3 ms·
This principally is for Amazon China and not the US where despite years of complaints Amazon has done little to visibly counter the same effects and issues. To
by mc32 8y ago
This principally is for Amazon China and not the US where despite years of complaints Amazon has done little to visibly counter the same effects and issues.
To wit: "In exchange for payments ranging from roughly $80 to more than $2,000, brokers for Amazon employees in Shenzhen are offering internal sales metrics and reviewers’ email addresses, as well as a service to delete negative reviews and restore banned Amazon accounts, the people said."
While not holding my breath, I hope amazon USA will take its issues in the US seriously and mitigate fake reviews and the issue with comingling bad and good inventories.
- jhwang5 8y agoWhy is this downvoted? Why does HN jump to conclusions and generalities when it comes to big corps?
- amelius 8y agoShouldn't there just be a law stating that doing such things as deleting negative reviews is fraud?
- mc32 8y agoA problem is many reviews are for a lack of a better term, unrigorous. Some are outright wrong (unrelated to item), vengeful (maybe comes up short, competitor), and of course astroturfing. So basically they are a signal, and bad actors act in bad faith, but there are also just people who don’t review properly or who don’t add context to their reviews. A more thorough system would be a bit more expensive. Gor example allowing either subject or reviewer a right to appeal to an arbiter, etc.,
- detaro 8y agoWhat about fraudulent negative reviews?
- akudha 8y agoThey will probably come down hard on someone selling sales metrics etc (assuming it is happening in the US), but probably leave the fake reviews etc alone. It is just business - anything that isn't a big enough problem (yet) for their bottom line, why would they care to change it? On the other hand, selling sales metrics etc is serious (Amazon almost never releases raw numbers, for example, sales of Kindle readers) enough for them to take action
- wongarsu 8y agoIf the customers lose trust in the review system that is a big hit. Maybe Amazon thinks they are entrenched enough that it doesn't matter though.