8 ms·
US imposes new tariffs on $200B of Chinese goods
- vadym909 8y agoIs there a simple chart somewhere that shows what are the old and new tariffs for the most commonly imported items. I'm just confused with hearing these large generic tariff news. Something like PCs- was 10% now 25%, Tshirts- was 10% now 50%, etc.
- NTDF9 8y agoThis looks like something NYT will come up with soon. They usually make pretty good infographics
- bowmessage 8y agomeanwhile other recent tariff deltas available here: https://www.usitc.gov/tariff_affairs/tariff_databases.htm https://www.usitc.gov/tariff_affairs/tariff_databases.htm
- cannabisceo 8y agoThe 25% is additional. So for the goods I import I still pay the old tarriff schedule but now I have a 25% line item tarriff that is additional to the existing tariffs.
- Taniwha 8y agoI have a sideline building open source hardware, I build and warehouse in China and sell all over the world .... I don't see these tariffs, I don't send the US govt money each time someone orders something, I just send stuff by mail to customers, they're the one doing the importing and end up paying local taxes in whatever country they live (just as I pay taxes importing stuff here in NZ when appropriate). People seem to forget that this is a really just a new tax that's being paid by Americans
- quantummkv 8y agoAnd if the Americans decide that the increased tax makes the total price more than what they want to spend, they'll stop buying your products. That is the intention behind these tariffs.
- RandomInteger4 8y agoWhat is the goal of Americans not buying stuff? What is it they hope to achieve?
- r_singh 8y agoIt's quite simple actually. This tariff is essentially is price disadvantage for China made products; products made in the US now have a relative advantage. So this is done in the hope that it will make sense for people to buy US made products and will also encourage local (US) companies to manufacture and sell in the States (since the tariff protects them from competition). It's a great move IMHO. I visited a WTO (world trade org) event in Mumbai recently and the US representative (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_N._Haass https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_N._Haass) was somewhat happy with what Prez. Trump is doing with import duties.
- Taniwha 8y agoI think it's largely a zero-sum-game - WTO rules allow a country targeted with unilateral trade sanctions to respond in equal measure without sanctions - which China is doing. Unlike a communist country they're free to pick targets that are political targets, in particular they're being smart, going for Trump's rural base. Meanwhile real people, in both countries are losing their livelyhoods.
- r_singh 8y ago> I think it's largely a zero sum game If I get your point right, I think that depends on a few things: (1) how much the 'Trump's rural base' in question depends on the Chinese market for their exports (not as much as the reverse IMO); (2) Whether US cos. will be able to take advantage of the higher tariffs on China made goods and hence sell more (therefore increase / stabilise employment); (3) If it doesn't really impact imports from China, and Americans just end up paying higher prices due to the tariffs, then how the GOV uses this new income from the tariffs? This could be used to strengthen local industry and increase employment, etc. > which China is doing China was doing this either ways by levying high import duties on products brought in to China, while US practiced free market and low key became somewhat of a victim to subsidised Chinese manufacturing. Disclaimer: my views may be naive, and would love to be corrected or given more insight on the subject to prove my view otherwise.
- clay_the_ripper 8y agoCan someone explain in plain English what the actual consequence of this will be?
- village-idiot 8y agoGoods that are purchased from China will rise in price. If China decides to retaliate, and they will, anyone who sells to China will see sales drop and losses pile up. Since the Chinese are likely to target based on American politics (think rural red states), the US government will probably step in and offer emergency loans or cash if it gets bad enough, pushing US deficits higher. There will also be some strange third order effects for Europe and other trading partners, but it’s beyond my skill with economics.
- cdash 8y agoChina will quickly run out of American exports that they can selectively (politically) tariff. In fact, they will eventually run out of ANY goods that they can tariff that are not already already tariffed much before the US does due the huge trade imbalance.
- NTDF9 8y agoBut the US has a trade surplus over China in Services exports into China. Presumably those will get tariffed. Also, US made products that relied on chinese intermediate products will go up in price, passed on to consumers. Those same US products will not be export competitive in other countries (because input costs increased with tariffs) and thus China can now export to places that US used to export to. Trade is not that simple and usually needs negotiations to be win-win.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoIn 2017 the US had a $40 billion trade surplus in services, and a $375 billion trade deficit in goods.
- 8y ago
- thwy12321 8y agoI'm having a surprisingly difficult time finding a nuanced view of these policies. On the one hand, china is taking advantage of us and is in part rotting our our middle class and blue collar workers. On the other hand, this could spark economic turmoil. Can anyone chime in here? Or is this beyond the scope of economics? (Not to dig on the field, bit we were told NAFTA we be great, look at the poverty in Mexico as a result.)
- golangnews 8y agoThe consensus among economists is that it's a terrible idea which will hurt everyone. Often this sort of trade war is a precursor to real war. Trade is not a zero sum game. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-05-02/economists-invoke-great-depression-in-warning-to-trump-on-trade https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-05-02/economist...
- thwy12321 8y agoThe people enacting these policies (Trump admin) argue that what we currently have is not trade, given how the Chinese have manipulated the markets, it is a one sided agreement. Free trade requires both sides not place restrictions on the others. Would you say this is true? Sometimes I feel like economic theory is like psychology, it seems real, seems like it has truth, but counter examples are abundant?
- gonvaled 8y agoIt's indeed not free trade, since the playing field is tilted massively in favor of the US, by controlling the global currency.
- lostlogin 8y ago“Trade wars are good, easy to win”. It’s an amazing statement and it will be interesting to see how it pans out. https://www.google.co.nz/amp/s/www.cnbc.com/amp/2018/03/02/trump-trade-wars-are-good-and-easy-to-win.html https://www.google.co.nz/amp/s/www.cnbc.com/amp/2018/03/02/t...
- gonvaled 8y agoThis will hasten the move away from the dollar. I hope that this allows the EU to trade prime matters and other goods in Euros, since interests are alligning perfectly.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- edhelas 8y agoSome, maybe dumb, thought. Imposing tariffs and therefore reducing the goods that are transiting to (and from) the US across the globe is not, indirectly, ecologically good? Less goods transiting, less transport to bring them across oceans, less container ships, less oil…
- lpcam33 8y agoThat's my opinion. For me this protectionism could be a good thing environmentally, and even socially if the tariffs income are well spend. For instance if we spend this tariffs in a UBI we could use this to change the economy to a more efficient and local economy.
- lostlogin 8y agoBut it’s more efficient to mass produce rather than have every country producing everything it needs. On top of that, some countries have inherent efficiencies in producing some items - proximity to resources for example.
- lpcam33 8y agoYou have the effect "mix vs sort" that shows that if you are very good making thing you are bad distributing them. So mass production is not as effective as local production if you account transportation externalities.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoPoorer countries struggle to look after their environment, if China's economy is slowing they may be tempted to burn more coal or dump more waste in their rivers.
- gonvaled 8y agoThis applies to trade in all directions. Funny how the US has been advocating for trade while it was "winning" (read, giving worthless papers for real goods). Since now we are hitting a wall (competing economies asserting themselves, and willing to be freed from the dollar), and since the US prsident seems to disregard, or not aware, of the massive advantage that the dollar means for the US economy, a trade war has been started. This war will either be won by the US on the short term, or the dollar will be dismissed as international currency.
- lpcam33 8y agoIs anyone here curious about where the tariffs income will be spent?
- NTDF9 8y agoBailout (buying votes) for more farmers who will lose export markets?
- lpcam33 8y agoFor me protectionnism could be a good thing environmentally like adhelas said. It could be a good measure if you use this tariffs to improve equality, distributing this equally through the population. Sadly nobody knows here the income will be spent.
- gonvaled 8y agoHow is equality achieved towards the Chinese workers?
- l_camacho84 8y agoBy reducing imports from China, China will need to invest in their local market too and by doing that they will need to improve chinese worker conditions.
- gonvaled 8y agoGreat. I hope the EU follows through and reduces US services imports to strengthen the local economy. I thought trade was good? Haven't I been hearing that from US officials for over 50 years?
- l_camacho84 8y agoYes, and in the last 50 years carbon emissions have skyrocketed, while wages have stagnated. We are depleting the resources of the planet and polluting at an unbearable pace. We have to change the economy and protectionism for me can be a good measure. If protecting the environment or health is good, why is protecting the economy bad? What is the opposite of protecting? attack? If so, why does protecting something lead to a trade war? should not it be to attack an economy? This area is full of self-righteous words like "free market" or "trade war". We cannot question something that is free? And a war is something that has to be fought at all times? We need to see through this.
- TheForumTroll 8y agoI find it funny and scary that the US think they can win a trade war. The only outcomes I can see is 1) China wins 2) it ends in war because why the hell not. Everything the US does ends in war.
- joefranklinsrs 8y agoThis actually looks like the start of the distanglement between the US economy and the Chinese economy. What will likely happens next (my best guess) is 1.) 40-60 percent of a company’s supply chain moves out of China 2.) China restricting the movement of capital/equipments out of China (similar to what happened with Korean companies last year) 3.) China growing homebrew competitors to the foreign companies leaving, part of the ‘made in 2025 in China’ strategy, via state enterprises or state spendings in startups. China will also make US companies’ operation in China very hard, either with license restrictions, or increased local ownership. 4.) China will disincentivize Chinese consumers from purchasing US (or foreign) products. Via propaganda, state media, others. This would be hard, as Chinese consumers prefer higher quality, higher brand value, and higher perceived value products. 5.) China will have to target US farmers with tariffs, as there isn’t much US imports to tax otherwise. Plus, there is the face saving situation. 6.) US will increase the tariff coverage to all Chinese imports, either triggered by tariffs on US farmers, or any other targets. 7.) China local governments will make a mistake of seizing a US owned corporate asset, or prevent a factory from shutting down by its owners. This will escalate the urgency for US companies to move out of China. 8.) 70-100% of company’s supply line will be out of China 9.) Eventually, most direct trades between both countries shrink. Down to a significant level where it starts to drop gdp for both countries (China way more than US) 10.) China will have no choice but to embrace its lost decade, ala Japan. It will tighten controls on its citizens. It will try to contain high inflation and high unemploment rate. It will try to unwind its debt for the next 10-20 years.