4 ms·
> He moved to Canada, roughly nine months ago, after purchasing the films in Australia Of course he moved countries, that would do it. The movie is available
by SideburnsOfDoom 8y ago
> He moved to Canada, roughly nine months ago, after purchasing the films in Australia
Of course he moved countries, that would do it. The movie is available in both countries, but in a different "version". The rows have different id, so the query does not match them.
The legal details of online media purchases and country are crazy complex. Like batshit, no reason for it, it got that way over time and now we're stuck with it, "not fit for 21st century purpose but here we are". I worked in this area and it's easily the most complex part of it and as far as selling and streaming bits goes, pointless.
- csydas 8y agoAgreed -- it's entirely non-sensical in how it's enforced as well. I'm a US expat, and travel fairly regularly for work; when I first left the US, I retained my Amazon Prime subscription, naively thinking "A video is a video, who cares where I am?" Then I learned about distribution rights, and how absolutely terrible companies are at informing people about whether or not certain content is actually available in their region or not. Unless something has changed since the last time I checked (2 years back, so happy to be proven wrong), there is no official method provided to consumers to determine if you can actually utilize most streaming services from any given country/region, and this is extremely frustrating to me. Streaming should be perfect for me as it's preferable to keep what I carry as light as possible, and yet I know that I cannot rely on any streaming service to reliably provide me with the content that I signed up with the intention of viewing/listening to. Granted, I guess that's my fault for traveling, but it just seems very silly that one situation where streaming is the perfect solution, it fails completely due to distribution rights.
- IronBacon 8y agoThey were going to force a "single digital market" in EU but I haven't heard news about it recently.
- zucan 8y agoThe digital single market for online content services is effective since April: https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/cross-border-portability-online-content-services https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/cross-border-p...
- chrisper 8y agoThis is why piracy is still going strong... purchasing movies is just so inconvenient. I really don't understand how hollywood doesn't see this.
- petepete 8y agoA better product, delivered in a more convenient way, more reliably and cheaper. Piracy isn't going away anytime soon.
- phs318u 8y agoAnd that's the real point that's misunderstood by most respondents to this article. Because the guy moved, he could no longer re-download his legally purchased movie in the new location (= new movie rights jurisdiction). However, if he should move back to the original location, he should be able to re-download them just fine. Meaning, that while he is in a media-rights jurisdiction different to that of his original purchase, his movie is in limbo. In other words, the ability to download his purchase, comes with a geographic restriction. That point should probably be pointed out to prospective purchasers.
- e12e 8y agoAnd if he'd purchased films on region locked dvds or blu-ray - he could've taken his blu-ray player with him when he moved - and be able to play his old films on his old player - but might have to buy a new player to buy locally purchased films. This isn't strictly true, though: DVD region locking is mostly broken now, and I think(?) few blu-ray disc's are actually region locked? This will be even better with drm in the display port standard or whatever - so you need an Australian apple TV on an Australian VPN connected to an Australian TV...
- SideburnsOfDoom 8y agoTo be clear, I would not entirely blame Apple. Apple is a digital company who will not care a lot about borders and region when selling hardware and software. But in order to sell movies and music that they do not "own", they have to enter into signed legal agreements with the rights-holders of that media. e.g. "Cars" is owned by Disney/Pixar. Those agreements will mandate that Apple enforce this antiquated fuckwitery.