5 ms·
IMO feeding the anxious with fear about supposed medical maladies is why their practices are unethical.
by Spooky23 8y ago
IMO feeding the anxious with fear about supposed medical maladies is why their practices are unethical.
- MrStonedOne 8y agoKnowledge is never unethical.
- Cyclone_ 8y agoWhat if it's knowledge w/o context that can be more likely to confuse than help someone?
- torstenvl 8y agoIf someone has access to data and doesn't know how to interpret it, they should go out and find someone who can help them. At the very least, they should try not to jump to conclusions. There is no ethical excuse for withholding information from someone about their own biology.
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoI would argue that knowledge without context is incomplete knowledge unless you can reasonably expect the receiver to have the context necessary. You aren't really being ethical if you aren't giving a truthful account of the information. It kinda falls under "well, I didn't actually lie... I just didn't say more than absolutely necessary. It isn't my fault if they assumed wrongly." In the example of early-onset alzheimer's, complete information would come with a recommendation of retesting, given the incidence of errors, a likelihood of the disease (was given), and whatever the accepted medical advice to follow afterwards is. It would probably be best to include warning signs of when to see the doctor about it if most doctors and insurances won't cover anything without symptoms. You can have all the legal disclaimers on this as well.
- teddyh 8y agoCherry-picked details and facts can be intentionally misleading, and still be true. Facts can also easily be spun into almost any narrative, all the while still being technically true.
- Cyclone_ 8y agoI'd be OK with these places charging a little bit more and letting people talk to a consultant that could help interpret the results.
- prepend 8y agoI had to work with a genetic counselor before my doctor would allow me to order a specific exam. The interaction was not very useful. They charged $450. My insurance did not cover it. They only met remotely via Skype. They read the exact material that was available to me through google. They were more about ethics counseling than interpretation of results at all. This person was not a very helpful consultant, but a layer of bureaucracy. I would have loved someone to help me interpret results. In my case it was someone who I said “I want this exact test on this exact gene.” And they said “Are you sure, if you know here’s what it can mean.” And I said “Yes” so the lab ran the test and gave me my results.
- jryan49 8y agoAt least there are a million disclaimers, specifically saying if you have depression or anxiety disorder or hypochondria to not enable the health checks.
- adventured 8y agoThe concerning prospect, which seems inevitable, is that the government gets heavily involved (after the nth scare story), regulates the hell out of the sector, and then I'm paying $5,000 for a service that used to cost $99. That is, after - if - I get permission and approval through my insurance provider, and after I give a doctor $500 before and after each test. Then I'll be reading articles about how expensive simple genetic services are in America and nobody can figure out why. Then more laws will be proposed to fix the problem, for something must be done about the gouging fees charged by genetic services providers.
- labster 8y agoYou sound like another happy Theranos customer. The US managed to hit the sweet spot of enough regulation to raise prices over developing countries, but not enough regulation to limit prices like developed countries.
- Spooky23 8y agoThat’s just lawsuit defense. People do that when they know customers will hurt themselves. Curiosity killed the cat.
- village-idiot 8y agoAnd bad for the consumer even if they’re right. How are you supposed to plan for or cope with the knowledge that you’re going to lose your mind in 15 years?
- geomark 8y agoI definitely think there is some planning you could and should do.
- flerchin 8y agoWhat? Coping is personal, but planning would be critical. Long Term Disability Insurance is totally a thing. One would probably make different reproductive decisions among other choices. The entire argument against knowing seems to be that it might hurt your feelings.
- jfk13 8y agoHow much is Long Term Disability Insurance likely to cost if you have been tested and shown to have a particularly high risk of developing a long-term disability? Oh, you wouldn't tell the insurer? That'll probably be grounds for invalidating the policy, if and when it ever comes to light. The more we are able to know about the likelihood of future medical issues on an individual level, the more dysfunctional the "insurance" model will become.
- village-idiot 8y agoNo, it’s that it’ll fill your life with dread without giving you the power to do anything about it. Yeah, you can do some piddly stuff around the edges, but no action you can take will prevent you from suffering one of the worst diseases we know about. It’s a bit like being put onto death row. Also, feelings matter. So “it’ll just hurt your feelings” is dismissive claptrap.