7 ms·
A certain sort of ruthlessness and lack of empathy, accompanied by having an extraordinarily driven personality, certainly seems to often make things happen (se
by Sharlin 8y ago
A certain sort of ruthlessness and lack of empathy, accompanied by having an extraordinarily driven personality, certainly seems to often make things happen (see also: Steve Jobs). The ages-old question is – is it worth it? Do ends justify the means?
- blindwatchmaker 8y agoPeople have been able to build successful organizations without being abrasive dickheads to their colleagues and subordinates all the time. I think it's a false dichotomy.
- sz4kerto 8y agoDo you have relevant examples (or even better, some statistics)? How do you measure this and how do you know if they were assholes or not? I guess you don't have a record of SLT meetings of large companies (as you have access to the emails between Linus and the maintainers). Leaders of large companies are _usually_ more aggressive, selfish and less agreeable than average people. This is a well-researched topic (and also makes sense intuitively -- leading a Fortune 500 company comes with so unique perks that there's an immense fight for those roles).
- rocannon 8y agoRicardo Semler is an example which comes to mind: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ricardo_Semler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ricardo_Semler
- parabx 8y agoI'ts not an company per se, but the rust community is fairly big and full of awesome, well mannered and cheerful leaders.
- Ygg2 8y agoWat. I been there and it's a fairly small community. They do have awesome and well mannered leaders but most are connected to Mozilla.
- noobermin 8y agoI think that's the point. However, such people "disappear" and end up being less known, even though they had a substantial impact of what they started. This fact then becomes part of entrepreneur folklore, reproducing more and more toxic people, etc, etc. I'm not sure why it has to be this way or whether it has to be.
- aerovistae 8y agoCompletely agreed. But it's definitely one of the archetypes of effectiveness, oddly.
- HaoZeke 8y agoHonestly though, LINUX IS FOSS. FOSS DEVELOPERS BURN OUT. PEOPLE ARE CRAZY. Give the guy a break.
- cowmoo728 8y agoPeople can be ruthless without being abusive. Linus had effectively ultimate power over the kernel for quite some time, so he could have said things like: "I disagree with this patch and I'm not going to merge it. It does these things wrong, and this line of reasoning makes no sense. Change these things and explain the reasoning behind this and I'll look at it again." Most of his rants that I've read could have been summarized by that without including any personal attacks.
- wolfgke 8y ago> People can be ruthless without being abusive. Everybody has a different conviction about what is abusive and what is not.
- cowmoo728 8y agoOne of Linus's more colorful rants: "Of course, I'd also suggest that whoever was the genius who thought it was a good idea to read things ONE FCKING BYTE AT A TIME with system calls for each byte should be retroactively aborted. Who the fck does idiotic things like that? How did they noty die as babies, considering that they were likely too stupid to find a tit to suck on?"
- Rainymood 8y agoHonestly it's a well-crafted insult, I give him that
- akudha 8y agoI don't know if it is worth it, but history is filled with people who treated others around them badly but achieved outsized success that much of humans can only dream of - including art (Picasso was terrible to others), military (Genghis Khan was ruthless to his own army), business etc.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ufo 8y agoI feel like Jobs was successful despite being abusive, not because of it.
- torstenvl 8y agoI'd be interested to know your thoughts in more detail, because I have a different perspective and have a hard time trying to see things from your point of view. From my perspective, people react to social condemnation of their actions. When someone does something incompetent, and they are gently corrected, that sends a certain message. When someone does something incompetent and they are lambasted, that sends the message not only that their work was of low quality but also that doing low-quality work is socially unacceptable. Since social acceptance is a much higher driving force for humans than merely being thought of as technically proficient, that would seem to be more effective.
- ufo 8y agoIt is one thing to reprimand people in public and another thing to be emotionally abusive about it. Steve Jobs is famous for being absolutely confident of himself (even for things that he didn't really know about) and for expecting the impossible from his employees (and being verbally abusive about it). This is a recipe for surrounding yourself with yes-men and for making your employees behave defensively when they are around you. Another thing is that people, like most animals, are better encouraged by positive reinforcement than by punishment.
- msbarnett 8y agoThere’s all kinds of problems with your perspective, most notably that it presumes the existence of an objective arbiter of “competence”. In reality, in the past Linus has lambasted people for patches that Linus misunderstood, which had no beneficial impact whatsoever and instead led to a least one case in which a highly competent contributor vocally said he was walking away from kernel development over Linus’ immature horseshit. It’s also important to recognize that essentially nobody chooses to be incompetent, so upping the “punishment” for incompetence does nothing to incentivize some other choice; rather what you perceive as incompetence is usually the result of either someone not knowing or understanding something you understand, or YOU not knowing or understanding something THEY understand. In the former case, lambasting someone will do nothing to improve their knowledge and help them be a better contributor; in the latter, lambasting someone over your own ignorance merely demonstrates to others what an ass you are.
- bastawhiz 8y agoI see this as two fold. If you hold a high bar with a stick, you might attain your goal of having a high bar—but you'll largely fail to inspire others to keep the bar held high after you leave. If you hold a high bar with carrots (read: empathy, professionalism, understanding), you'll impress your standards (and your values!) on the rest of your organization. Organizations that are led by the latter sorts of leaders last longer and tend to be more successful. That's not to say that there's no room for being firm—and OSS politics could drive the pope to violence at times—but LT's behavior has crossed the line many times over. I very much look forward to a more approachable kernel leadership approach.
- gerdesj 8y agosee also: Steve Jobs Mr Jobs was an entrepreneur who ran a company - a very influential one, I'll grant you. Mr Torvalds created something that turned out to be quite important and gave it away and encouraged others to help him improve it. When I consider "ends justify the means", I like to start with which ends might be important 8)