11 ms·
Google's shutdown of products and APIs seems to have led to critical level of trust loss amongst developers and influencers. It's time for Google to either fix
by andrewstuart 8y ago
Google's shutdown of products and APIs seems to have led to critical level of trust loss amongst developers and influencers.
It's time for Google to either fix this or get out of providing services and APIs to developers.
Google doesn't seem to put any weight at all on the outcry every time its shutters another service/API.
The trust must be restored.
Google doesn't seem to understand that when they shut service X, that their (potential) customers for service Y (such as Google Compute Engine) become concerned that service Y will be shut down too.
To put a positive suggestion forward, Google could consider giving all services a "sunset guarantee".
A "sunset guarantee" is a commitment that the service will be shut down only with a minimum notice period of say for example 5 years.
- smt88 8y agoMy company switched from AWS to Azure without considering Google's Cloud at all, and the loss of trust is the reason.
- fartcannon 8y agoOut of the fire and into the flames with choices like that though, eh.
- mdtusz 8y agoBest of luck. I've found azure far more difficult to manage even simple things with than on AWS. Even spinning up a single simple development server feels far more complicated.
- praneshp 8y agoDid you consider Google cloud, and reject it because you don;t trust Google? that's different from not considering gcp at all :)
- ldiracdelta 8y agoWith respect to googlers, I 100% do not even consider google solutions because I have so little trust that what I do on whatever platform they role out this week, however great it may be, will actually still work in one year.
- mr_toad 8y agoMicrosoft have done a few of their own u-turns on developers. The most recent that springs to mind is the ditching of ADO in favour of ODBC which pissed a lot of developers off. There are plenty of other examples.
- smt88 8y agoThey U-turned on devs, not on paying corporate clients (mostly).
- mbrumlow 8y agoShould have switched to bare metal, things like AWS cost a ton more than you realize, it just looks like a good deal because you have smaller cost up front. But in the long run managing your own systems at places like Softlayer can save you a bundle. EDIT: I don't care about downvotes, but if you are going to do it at least leave a comment of why you think I am wrong.
- mmt 8y ago> managing your own systems at places like Softlayer The problem is, at a place like SL, they're not actually your own systems. > can save you a bundle It can, and usually does provide at least some savings, but it still comes with both the obvious form of vendor lock-in, and a subtler disadvantage, which is that you're limited by SL's specific hardware and engineering (including network) choices. The real (performance and/or cost) magic of running ones own servers comes from custom combination of commodity ingredients, not merely lack of virtualization.
- mbrumlow 8y ago> The problem is, at a place like SL, they're not actually your own systems. You are right, I do prefer colo and EOL hardware for low budget operations. But SL is a step lower than AWS. SL still can give you a punch in the face. But the point I really want is bare metal more than anything. Also, if you need current gen stuff not owning can be nice because you won't have to repair when they break. > It can, and usually does provide at least some savings, but it still comes with both the obvious form of vendor lock-in, and a subtler disadvantage, which is that you're limited by SL's specific hardware and engineering (including network) choices. I advise you never to use vender provided features (that means avoiding AWS features along with depending on SL network topology (which is vlans, nothing special)). Anybody making a service today should be able to buy a server at any provider, or setup a colo anywhere and join those resources in and get advantage of those resources instantly. All without depending on stacks and software you have no control over.
- mmt 8y ago
- pratyushag2 8y agoBurn I wonder if that’s really a problem because in 3 years, if GOogle Cloud becomes a billion dollar company then most wont question its financial importance to Alphabet.
- tannhaeuser 8y agoBut that also means if it doesn't become profitable, it'll be shut down on short notice. Which is exactly the reason nobody is considering Google Cloud, and going to AWS and Azure instead. Google knows this (they're not stupid after all) and seems to be pulling out of kubernetes development recently.
- dankohn1 8y agoGoogle is not pulling out of Kubernetes development. Their contributions have stayed at a very high level and they remain the largest single contributor, although their % of all contributions has declined over time as many more companies have gotten involved. You may have gotten confused by this clickbait TechCrunch headline, which does not match the article content: https://techcrunch.com/2018/08/29/google-steps-back-from-running-the-kubernetes-infrastructure/amp/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/08/29/google-steps-back-from-run... Disclosure: I’m executive director of CNCF which hosts Kubernetes.
- tannhaeuser 8y agoThanks for clarification! The TechCrunch article might indeed be click-baity, but OTOH it seems credible to me Google wouldn't be maintaining k8s indefinitely when they've nothing to gain. I understood Google said as much when they were calling on other parties (presumably AWS, Azure) benefitting from k8s more than Google itself to engage in k8s development. Though I'm not sure Azure, and much less AWS, would have a business case for doing so.
- smt88 8y agoI'm worried about individual services being killed, not the entire Cloud business.
- eropple 8y ago> Google's shutdown of products and APIs seems to have led to critical level of trust loss amongst developers and influencers. Some companies have to care what developers think. (Few, to be frank; developers overestimate their importance.) Many companies have to care what "influencers" think. But not all, and Google is not part of that "most". Google doesn't have to give a shit because everyone uses Google. They are literally market-saturated at this point. They have no competition and the only material threat in the medium run is a powerful country with a salty antitrust division. And on your other point, the idea that a company like Google should care about the rounding error of people who care about some B2C thing like Reader shutting down (while many totally-fine alternatives exist) being so personally put out that that colors their analysis of B2B offerings is more than a little silly. If you decide on GCP based frustrations over Google Reader or Google Inbox, you probably aren't clear-headed enough to be making decisions for your company and it's probably a good thing that you are a rounding error besides. (I use some Google services; I don't use GCP for a variety of reasons completely unrelated to babyraging over a B2C shutdown.)
- GW150914 8y agoYou don’t need goodwill until you need it, and then it’s almost impossible to garner. How does that saying go? When you’re on top of the world you can do no wrong, when you’re down you can do no right? A lot of giant companies have to learn this the hard way, probably due to institutional inertia, apathy, lack of foresight, and the reality that today’s C-levels will probably be gone before that shit hits the fan.
- eropple 8y agoIf you are banking on B2C-related "goodwill" to save a company whose revenue model is basically all B2B, then you're already dead. Google fairly obviously is not doing that.
- GW150914 8y agoOnce upon a time similar things have been said about other giants who fell upon hard times, or died, or had to become shells of their former selves. It’s not like Google has made good friends with the business world either. Besides, the core of their business is advertisements, and they should probably pay attention to the slow, but inexorable backlash against advertising. Given that only a minority block ads and protect their privacy today, it may seem like that’s a silly thing to say, it history suggests otherwise. A bit of goodwill earned while on top can make inevitable slides down the mountain less fatal.
- Aeolun 8y agoI don’t know, they lost me with this one. They were on their initiation to join the ranks of the evil the last few years, but they’ve really stepped up their game this year and become a full fledged member. I used to be a 100% Google products user, but my faith that it is fundamentally a good and ethical company has been systematically destroyed in the past years.
- istjohn 8y agoYep. I'm getting off the Google train.
- iamdave 8y agoTo put a positive suggestion forward, Google could consider giving all services a "sunset guarantee I'd honestly even settle with something like a program where users can choose to enroll in these programs in some sort of test phase. Maybe put some kind of marker in the name or even on the logo that clearly informs and denotes "this product might not last long, it might go into production, it may die after 3 years, you have been warned". There's a word for this but for some reason it eludes me (and apparently eludes google as well). At least it'd soften the blow when they inevitably roll things up on one of these so designated services.
- tajen 8y agoGmail itself was in beta, until recently. Everything was in beta.
- ant6n 8y agowasn't gmail in beta for like 5 years?
- jsjohnst 8y ago> There's a word for this but for some reason it eludes me (and apparently eludes google as well). Beta? Developer Preview? Google (mis)uses both already. Heck Gmail was in Beta for years (5? Not sure, but that seems the right ballpark).
- _match 8y agoThis is nonsense. Gmail is free. Inbox was free. Google Search is free. You can launch a profitable business on Google Cloud or Firebase in the free tier. They built Kubernetes and Go, for free, and it's very easy to port your Cloud infrastructure anywhere. You can translate text to any language, for free. What exactly do they owe you? Not enough people were using Inbox. It was an experiment and now they're moving on.
- manquer 8y agoGsuite also had inbox and Gmail and they are not free. Users who pay for those care. Next time I have to make a choice on Google product, most likely will reject it coz I can't really on them to either maintain it or give actual human support either MS is probably supporting XP in the embedded world. If you are not selling to consumers you have to be prepared to do that
- aembleton 8y agoOnly if the administrator has allowed Inbox. Mine doesn't. Maybe most of them don't and so keeping it alive can't be justified.
- manquer 8y agoThat's the difference between with MS and Google(i.e. enterprise and consumer), it doesn't matter how small the user base is, once a feature/product is GA to paying customers, you maintain it for a reasonable amount of time (>>> 1 year ) If you are not sure whether it will have usage/ interest, do your research , but once you go GA stick to it. Even if you are maintaining it for one customer, it shows the commitment you are showing to your customer , builds a lot of confidence on the vendor - Google doesn't get mine today. * I meant the SLA for notice of deprecation not the lifetime of the product
- nicodjimenez 8y agoYou're right they owe you nothing, but that goes both ways! When companies launch experiments and features that people actually like and then take them away, they piss some people off. The bad PR they are getting from this means they didn't make it clear they were going to discontinue the service in 2020 (or something like that) and make it super easy to transition. It's pretty weird they wouldn't just keep their Inbox service up and running and minimize maintenance costs. Seems to suggest they want to make big changes to the underlying data storage and don't want to worry about backward compatibility.
- thebooglebooski 8y ago"The trust must be restored." Playing devil's advocate, what happens when the trust doesn't become restored? The company loses ad revenue? Developers flee in mass droves to...Yahoo and Microsoft? Look what happened when people "lost trust" in Facebook. Shares are down 4% relative to a year ago. Is the company permanently crippled? Are people revolting and moving to alternate forms of social media? Fewer of the people immediately connected to your local graph are probably using Facebook. But that local loss of users gets completely offset by the new users they grow internationally. Ultimately, these companies are beholden to their boards and shareholders. Unless Inbox users clicked enough ads to make a dent in revenue, the organization has every reason to deprioritze competing products, and continue down the path of creating free A/B tests, and then merging the winner into a hybrid/better product. Take a look at Fuchsia. Or Dart and Flutter. Or Hangouts and Talk. An easy heuristic here might be, "Lose trust in the few in order to benefit the many." It sounds really sad, but it is the reality numerous companies live by.
- 3pt14159 8y agoEh. I just refuse to work on stuff involving Google APIs unless I really have no other choice. It's not as annoying to set up as, say AWS, but it's much less predictable. Not worth it. A focused alternative is usually more responsive. Though sometimes they get acquired so there really is no winning.
- throwaway2048 8y agoThere are plenty of signs facebook proper is in trouble
- ladzoppelin 8y agoFacebook is in trouble man, I am amazed the outcry of general public. Its all circumstantial evidence but the amount of people in my circle who are talking about leaving, creating fake profiles and getting their kids pictures of the platform is profound. Edit: IMO.
- O_H_E 8y agoThe problem is that all HN reader's outer circles would never constitute 1% of Facebook's user base
- yourbandsucks 8y agoGoogle doesn't care about the opinion of outsiders. It's one of the primary features of their culture.
- ryanobjc 8y agoThere is already a sunset guarantee for GCP: https://cloud.google.com/terms/ https://cloud.google.com/terms/ Section 7: 7.2 Deprecation Policy. Google will announce if it intends to discontinue or make backwards incompatible changes to the Services specified at the URL in the next sentence. Google will use commercially reasonable efforts to continue to operate those Services versions and features identified at https://cloud.google.com/terms/deprecation https://cloud.google.com/terms/deprecation without these changes for at least one year after that announcement, unless (as Google determines in its reasonable good faith judgment): (i) required by law or third party relationship (including if there is a change in applicable law or relationship), or (ii) doing so could create a security risk or substantial economic or material technical burden.
- MichaelMoser123 8y agoI think the corporate culture of Google does not allow for continued support of 'non core' projects. It's so much cooler to work on new stuff, supporting a chrome plugging that was written eight years ago probably doesn't get you anywhere within Google. Also they don't have any feedback / bug report channels - these are also important if you plan to support your own stuff (I know you can monitor a lot but it's still not the same level of customer support)
- deminature 8y agoIf the product was a paid service, there would be a better case to be made for guarantees. Given no money is changing hands and Google is providing a world class service for nothing, I'm not sure users have any right to make demands about minimum notice periods.
- UncleMeat 8y agoThis is bizarre to me. Pivoting is seen as a tremendously good thing in the startup community. If you have a product that isn't working and isn't getting users, you do something different or your company dies. You simply cannot keep throwing developer time at such a product. Google has a lot more money than a startup and can afford to waste developer time, but it still isn't good. "We tried this thing out and it didn't get a lot of users" is an absolutely reasonable argument for killing a product. Google just gets known for killing products because they are so big and therefore start so many new products.
- coldtea 8y ago>This is bizarre to me. Pivoting is seen as a tremendously good thing in the startup community. What's good for the startup community is not the same for the entrenched behemoth community. >. If you have a product that isn't working and isn't getting users, you do something different or your company dies. You simply cannot keep throwing developer time at such a product. Google however can. But instead of developing their product further, they announce it as the next thing, get millions of users, and then forget about it, don't update it, don't promote it anymore, and eventually close it pissing off all those users and failing to attract more users due to their own inaction. (See the ex-googler's comment above about how this process goes).
- llampx 8y agoNobody misses products that aren't working, or that aren't satisfying anyone's needs. In the very article you are commenting on, the author says "Good riddance" to the Chrome extension that has been superceded by Gmail's offline capability. Killing a thriving service is not the same as pulling the plug on one that no one uses.
- ldiracdelta 8y agoMicrosoft and Intel _worship_ backwards compatibility and the result is that I actually do trust them to not nuke api's on a whim. I can build a product on MS or Intel and it will work for a long time. Google does not care about developers if it nukes api's.
- twblalock 8y agoI've worked with Google APIs before and I was frustrated by the poor support and the breaking changes, but I didn't have a choice. Lack of integration with Google services would have been a major weak point for our product. The bottom line is that Google is so big and important that other companies just have to put up with Google's behavior. Until that changes there won't be a migration away from Google's APIs.
- jaimex2 8y agoYup, I use scrapers instead of the official APIs for any data from Google these days. It's works out better in the long run and you can do whatever you like.