3 ms·
The battery is replaceable in most (all?) of their products, just not by the user. Battery service is sold on their site today.
by matwood 8y ago
The battery is replaceable in most (all?) of their products, just not by the user. Battery service is sold on their site today.
- cptskippy 8y agoI believe was asking for something akin to old Nokia phones.
- Tor3 8y agoThe old Nokia phones used another strategy (and so did most other vendors): Every new model used a different battery. Which at the same time obsoleted the battery in the old model, i.e. no new batteries were produced. You could still buy them, but they would have stayed on the shelf for a long time - in other words, they were as old as the battery you replaced. I bought a number of replacement batteries over the years, and without exeception the new battery (originals, mind) were as bad at keeping charge as the old one, after a couple of months. Into the drawer with the phone, buy a newer one, repeat. I'm absolutely certain that this constant change of battery form factor was just that: No point in replacing a battery because you could only find old ones. Buy new phone instead. This year I emptied a drawer full of old phones going back to around 1997 (the very earliest used NiCd batteries) until recent. Wow there were many. And I never got a new one unless the old one still worked - they all went into the drawer because they couldn't take a charge anymore. It should be said though that batteries don't die on me as quickly as they used to - the change seems to be from the last few years. They seem to keep better in storage, but charging strategy also matters - old phones used to really deep-discharge batteries before declaring them below 10% charge.
- cptskippy 8y ago> Every new model used a different battery. In the 90s when the phones were rapidly evolving and the batteries where huge and often incorporated into the exterior design of the phone. My first Nokia ~1997 was the size of a large TV remote, the second was the size of a king size snickers, the third was smaller than a regular size snickers. I had the Nokia 8290, and 6590 which were about 2 years apart and they used the same battery. They really didn't have that many batteries across their line after 1999: http://pinoutguide.com/CellularPhones-A-N/nokia_blb_battery_pinout.shtml http://pinoutguide.com/CellularPhones-A-N/nokia_blb_battery_...
- tialaramex 8y agoNo. I used Nokia phones from the mid-1990s until I reluctantly bought an Android phone a few years back. The 6110 needed a different battery from the 2140 I had originally, but from there all the way until the 6310i in mid 2000s they were compatible. Its even spelled out on their Wikipedia entry. "Accessories (such as batteries) can generally be swapped between all these models."
- frabert 8y agoBy that logic, the SoC is replaceable too, you just need a hot-air rework station, right?
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoAfter which the product will never be quite the same again. Sure it's usually good enough, but it'll never be quite as good as before, even when it's Apple doing the replacing. With an actual removable battery that only becomes the case after dozens of battery replacements (see remote controls, torches, older phones etc).
- mmjaa 8y agoThis is only convenient for users who can afford to be without their phone for a day or two, and also those who are anywhere near an Apple store / service centre. Perhaps there is data that supports the statement "this is most users", but as an Apple customer who travels a lot and is not anywhere near an Apple service centre most of the time, this is very inconvenient. I'd rather just be able to order a new battery, receive it in the mail, and do the replacement myself - having to go through hoops to get Apple to do it, even if its free, is a serious hindrance to productivity. Some of us use our phones for work, and the delay of days, for a service cycle, compared to minutes, if I can do it myself, makes a huge difference to that productivity...
- rimliu 8y agoCan I ask how often do you replace batteries on your phone that it must be done when you far away and it affects your productivity? Or is just another example of the strawman in this discussion?
- mmjaa 8y agoI keep my phones for 2 - 5 years. During that time, I'd need to replace the battery at least once, maybe twice. Its not a straw man argument - but I find your response telling. Perhaps its not clear to a majority of HN users, but not all of us iPhone users live within productive reach of an Apple Store. Getting to one in person can be very inconvenient if you're not an American in a metropolitan city. This is a very USA-centric point of view, you know. Having a user-replaceable battery would go a long way towards assuaging the hassle of having to deal with Apple Service. Especially in parts of the world that don't have that luxurious, consumer-friendly, American-style glass facade with its fancy logo and happy green-shirt wearing customer reps ..