7 ms·
Ten years after the crisis, the contagion has spread to democracy itself
- BenjaminBlair 8y agoIt's a bit terrifying how "alive" the crisis of 2008 still is. 10 years have passed and it doesn't look like the economy has recovered, not by a long shot. There are strong points in this article, I can't recall exactly, but I think it was the idea of Slavoj Zizek, that the strongest point of ideology is to define something as "non-ideological". Exactly how the crisis was communicated, like something natural, a hurricane or something. Not the ideological mechanisms that allowed for the bankers to take huge risks in their loans, for sure not Henry Paulson with his bank bailout. The link to the far-right seams scary too, thanks for sharing.
- mschuster91 8y ago> The link to the far-right seams scary too, thanks for sharing. Point is, the far-right/fascism/nazi ideology always thrives when social safety nets are being dismantled or are no longer existing. The rise of Hitler, for example, was based on him blaming the Jews for Germany's messed up economy (when it was the insane reparation load of WW1 that caused the economy situation), the rise of Trump was and is based mostly on rednecks blaming the loss of their jobs on immigrants (instead of climate change rendering e.g. coal superfluous plus decades of dismantling every social system the US has), and the rise of the AfD in Germany is based on the SPD dismantling the social safety net over a decade ago as well as stagnation in wages over the same time, which of course the AfD blames immigrants for...
- dredmorbius 8y ago...when social safety nets are being dismantled or are no longer existing... I'm slowly coming to realise this. You'd think that point might be more broadly advertised.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rdm_blackhole 8y agoBut what you describe is a real conundrum for governments isn't it? If this hypothesis is true then you would think that the government in place would do everything they can to stop the far right/far left from rising from the ashes of the failed social safety net. Instead, what we see mostly is the mainstream parties blaming the far right/far left without even addressing the issues that have led to people actually joining their ranks. Its the same in Europe. Some people say they want a different Europe, mainstream politicians say no. People then have the impression that their voices have not been heard. What do they do? They vote far right or far left and say: "now, can you hear me?" But even that's still not enough, because most politicians are only concerned with being reelected, they still don't listen and they even blame the people who now despise the mainstream parties. I can't understand this kind of logic.
- BenjaminBlair 8y agoAddressing the far-right/far left for the mobilization of unheard voices is kind of like treating the symptom. What we have here is a failing economy based on the enormous banking sector, debt and trickle down economics. Most of it is based on ideological premises, the belief that big profits will be reinvested to create more jobs, the idea of "responsible business", whatever that is. I mean, I can imagine small responsibilities that successful businesses take upon themselves, but can't imagine them solving global or national-scale scale problems. Anyway, the public political discourse is usually addressing the symptoms, like far-right blaming the immigrants or far-left bringing back some welfare-state memories. Looks like ever since the iron curtain was lifted global economies have been rocked by constant crisis and the voters want an answer, so they choose either left or right or whoever is speaking "the truth". And of course it's hard to address economic problems, requires a well-educated know-how.
- mschuster91 8y ago> If this hypothesis is true then you would think that the government in place would do everything they can to stop the far right/far left from rising from the ashes of the failed social safety net. The problem is that politicians care about their individual pockets, not what happens to society after their term. Politicians are not incentivized to serve the people - quite the contrary. And even if they do end up thrown out of office, a nice private sector job is waiting for those who let themselves be bribed.
- shard972 8y agoYou do realize issues about immigration aren't just about jobs, its about having a home. Maybe it's too hard for the rootless masses on HN to understand what its like being rooted in an area over generations to just watch it become a foreign country within a decade. Then to be told if only you cared more about climate change everything would be fine...
- bryanlarsen 8y agoOpposition against immigration is highest in areas with very little immigration, and support for it is highest in areas with a lot of it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Rubinsalamander 8y agoWhich kinda makes sense. Why would you life in an area with high Immigration if you dont Like/Support it. You would have to look at the data of people living in areas where Immigration just begins/recently started to see if they are happy about it
- mschuster91 8y ago> You would have to look at the data of people living in areas where Immigration just begins/recently started to see if they are happy about it I live in Munich. Aside from exorbitant rents caused by politicians ignoring housing issues for decades, we don't have a significant problem w/ immigrants and refugees. We do have a couple Nazi groups (two different Pegida groups, plus the "old" NPD nazi party plus the AfD neo-fash) with maybe two dozen people on the streets, but no one except Antifa gives a flying f..k about them.
- Rubinsalamander 8y agoThe exorbitant rents were the reason i didnt move to Munich, but Nuremberg. Rent is a Gatekeeper though, only "succesfull" people can afford to live there. The conflict seems to be more about gentrification. Also i personally dont know anybody who got negatively affected (besides closed school Gyms) by the refugee crisis, but many worry anyways. Probaly Social Media makes it feel worse then it is,similar to people feeling less safe now despite way lower crime rates.
- titzer 8y ago> The rise of Hitler, for example, was based on him blaming the Jews for Germany's messed up economy (when it was the insane reparation load of WW1 that caused the economy situation) Hitler spent far more time blaming Democracy for that, and several missteps in a row really handed it over to him. He despised Jews and blamed them, but you don't really come to power by blaming hidden minorities. He had to first destroy Democracy, which he did, to rousing applause. He convinced everyone that autocracy was the solution. And man, was it fast. As soon as he was Chancellor, they were up and murdering what was left of the minority opposition. It was fast and ugly. And after that, it was ironclad. People should be more worried.
- slededit 8y agoHe doesn’t have control of the justice department. It’s also uncertain the military would violate the constitutional ban on law enforcement at his order. To get closer to autocracy he’d need better control of one of those two branches.
- brandonmenc 8y ago> Hitler spent far more time blaming Democracy "democracy is fundamentally not German: it is Jewish" - Hitler Hitler believed the Jews invented and foisted democracy onto the world. So when he's blaming democracy, he's still blaming the Jews. > you don't really come to power by blaming hidden minorities Except he did exactly this, repeatedly and publicly, in his writing, speeches, and policy.
- titzer 8y ago> Except he did exactly this, repeatedly and publicly, in his writing, speeches, and policy. Sure. He pointed a hell of a lot of fingers. He had a special hatred for Jews, yes. He said it publicly, but my point was that it he didn't come to power by solely blaming Jews for everything. The "humiliation" that he felt Germany suffered due to the end of WWI generally played much better.
- brandonmenc 8y ago
- josefresco 8y ago"the rise of Trump was and is based mostly on rednecks blaming the loss of their jobs on immigrants" Please stop calling them "rednecks" and please don't assume that all his supporters were simply anti-immigration. While "redneckism" was a part of their campaign, Trump was elected by college educated, white suburban women too. Personally, the Trump supporters I've talked with are mostly well-off (small business owners), and mostly disconnected from world news. They don't identify as rednecks, and live in a very blue state. The usual justification goes like this "I worked for what I have, I don't think others should get hand outs" and "Politicians are all evil, I like that Trump is 'shaking things up'" To be clear, I'm not defending Trump supporters but rather advocating for looking at them with a broader view. While my state is one of the most liberal in the nation, 50% of my neighbors identify with GOP messaging.
- GW150914 8y agoI think all of what you’re saying can hold for people who supported Trump before his election, to an extent. Now however? I’m not inclined to cut people who still support him any slack. He’s more than demonstrated that in addition to all of his many hideous qualities, he’s not shaking anything up. The massive tax cut, continuing with the wars, involvement in Syria, etc, are all pure status quo. The ways in which he’s demonstrably different are his open racism, misogyny, and anti-democratic, anti-immigration stances. And polls keep showing that the people who voted for him do not regret their vote. “Redneck” may be unfair, and a slur, but the spirit of it in term of cultural identity (small-minded racists) has sadly been proven through his continued support.
- josefresco 8y ago"Now however?" A logical thing to assume for someone who is fully engaged with current events/news. However, most don't follow /r/politics religiously, and the nightly network news certainly isn't covering it (with the outrage that they should be) so many are still blissfully ignorant. Or is it willfully ignorant?
- chii 8y ago
- mmjaa 8y agoIn 2007 the World Bank issued a report stating, in effect, it wanted more right-wing governments in power around the world because they tended to borrow more (for wars) and it was better for the World Bank to have right-wing/crypto-fascsist in power than the liberal social democrats that had been paying off their bills. And now, look where we are. In short, if you're sick of all the right-wing nonsense, follow the money: who loaned them the money to get where they are today, in power? Follow that trail all the way back and you'll see the real string-pullers behind the puppets...
- petre 8y agoPoliticians cannot and will never fix the economy by going against the business cycle. It's all just hype, lies. Polarization will happen whenever people are discontent and facing hardship. They will look for someone to blame.
- Amygaz 8y agoI feel like it’s like that everywhere. The status quo is to convenient for upper management, while adopting sustainable policies within large companies is too cumbersome and not valued.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 8y agoSeveral key highlights for me here: (de)politicisation of, and power dynamics of finance. Attacking trust in institutions. And this: Financial crises foment authoritarianism. In 2015, a trio of German economists studied financial panics in 20 advanced economies dating back to 1870, and concluded that they almost always result in major gains for “far right” political parties after a lag of a few years. The most pressing question for policymakers facing a banking meltdown is not, “How do we restore our banks to profitability?” but, “How can we prevent social collapse?”
- def_ConGame 8y agoFacing a banking meltdown, no one's mind is fixed on what the political winds might turn into, after the seams burst, and the clean-up effort hoses off the sidewalks and sweeps the remains into the gutter. It's survival mode, not even women and children first. So before the dust settles, or even earlier when the economy is clearly imbalanced, unstable and listing off to one side, they expect people to think about the extremists this is going to bake over the next half decade. Never going to happen. Business people, accountants, financial operators, their minds do not work this way. But there's easily multiple folds or layers that all add together to produce such an effect. And part of it is age brackets. If this is a fifteen year cycle, it's partly generational, and as much about the ritual of hand-off as it is about who is actually landing in the driver's seat. But the roughest part is the polluter's mindset of those who set up the meltdown. They're definitely there to say: not my problem; so long, suckers! Immediately prior to that there's probably some mild discussion about incentives driving performance. Why perform at all, if not to reap rewards? And immediately prior to that, there's probably a period with a good record of following the rules, aging out and retiring uneventfully. So, if the process seems to havea natural rhythm, it's probably because human mortality means good teams eventually kick the bucket, and upstarts fill their shoes with less integrity. The faces change, but the story doesn't.
- dredmorbius 8y agoBanking and monetary regulators, and others, should and do look at long-term risks, though. That's part of the job. As is noting perverse incentives and adverse selection.
- ben_w 8y agoI remember reading an article (which I unfortunately can’t remember the title of) whose thesis was that there are two types of economic crisis, major and minor; that minor crises happen fairly often (every 8 to 15 years or so), while major crises happen every… I think it was 40 to 80 years; and all the major crises are followed by radical political transformation. French Revolution, replacement of the Tsars with communism, fall of the Whigs and the UK’s Liberal party, the end of the Weimar Republic, the fall of the Soviet Union, that sort of thing. It furthermore claimed that the major political upheaval only became apparent at the next minor economic crisis, because political scenes reacts to a major or a minor crisis by switching between two dominant schools of thought, and once both schools of thought are shown to be incapable of dealing with the situation, society forces them to be replaced with a different dichotomy. This certainly pattern-matches what’s going on in the UK at the moment. I’m not sure about the USA — although most of the Americans I know think poorly of Dem and Rep alike, that’s a massive sampling bias on my part because my American partner is a volunteer for the Green Party.
- sharemywin 8y agoI'm closest to a Green, but I would never vote for them in a national election. They should focus on winning some local elections. And work like a PAC at bigger levels.
- carlmr 8y ago>all the major crises are followed by radical political transformation Personally I think the last economic crisis was major, but there was no great political upheaval after it. The bad actors were propped up with bailouts, the advisers that really drive politics remained in power. Which makes me think the next crisis will be even more major, because we haven't solved any of the underlying problems. This is kind of like with a bug caused by technical debt. We implemented a workaround that will cause much bigger failures than the last one instead of refactoring.
- rustyboy 8y agoGreat read, the cancer of de-regulated financial services still hasn't been addressed, and might not ever if Trump and his richest cabinet in history continue to hold power. Wall Street continues to take on obscene amounts of debt from the government for essentially no interest, see Quantitative Easing, so that they can avoid paying even more taxes on their even greater profit. This is also fueling bubbles in other wealthy assets as everything is actually just leveraged debt. The prospects of another financial crisis is just as real as it was 10 years ago and again the lower-middle class will be left to hold the tax bill while the fat cats get fatter.
- segmondy 8y agoHah, if that was the issue it won't be bad. Wall Street taking debt is no concern really. The real issue is the extraction of wealth from citizens by Wall Street, Wall street builds nothing, absolutely nothing. They claim they provide liquidity, but yet when things look bleak, that liquidity dries up as they run and tighten up on credit. When they going is good, it's all about wealth extraction, they extract it from 401k, pension funds and from every day transaction between average investors trying to make an investment. The entire world of HFT is a joke. They have turned the market into something worse than a casino. In Vegas, you really know your odds, at wall street some of the instruments that are being pedaled shouldn't even be allowed in a video game.
- rustyboy 8y agoThey're both the same issue, a lack of regulation creates an entire web that makes everything it touches super fragile. When Lehman Brother's tanked they were one of the highest leveraged at 38:1, and current legislation allows 20:1 which many were originally operating at. If you look at any wealth asset, real-estate, wine, art, etc. these are all artificially high making the leverage crisis exponentially worse because when it comes time to shore up accounts these people don't actually have the value their writing in their books. Most of these retirement funds have to prove some basic stress solvency, but they're doing it with leveraged funds and debt. Thus when a downturn happens and it comes time to pay back the middle class we will have to bail them back out. We're paying twice! Student loans almost certainly will be the next bubble, Wall Street already sells these as an asset backed security (see SLABS). At over a trillion in value with the rules written against students when mass defaulting happens the whole system will come down again with individuals having absolutely no protection, and no one willing to fight for them.
- settsu 8y agoI couldn’t finish the article. It dredged back up the insecurities and feelings of personal and professional failure in the aftemath of the financial crisis from watching my home value being decimated and small businesses tanking, those being the bread and butter of my growing freelance design & development. All the time, financial, and emotional investments completely sunk while watching the rich, entitled Wall St set have their billions of dollars in gambling debts paid off with my tax dollars. (And then to come to the realization that I probably had that home to begin with largely thanks to the real estate gambles they were making back in ‘02…)
- josefresco 8y agoI've composed 3 lengthy replies to you describing my all-too-similar experience but deleted each because of the pain, and mountain of venting that can't be conferred in a simple comment. All I can say is that - I feel you brother. Been there, was screwed, my wealth was transferred (via real estate) to an older generation. I was left to rebuild my life and have yet to full recover. The one thing that remains in my head 10 years later: "Markets can remain irrational for longer than you can remain solvent" -John Maynard Keynes
- akudha 8y agoIs there a solution to this at all? What can a normal person do to protect themselves and their loved ones? I am not talking about voting, running for office etc, though that is probably the correct, long term fix. But short term?
- josefresco 8y agoMy mistake (with hindsight) was not being more cautious. I needed a home to start my family, and moving hundreds of miles away (which would have made me jobless) to a depressed region just to find an affordable house was out of the question. My wife and I were told that real estate was a "sure bet". I distinctly remember my mortgage broker telling me "I can't promise you anything, but real estate prices have been going up for 12+ years straight" Everyone a generation older than us were living in (and selling) houses that were skyrocketing in value. We felt that if we didn't buy now, we'b be priced out of the market forever. That being said, there wasn't a single person in my wife (personally or professionally) who could have warned me. It was either keep renting or jump in.
- everyone 8y agoCan someone post plaintext? The oath family popup is awful.. Either agree or 'manage options' which leads to a load of crap. I'm not agreeing, or drilling into all those options. Also, when you hit back, it brings you to the same page.. Thats some dodgy shit.
- walterbell 8y agohttps://outline.com/uagYRs https://outline.com/uagYRs
- manicdee 8y agoThe contagion is merely a symptom of the presence of one of the vampire-squid’s blood funnels attempting to extract all possible economic value from this new market.