don't even allow their own citizens to move more than a small amount of money out of their country. There is a great black market of people smuggling money into and out of china because the government restricts cross border capital flows -- like hiding money in your socks or trick suitcases, bribing border guards to let you through stuff. This is why the U.S. is the reserve currency, and it is also why we have a trade deficit, because as the rest of the world's capital pours into the U.S., that forces our currency to be overvalued enough to have an equal sized trade deficit on the way out. Whereas you seem to think that that the U.S. "manipulating" it's currency by making U.S. currency more attractive to hold for foreigners -- is somehow a counter or offsets what China is doing, which is making its currency less attractive to hold. But it's not, these two work together to cause the same distortion and large trade deficits.