10 ms·
Apple Lightning Connector Serial Access (2015)
- doe88 8y agoPrevious discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9049113 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9049113
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Lomaxing 8y agointeresting, it would be nice if there was a Mod, so you could replace the lightning port to usb c.
- sebslomski 8y agoImpressing, that's real engineering. That persistence astonishes & impresses me!
- exabrial 8y agoApple is kinda put into a tight spot with lightning; they spent a bunch of money developing the connector an accessory platform. Now usb-c is taking over and they've moved to 100% usb-c on their laptops. it'll be interesting to see if the lightning connector gets The Chopping Block anytime soon
- ilovecomputers 8y agoIt's firewire all over again. They'll never learn.
- coldtea 8y agoLearn what? They've gone from near bankruptcy in 1997 to the the most valuable company on the planet in 2017, so it's not like firewire hurt them (or anybody cared much about it except some video and audio pros).
- rvense 8y agoI know a lot of regular people who got external Firewire drives with their Macs in the late 00's. My dad has a good pile with old photos on them.
- photojosh 8y agoIt was significantly faster than USB2 in practice. I sold my external FW drives not that long ago, was using them with a FW-Thunderbolt adapter for quite a few years ago.
- kccqzy 8y agoI bought FireWire drives in the early '10s too. Although USB3 was available, FireWire drives still tend to be cheaper.
- coldtea 8y agoI got a couple as well. But the huge majority of the population didn't. Most PCs didn't even come with such ports...
- toast0 8y agoThey sort of tried to let FireWire be a standard, and it never caught on. So for lightning, they didn't bother. Sounds like the learned their lesson about making standards. USB-C is kind of a big mess. Reversable connector is nice, but power is wonky, alternative nodes are wonky, everybody wants to add more alternative modes to the point where the only thing universal about it is the conbector (and usb 2 compatibility)
- vardump 8y agoThere are plenty of rumors of Apple moving to USB-C in 2019 models.
- freehunter 8y agoThere were plenty of rumors of Apple moving to USB-C for the 2018 models too, and zero excuses for them not to.
- reaperducer 8y agoAnd dozens of rumors for the last 10 months from supposed financial authorities that the iPhone X was dead. I've given up on Apple rumors. Especially anything from a business web site. Nothing is good since the death of Think Secret. If it's not on Apple's web site, it didn't happen and isn't going to happen. Heck, even then Apple has its own vaporware.
- toast0 8y agoI'm reasonably sure they'll switch either to USB-C or something they find even better (which could very well be inductive charging only, no connector), but there were plenty of rumours about adopting all flavors of usb before they switched to lightning too.
- inferiorhuman 8y ago> They sort of tried to let FireWire be a standard, and it never caught on. Firewire is a standard — IEEE 1394.
- scarface74 8y agoWhat do you mean? FireWire wasn’t widely adopted in the consumer market, but who cares? Most digital video cameras at the time supported FireWire as well as laptops from Sony and the higher end laptops from Dell. There wasn’t any dirth of hardware for people who needed it and where it made sense.
- reaperducer 8y agoAnd cable boxes used to be required, by law, to have firewire connections. I used that little loophole to request a different cable box from Comcast, then shoved the Firewire plug into a MacBook so I could record TV on it. (The firewire port was required because many early large projection HDTV sets had Firewire video ports and the FCC didn't want to suddenly obsolete millions of early adopters.)
- dwighttk 8y agoThere isn't much need these days to plug a phone into a Mac. If you need or want to, there are lightning to USB-C cables. I would be surprised to see them switch anytime in the next few years. I would be less surprised if they removed lightning altogether from a new phone than if they switched from lightning to usb.
- shshhdhs 8y ago> There isn't much need these days to plug a phone into a Mac. Actually, I plug my phone into my MacBook for two reasons: (1) to charge it when there’s no outlet nearby and (2) to have less interference when I use it as a hotspot and to charge it at the same time.
- scarface74 8y agoThat would be an even better reason for Apple to switch to USB C on both ends.
- SippinLean 8y agoBut if you want to quick charge your iPhone X (or 8) you need USB-C. The included USB-A to Lightning cable won't do it (neither will the 5W power brick included with the iPhone X). You'd need a lightning to USB-C cables and a USB-C PD power brick, neither are very cheap. Apple's USB-C cables start at $19 and the charger at $49!
- Shikadi 8y agoApple has a history of expensive accessories and cables, so it's nothing new
- ryanianian 8y agoI've purchased a large number of USB-C cables, and the Apple one is the only one that seems to charge a macbook pro at full-speed (87watts). All the others (Anker, Amazon Basics, a few others) only charge at 30w or 60w which can leave your computer out of battery after a full day of use even when plugged in if you're doing compute-heavy things. Not saying the $19 price-tag is "fair," but at least it's a high-quality cable.
- sebslomski 8y agoApple won't switch. They pissed of many people with the switch to lightning and were aware of that. They will probably do the same thing as with the headphone jack: Getting rid of any kind of connector. They already have the basics for that in place. It's just a matter of tooling now.
- scarface74 8y agoHave you ever known Apple not to drop ports in fear of pissing off customers?
- selectodude 8y agoThey have never had this many customers to piss off. A billion active iOS devices is pretty serious.
- scarface74 8y agoYou mean like when they removed the headphone jack? What are those pissed off iOS users going to do? Switch to Android and still have to buy new cables? Edit: The exclamation point was a typo. I didn’t mean to have the tone that might imply.
- threeseed 8y ago> What are those pissed off iOS users going to do? Firstly, the number of those users is from Apple's perspective anyway insignificant. The fact that they stopped shipping the Lightning->3.5mm dongle indicates this. Secondly, there are many workarounds. Including buying the dongle, switching to headphones with Lighting connectors or using Bluetooth.
- hrktb 8y agoIt seems with their current customer base, there is so much variety in what people want that they have more leeway to ignore what any specific group cares about. I’d guess for instance the number of people pissed off by a change of cable could be balanced by the people happy to use USB-C. The balance between the two is unknowable beforehand, so I’d imagine Apple managers just not care that much as long as a move makes some sense.
- gumby 8y agoDon't forget that Apple also participated in the design of Type C, which followed development of lightning. The big wins for lightning are that it's tsuper thin and that the part more likely to break is on the cable rather than the socket, while the type c socket on my MacBook and the one on my Anker charger (somewhat) rapidly became loose. I'd hoped that it would be the ground shroud on the cable but sadly it was the sockets that failed. The newer phones are getting thicker again so it's possible there will be room for Type C. The 6/7/8 designs were too thin to admit a type C cable, especially given the camber.
- ClassyJacket 8y agoIt's not a matter of thickness. The Moto Z is 5.2mm thick and has USB-C, vs the iPhone 7 at 7.1mm.
- radicaldreamer 8y agoThis is going to be a moot point soon as I anticipate we'll switchover to a completely wireless charging and data system. There might still be a physical debug port or something hidden away, but Qi charging plus a 5Ghz connector technology (like that in the Essential phone) is the future of mobile I/O
- imglorp 8y agoWhat's up with Qi charging anyway? We've had well-implemented inductive charging starting with the Palm Pre in 2009, but very few devices since then. It was on the Nexus 5 but not the 6 or the Pixels, I think. It adds very little hardware and enormous value. I dreamed of inductive charging everywhere, incorporated into desks, tables, and cars. But no. So, what happened to prevent its wide adoption long ago?
- gumby 8y agoIt's a harder problem than it looks: since it's typically pretty inefficient, how do you manage the signalling to get the right amount of power into the target device (you have 1/r2 issues, alignment issues, and insulation issues) without heating everything up and wasting power. I think that's why Apple's Airpower pad has quietly been put down -- heat. The current Qi protocol is pretty low power.
- shams93 8y agoFor pro audio lightening just works far better than any alternative. My ipad 2018 gets around 5ms of round trip latency with cubasis 2 and keep in mind this is Apple's entry level device for the education market, not an ipad pro.
- scarface74 8y agoApple spent $356 million on Authentec for its fingerprint authentication technology and more on research and is dropping that in favor of Face ID. Apple is well known for dropping ports. It dropped all of its ports for USB back in 1997. I doubt that Apple will let sunk costs stop it from moving forward.
- saagarjha 8y agoWell, Macs still use Touch ID, as well as a couple of iPhones that they still sell.
- scarface74 8y agoBut for how long? If they follow thier usual pattern, they will drop the iPhone 7 in 2019 and the iPhone 8 in 2020. It’s rumored that they are releasing new iPad Pros with FaceID this year. I suspect that the low end iPad will be the only thing that stays on TouchId for new products for the next few years.
- gammatrigono 8y agoThey made way more than $350 million off the Touch ID platform. Caring about sunk costs is a great way to not be Apple.
- johnhenry 8y agoBecause Apple recently stopped selling iPhones with 3.5mm jacks; today, the only way to get wired audio out of one is by using a first-party accessory. Now, third-party dongles and headphones fail to work and are met with a "No longer supported" message. If you want something to plug into "i" device, it either needs to be made by Apple or have their special approval. Third-party developers would cry fowl if they implemented USB-C and tried something similar. Because losing it would function to hinder their control over their accessory ecosystem, I don't see it on the "chopping block" any time soon -- despite how much we all would like to see it replaced by something more consumer-friendly.
- ganoushoreilly 8y agoIf you look at the issues with USB-C based phones without headphone jacks it's much more fragmented. Finding a device that functions correctly is very difficult. I think the verge did a story on it recently.
- johnhenry 8y agohttps://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2018/6/15/17467216/usb-c-headphones-wireless-future https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2018/6/15/17467216/u...
- jtaft 8y ago"Hit enter to break into the command prompt..." I wonder what's there.
- saagarjha 8y agoProbably astris or some other serial debug interface.
- jordache 8y agousb-c is a POS... the USB-C power connection on my MBP was noticeably looser after 1 yr of use.. lightning never exhibited this degradation.
- squaredpants 8y agoIt's funny, I also prefer much more the lightning connector to the Type-C one, but Type-C is not under Apple's tight grip...
- SargeZT 8y agoSo what you're saying is that Apple's implementation of the USB-C connector is terrible? I don't see how that's a legitimate criticism of the standard.
- jordache 8y agoI suspect the hollow USB C male connector is more susceptible to this degradation. The lightning male connector is not hollow
- jayd16 8y agoYou're the second person in this thread to mention this problem on the MBP. I work with tons of phones with USB-C and my laptop charges with USB-C and I don't see this "degrade over time" issue the MBP seems to have.
- akvadrako 8y agoIt's really too bad Apple didn't turn lightning into a standard connector. It could serve the same purpose as USB-C alt-mode (3.1 / DP / HDMI / Thunderbolt) without the legacy USB 2 wires. Especially if they made it double-sided (16 pin) but kept the form-factor the same.
- walterbell 8y agoFrom https://www.trustedreviews.com/news/apple-usb-c-european-commision-3525764 https://www.trustedreviews.com/news/apple-usb-c-european-com... > The European Commissioner for Competition ... is considering clamping down on tech companies who have made “unsatisfactory progress” towards common charging standards ... Apple is now the biggest player to have not adopted the USB Type-C standard for its flagship phones ... This is no idle threat ... the European Commission were recently behind the record €4.3 billion fine levied on Google https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/circuitbreaker/2018/9/10/17841152/apple-ipad-pro-2018-usb-c-lightning-charger-rumor https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/circuitbreaker/2018/9/... > Apple’s upcoming iPad Pro rumored to switch from Lightning to USB-C ... Ming-Chi Kuo says that the next high-end version of the tablet will switch over to USB Type-C
- LocalH 8y agoThe EU mandating which connector the actual phone has is a huge overreach. All Lightning-supported devices can be plugged into USB ports appropriately.
- pfranz 8y agoThis all started because of the incredible amount of e-waste because every brand used their own standard. Things didn't seem much better when USB started becoming standard on the other end of the cable for data and charging. Apple's original compromise was to offer lightning to micro-usb adapters[1]. [1] https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MD820AM/A/lightning-to-micro-usb-adapter https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MD820AM/A/lightning-to-mi...
- LocalH 8y agoI would posit that Android devices are actually worse historically than Apple ones. Many of them will not properly charge unless you either connect them to a charger manufactured by the device manufacturer, or to a PC/Mac (where they likely won't draw anything more than 500mA). I've had far more luck using Apple devices with non-Apple chargers, than the other way around.
- hughc 8y agoIn talking about a switch to USB-C, one point seems to be missing - Lightning gives Apple absolute control over which devices can connect. If you don't pay up your MFI fees, and get your device blessed, then there's a chance it can be blocked in a later firmware update, at Apple's discretion. This extends all the way down to charging cables, (tho I'm not sure how well it's enforced / easily sidestepped for charging cables). Maintaining that level of control, and maintaining the licencing revenue stream, over USB-C, might prove difficult? Either that, or they change the connector, and leave all the handshake protocol / custom chipset at both ends in place, in which case we will end up with devices that are USB-C in connector only.
- abraham_lincoln 8y agoI remember some comments here about HP's USB-C charger and laptop not allowing non-HP devices?
- dcbadacd 8y agoUSB-C standard has a stload of DRM built-in with quite a bit of crypto protecting it. You can even ask the country code where the power is from! I've yet to hear about Lighting possibly being region-locked D:
- myrandomcomment 8y agoI have no wish to see a usb3 on my iThings anytime soon. The lighting connector just works. There are 5 iPads and 3 iPhones in my house and I have never had any issue with the lightning connector. On the other hand everything that I have that has usb3 type C ends up becoming loose. USB is great, I just wish they made it with a good connector for once.