10 ms·
The other huge news here, both for Linux and for numerous other communities trying to make similar changes: The most recent commit, right before the release, d
by JoshTriplett 8y ago
The other huge news here, both for Linux and for numerous other communities trying to make similar changes:
The most recent commit, right before the release, deletes Linux's "Code of Conflict" and replaces it with a real Code of Conduct, the Contributor Covenant.
https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux.git/commit/?id=8a104f8b5867c682d994ffa7a74093c54469c11f https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/lin...
https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/latest/process/code-of-conduct.html https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/latest/process/code-of-condu...
Quoting the commit message:
> Explicit guidelines have demonstrated success in other projects and other areas of the kernel.
> Here is a Code of Conduct statement for the wider kernel. It is based on the Contributor Covenant as described at www.contributor-covenant.org
> From this point forward, we should abide by these rules in order to help make the kernel community a welcoming environment to participate in.
Something worth emphasizing here: adopting a code of conduct, and choosing to be welcoming and inclusive, does not mean a project and its developers avoid disagreement, or avoid feeling passionate about their work, or avoid discussing and fixing issues. It just means not letting things turn heated or hateful, and treating people well.
- wolfgke 8y ago> It just means not letting things turn heated or hateful, and treating people well. Different people have very different beliefs what is to be considered "heated", "hateful" and "treating well" or not.
- JoshTriplett 8y agoHence writing it down explicitly to establish a common understanding.
- wolfgke 8y ago> Hence writing it down explicitly to establish a common understanding. This writing will not lead to a common understanding, but just one layer of indirection: The strife will now be about how different people have different beliefs how the words in the writing are to be interpreted. On the other hand: the mere existence of a CoC is a seed of strife since it is an open invitation for Social Justice Warriors.
- pron 8y agoThis is why a governing body codifies their interpretation of the matter into rules that everyone who wants to be part of the community has to abide by.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIt's a nice theory, but the reality is that those rules tend to get enforced differently for different people, so it fails to entirely stamp out problem behavior. Shit runs downhill. Whomever is at the top is the DNA for how things actually work. To me, the good news is Torvalds is taking some time to figure himself out. That is likely to make a major difference. Few people bother to really deal with the man in the mirror in earnest.
- sridca 8y agoYea. I fail to see how something like CoC can ensure a truly harmless community, when it is the covert power (the unspoken vibes, ambiance, etc.) that ultimately dictates the level of malice in a community.
- JoshTriplett 8y agoA code of conduct alone doesn't, but it's a start. A statement like this one from the project lead(s) helps as well, to set the overall direction. This isn't the end of the process for the kernel community; it's a major step in the right direction.
- sridca 8y agoIt remains to be seen how this all plays out. Personally I remain skeptical, because in one community I saw first-hand how the people at the top used something like CoC to justify their malicious acts, in the name of being welcoming. It is the same old morality game that does not ensure any genuine harmony.
- pron 8y agoOf course, but it's a start and a symbolic gesture.
- tptacek 8y agoApparently that just didn't occur to Chris Mason, Olof Johansson, Dan Williams, Greg Kroah-Hartman, Steven Rostedt, and Linus Torvalds.
- wolfgke 8y ago> Apparently that just didn't occur to Chris Mason, Olof Johansson, Dan Williams, Greg Kroah-Hartman, Steven Rostedt, and Linus Torvalds. But to Rafael Avila de Espindola (LLVM): > https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=LLVM-Rafael-Espindola https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=LLVM-Raf... > http://lists.llvm.org/pipermail/llvm-dev/2018-May/122922.html http://lists.llvm.org/pipermail/llvm-dev/2018-May/122922.htm... and many FreeBSD developers: > https://forums.freebsd.org/threads/is-the-community-become-fragile.64690/ https://forums.freebsd.org/threads/is-the-community-become-f... > https://www.reddit.com/r/freebsd/comments/7xapx2/freebsds_new_geek_feminismbased_code_of_conduct/ https://www.reddit.com/r/freebsd/comments/7xapx2/freebsds_ne... > https://www.reddit.com/r/freebsd/comments/7y43fk/censorship_on_rfreebsd/ https://www.reddit.com/r/freebsd/comments/7y43fk/censorship_... > https://www.reddit.com/r/freebsd/comments/7yby9i/donations_to_freebsd_foundation_after_geek/ https://www.reddit.com/r/freebsd/comments/7yby9i/donations_t...
- geofft 8y agoI don't see any FreeBSD developers in any of the four links you provided. In one of them I see a specific claim that the people in the thread don't seem to be connected with the FreeBSD community.
- tptacek 8y agoThat is a non sequitur response to my comment.
- loeg 8y agoI am a FreeBSD developer. None of those links are or represent FreeBSD developers.
- meowface 8y agoI don't think the language of the Contributor Covenant [1] contains anything really objectionable by anyone, even people who wouldn't consider themselves left-leaning. "Trolling, insulting/derogatory comments, and personal or political attacks" is arguably the only ambiguous part. That said, I am a bit skeptical of the CC creators' motives and goals. [1] https://www.contributor-covenant.org/version/1/4/code-of-conduct https://www.contributor-covenant.org/version/1/4/code-of-con...
- DC-3 8y agoThe contributor covenant is fairly in-objectionable. Yes, the list of 'privileges' is a bit of a checklist for left-wing soapboxes, but it's not necessarily a bad thing to explicitly list traits commonly targeted by bullies and harassers. The problem many people have with it, as you imply, is that it's the thin end of a doorstop, at the thick end of which is the Post-Meritocracy Manifesto: https://postmeritocracy.org/ https://postmeritocracy.org/ Written by the same author and often championed by the same people as the Contributor Covenant, it espouses some rather more radical ideas which, while carefully stated to sound superficially agreeable, are not ones I would consider beneficial to the open source community.
- Ws32ok 8y agoJust one example from that manifesto: “We have an ethical responsibility to refuse to work on software that will negatively impact the well-being of other people.” This a terrible slippery slope. It eliminates any military, security or even anything useful. A thief’s well-being is meant to be negatively impacted by a security measure. A guidance system in a missile is intended to negatively impact the well-being of the enemy. I feel negatively impacted by this manifesto. So by definition every signatory is in violation of that manifesto.
- tptacek 8y agoThe Contributor Covenant says nothing of the sort. It is entirely reasonable for developers to believe that the statements in the Covenant are a baseline for professionalism and, at the same time to disagree amongst themselves about whether they should contribute to military projects (or whether they buy into a "post-meritocracy" philosophy).
- tom_ 8y agoThis is the really interesting part of introducing a code of conduct to me: that it flushes a particular type of person out of the woodwork. They are forced to reveal themselves. Forced. It's like you're playing one of those hidden role games, and suddenly you do something that means people have to reveal their concealed cards. It's almost magical.
- wolfgke 8y ago> This is the really interesting part of introducing a code of conduct to me: that it flushes a particular type of person out of the woodwork. They are forced to reveal themselves. Forced. It's like you're playing one of those hidden role games, and suddenly you do something that means people have to reveal their concealed cards. It's almost magical. So you advocate a witch hunt against these people?!
- mcguire 8y agoAttacking ideas is fine. Attacking people is not. There are fine gradations that are open for interpretation.
- HaoZeke 8y agoThe Contributor Covenant is basically just a lot of publicity grabbing faux FOSS addition. I mean if you can't contribute code why simply mess around with things like the Code of Conduct.
- jerrysievert 8y agowhy write tests? why improve ux or ui? why help with documentation? > I mean if you can't contribute code why simply mess around with things like the Code of Conduct. there are many more parts to a community, even a community of developers, than just contributing code.
- lolikoisuru 8y ago>why write tests? why improve ux or ui? why help with documentation? Because these actually improve the project.
- joshuamorton 8y agoMany (decent) developers believe a CoC improves the project, in much the same way that any documentation on the development process or release lifecycle does so.
- jerrysievert 8y agoso do developers who would contribute if either there wasn't abuse, or if that abuse led to consequences. a code of conduct tends to improve projects when having one can help attract additional people to the project, or keep people there.
- danso 8y agoBut documentation is often not code.
- gedy 8y ago> there are many more parts to a community, even a community of developers, than just contributing code. True, but OSS and business software development is frequently short-handed in people who can actually make the software, not the planners, organizers, etc. The political debate gets polarizing because many of the "makers" think it's a lack of skill, and the other side comes across as blaming the maker's attitudes/community/etc.
- quotemstr 8y agoAdopting a code of conduct for Linux is a worrisome move. Any code of conduct that purports to police what contributors do outside the context of the project is a totalitarian infringement on individual autonomy, especially since enforcers of codes of conduct tend to take an expansive view of their remit. What CoC enforcement eventually becomes is a prohibition on project contributors professing political opinions that the CoC enforcers find reprehensible. You don't need a CoC to get civil behavior.
- JoshTriplett 8y ago> What CoC enforcement eventually becomes is a prohibition on project contributors professing political opinions that the CoC enforcers find reprehensible. To quote a comment I made elsewhere in the thread (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18001722 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18001722): If you want to argue about the level of taxation, the right size of government, regulations on business, whether public or private is the most efficient way to accomplish a goal, or myriad other areas of policy like those, go right ahead. Those kinds of things are absolutely reasonable subjects for healthy and reasonable debate. (They're rarely on-topic for a software project, but in some types of communities, or in companies, or in random side conversations, sometimes they are.) Those are almost never the kinds of political opinions that people have in mind when they're suggesting that "political opinions" should be an explicitly protected category, though. It's funny how the people worried most about whether they'll feel unwelcome for their political opinions are often those whose political opinions revolve around making others unwelcome, or hurting others, or questioning (or asking with superficial politeness about) others' right to exist. Those kind of "political opinions" do not and should not get any protections, in a code of conduct or anywhere else. You're legally allowed to say them, but you should not expect to do so without any consequence. > You don't need a CoC to get civil behavior. If you're lucky enough to have a community that all has a common understanding of how to behave well and treat others well, perhaps. But even then, writing that common understanding down helps others in the future. Usually, when we have undocumented information that people need to know, we call it "tribal knowledge", and we try to fix that by documenting it.
- quotemstr 8y ago
- aaron695 8y ago> Contributor Covenant The Contributor Covenant is horrific and harks back to the days of the Catholic Church(Or insert religion here) and morality and it's enforcement. It's a power trip that will end badly. Morality should come from within, a learned and practiced behaviour, personally and within communities, not prescribed. Manifesto's are purely implemented to bully people, they allow for the lynching and harm to others without remorse. They also very quickly mutate once they take hold, they are evil at its worst.
- danso 8y agoWho has been lynched because of a Contributor Covenant, or other similar open-source code of conduct? edit: You assert that "morality should come from within", though I'm assuming you're OK with projects and teams not reinventing things like PEP8 or language/framework best practices. But then you complain about manifestos "mutating". Isn't mutation a consequence -- many would describe it a desired feature, i.e. iteration -- when a community decides to develop a rule framework from within? (and I would argue that a community adopting something like the Contributor Covenant is quite clearly a decision made by that community)
- busterarm 8y agoRod Vagg, at least they tried.
- danso 8y agoIf the one example you can think of is apparently one in which that there was a failed attempt to lynch someone, then maybe it's possible it is an outlier (ignoring for now the debate on how much the CoC itself led to the Node.js conflict).
- CookieMon 8y ago> Who has been lynched because of a Contributor Covenant, or other similar open-source code of conduct? The scope of the Contributor Covenant was widened in an attempt to l̶y̶n̶c̶h̶ harass and ban Elia Schito for an opinion he had expressed on his personal twitter[1]. Because Elia's twitter conversation wasn't connected with the project (beyond the project being listed in his bio), a new clause needed to be added to the Contributor Covenant in order to get him. To get it in, the new clause was presented to the Opal project as a pull request labelled "Update Contributor Covenant to include ethnicity"[2]. The Opal project noticed the extra change and guessed its real intent (that intent - needing it to go after Elia - was confirmed later by people arguing for the change[3]), so Opal edited that clause before accepting the change, but everybody else using a Contributor Covenant now has it, including Linux. (The Linux one has customized enforcement/judgement guidelines, so in its case the presence of the "Elia clause" might be less easily weaponizable by the twitter mobs it was written for) The attack on Elia was instigated by the creator of the Contributor Covenant[4], who was unrelated to the Opal project but tagged in via twitter - it turned out this kind of drama was the Covenant's purpose. After watching that I no longer see codes of conduct as community measures written in good faith. It hasn't just been the Contributor Covenant one that's bad faith either, however, projects that adopt them are changing and rewording them in good faith, so they can get better - it's just not the CoC intent. Opal eventually got rid of their Contributor Covenant. Links because of how unbelievable this stuff is: [1] https://twitter.com/elia/status/611319469982527488 https://twitter.com/elia/status/611319469982527488 [2] https://github.com/opal/opal/pull/948/commits/817321e27eccfffb3841f663815c17eecb8ef061#diff-a1ee87dafebc22cbd96979f1b2b7e837R11 https://github.com/opal/opal/pull/948/commits/817321e27eccff... [3] https://github.com/opal/opal/pull/948#issuecomment-113486020 https://github.com/opal/opal/pull/948#issuecomment-113486020 [4] https://github.com/opal/opal/issues/941 https://github.com/opal/opal/issues/941
- ricardobeat 8y agoWas there a public discussion that led to this change? The 'Contributor Covenant' contains this line: > Other conduct which could reasonably be considered inappropriate in a professional setting which is essentially a carte blanche for any actions based on 'violation of the code of conduct', especially with the inclusion of public spaces in it's scope. We've seen it being (ab)used many times recently in open-source projects. Most recently it's been considered legally binding, and the wide net it casts seems to be a huge liability for contributors (not a lawyer, so feel free to school me on this one).
- lgleason 8y agoEvery good thing must come to an end. Sounds like linux is going to go down this path and the industry and innovation will suffer as a result of this. They've been gunning for Linus for a long time. My guess is that they got some dirt on him.
- explainplease 8y agoPerhaps http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=6907 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=6907 has come to pass.
- danso 8y agoWho would that be? I'm asking because you seem to be implying something more than just a general "anti-SJW" movement or belief system, if you do think that there could be a concerted effort to blackmail Linus and usurp his position.
- quantummkv 8y agoIt's a good practice to have some concrete guidelines regarding work environment. But this particular code of conduct is pure and utter garbage. I'm really not sure how Linus could ever willingly accept this. > Other conduct which could reasonably be considered inappropriate in a professional setting This statement here from the CoC is pretty much an open invitation to send whoever you don't agree with to the gulag/camp/whatever. What concrete definition is there of "reasonably be considered inappropriate in a professional setting"? These change across cultures and countries. Linux is a global effort. Not everyone on the planet follows the silicon valley, American or any single culture. You either have fixed and clear guidelines on what is acceptable or not, or have no guidelines at all. Something open ended like this is nothing more than a potential witch hunt in the making.
- JoshTriplett 8y agoThere's a large overlap between hurtful people and rules lawyers. Writing down samples of bad behavior is helpful; treating it as an exhaustive list is an open invitation to come up with creative new ways to hurt people that aren't on the list. Keep in mind that this is all based on the enforcement done by the project maintainers. If you're inclined to do things the project maintainers will consider unacceptable behavior, you're already going to have a problem. This just documents that.
- quantummkv 8y ago> treating it as an exhaustive list as an open invitation to come up with creative new ways to hurt people that aren't on the list. I am not saying that the samples should be very particular for particular situations. They should address a class of actions, like no racism or no sexism. But leaving it open to whatever the maintainer thinks applies is just too much power. > If you're inclined to do things the project maintainers will consider unacceptable behavior, you're already going to have a problem. As long as I am not openly abusing someone in the context of the project, the only thing that should matter is my code. The fact whether my political or personal views that I air on some other platform do not match those of the maintainer or some contributor should not matter at all. This CoC opens the gate for exactly this kind of abuse. Infact, it has been used for this kind of abuse. That is why I am hesitant about this. Linus might not use it like this, but regimes can change.