34 ms·
I know this is against the bandwagon but still: it was just fine the way it was. Changing the clocks (that is, society's timetable) to match the suntime is a go
by andrepd 8y ago
I know this is against the bandwagon but still: it was just fine the way it was. Changing the clocks (that is, society's timetable) to match the suntime is a good idea. And countries should absolutely have the freedom to choose what suits them best.
Now we're going to have to pick either summer time or winter time, to be on all year. Pick the latter? Bye-bye awesome summer afternoons with the sun setting down at 8:30. Pick the former? Say hello to waking up in darkness with the sun rising at 9 during winter.
- krupan 8y ago"Changing the clocks (that is, society's timetable) to match the suntime is a good idea" Except that's not what we do. The sun doesn't shift rise and set times by an hour on two magic days of the year. You know this right?
- ipqk 8y agoThere's a lot of unused sunlight hours in the morning in the summer, so we change our clocks to make use of it. That's how we "match the suntime".
- incompatible 8y agoOr just get up earlier.
- amanzi 8y agoGetting up earlier is definitely an option but you can't make the most of the time if schools and workplaces are still on fixed times.
- davemp 8y agoOf course. It’s called an approximation—I’m sure you know this though. Being a pedant doesn’t lead to interesting and/or productive conversations.
- krupan 8y agoSorry, I still don't get it. The sun doesn't shift by an hour, it just shows itself for less time as we get into winter and more time as we get into summer. Why can't we just center our days so that noon is always when the sun is highest and be done with it? The shift makes no sense.
- romwell 8y ago>Why can't we just center our days so that noon is always when the sun is highest and be done with it? That's what abolishing the DST gets us closer to, and the answer is - nothing is stopping us. Arizona has it that way, and they're fine. A longer answer: time zones are just an approximation to "sun is highest at noon" because it's awfully convenient to have clocks show the same time for people within a several hundred mile radius. The railroads made it pretty much a necessity, but even things like scheduled television programming would be very tedious with astronomical time: every city would end up with a slightly different schedule. Think about it this way: the circumference of the Earth is about 25000 miles, and one revolution is 24 hours. That means that 1000 miles is roughly an hour difference, and 100 miles is about 5 minutes. That means that, with astronomical time, if you have a 100-mile commute (sadly, not uncommon), you also have to account for the 5 minutes time difference between your home and work! While this might not be the question you are asking, some threads on HN have considered the possibility of everyone being on astronomical time, since we can put a GPS chip in every clock (...heck, we pretty much do that already), and everyone gets their schedules from realtime systems. But perhaps a more compelling alternative is just to give up and have everyone follow the same clock[1], extending the convenience of time zones (which are, after all, arbitrary and are an awful approximation for Solar time!) to the whole globe. [1]https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2016/02/12/the-radical-plan-to-destroy-time-zones-2/?utm_term=.231358155d61 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2016/02/12...
- krupan 8y ago"That's what abolishing the DST gets us closer to" Which is the point I was trying to make. Thank you.
- EastSmith 8y agoWell, we voted and we do not like it.
- hashmap 8y agoLosing an hour of sleep is bad for you, and having a mandated lost hour of sleep every year could be more than just bad for some people: https://healthblog.uofmhealth.org/heart-health/why-daylight-saving-time-could-increase-your-heart-attack-risk https://healthblog.uofmhealth.org/heart-health/why-daylight-...
- nraynaud 8y ago> setting down at 8:30 uh, in France it's more like 10pm in Paris at the end of June, and 10:20 in Brest (western France).
- hannasanarion 8y agoFrance is also a full time zone West of where it should be.
- beojan 8y agoPart of France is in the right timezone, and part isn't. It's Spain that's really crazy.
- etiennemarcel 8y ago"Funny" story about that... We switched to Berlin time when Paris was occupied in 1940. We didn't go back to GMT after the war.
- rvschuilenburg 8y agoSame thing happened here in The Netherlands. We were in our very own little "Amsterdam Time" which was UTC+00:20 but switched to Berlin Time during the war and we never switched back.
- tom_mellior 8y agoHaving lived both in France and a solar hour to the east of it (but still in CET), I find that France is exactly where it should be and most of CET is off by an hour or more. Moving the EU to permanent DST will fix some of this for me.
- beojan 8y ago> I find that France is exactly where it should be and most of CET is off by an hour or more How? The correct timezone is the one where the sun is closest to directly overhead at 12 noon. The real problem is that 9 to 5 is a lopsided working day, because it's centred on 1 pm, not noon. DST just moves solar noon to 1 pm, when the correct fix would be to move the working day to 8 to 4.
- MrQuincle 8y agoAt 1st of July sun sets in Amsterdam at 22.04 and rises at 5.22. Summertime doesn't make much of a difference. It's basically light all day. In winter it's the opposite. Just live with it and try not to be depressed. :-)
- fsloth 8y ago"it was just fine the way it was." I agree. Before the nonsense about turning the clock twice a year was "invented". "During World War I, in an effort to conserve fuel, Germany began observing DST on May 1, 1916." [0] See, there was shortage of fuel, and they thought DST would save energy. I don't think anyone has any credible data to support that it does. This has been an ongoing experiment for a century. Maybe we all can declare the experiment over. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daylight_saving_time_in_the_United_States#1966%E2%80%931972:_Federal_standard_established https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daylight_saving_time_in_the_Un...
- bduerst 8y agoA net energy loss/gain analysis of DST would be interesting, at least from the consumption side. That could impact carbon emissions which would be relevant today, right?
- hannasanarion 8y agoMany analyses have been performed and the only thing they have agreed on is that the difference, whether more savings or extra waste, is miniscule: less than 1%
- avh02 8y ago> less than 1% On a global or national scale this can be a very large amount - calling it miniscuLe is a little disingenuous
- amanzi 8y agoI agree with you. I grew up in South Africa with no daylight savings time. In the summertime the sun would be up and shining by 5am and would set by 7:30pm. Now that I've experienced daylight savings time in both the UK and NZ, I would much rather have a minor inconvenience twice a year to make the most of the sunny days.
- Tyrannosaur 8y agoIt speaks volumes that we find it easier to redefine time than to go to bed and wake to earlier.
- ako 8y agoI cant change the times the school of my kids start, so i cant change the time when i start working. I do most of my sports outside, in the summer while it's still light, DST is a great! It's just wonderful to windsurf or kitesurfing till 22:30 in May, June and July. Getting rid of DST means a lot let sporting hours for me...
- romwell 8y agoYou know, I have a better idea then! Let's have DST year round! It both saves the hassle of moving the clock, and gives you the extra hour of sunlight in the winter months as well as summer months!
- mrweasel 8y agoRussia tried going DST only, they had to switch back to winter time only because people hated summer time in the winter. May a better idea would be winter time only in Northen Europe and symmer time only when you get further south.
- creeble 8y agoWe did that once: https://www.mercurynews.com/2016/10/30/the-year-daylight-saving-time-went-too-far/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2016/10/30/the-year-daylight-sav... I'm surprised it's unmentioned here. My recollection was that a kid got hit by a bus in the morning, and that ended that.
- tragomaskhalos 8y ago> And countries should absolutely have the freedom to choose what suits them best. Unfortunately that's not how the EU works.
- beojan 8y agoYou can't change the number of daylight hours in a day by fiddling with your clocks. That's just impossible. All DST does is move an hour of daylight from the morning to the evening.
- s_kilk 8y ago> Bye-bye awesome summer afternoons with the sun setting down at 8:30 For whatever it's worth, there are plenty of people who hate this. The sun is still up when they're going to bed, meaning summer is a season of lost sleep.
- bausshf 8y agoI'm one of those few, because I have to get up really early, so I also gotta get to bed really early and I have trouble sleeping when it's light outside.
- zepolen 8y agoOr make work periods 10am - 6pm in the summer..
- andrepd 8y agoIs that not precisely what DST does?
- 8xde0wcNwpslOw 8y agoIt's the exact opposite. I can't understand the amount of people who have elementary problems comprehending which way the clock changes "geographically" speaking, and what it means in practise.
- mrweasel 8y agoMost European countries did start using summer time until the late 70’ early 80’, I assure you eliminating summer time would be a non-issue.
- Jnr 8y agoEven with DST at about 60° North latitude we wake up in darkness during winter. But having sunsets after 10PM in summer is really nice.
- neor 8y ago> Pick the former? Say hello to waking up in darkness with the sun rising at 9 during winter. If I recall correctly the EU prefers their members to choose this because most people prefer more daylight at the end of the day. I hope they do, I don't mind the darkness in the morning but that extra hour of light at the end of the day helps me go outside after dinner instead of turning on the telly and doing nothing all evening.