9 ms·
I really don't understand this meme. Most of the non-Anglosphere developed world has free or very low-cost education. Typically they aren't full-inclusive luxur
by keiferski 8y ago
I really don't understand this meme. Most of the non-Anglosphere developed world has free or very low-cost education. Typically they aren't full-inclusive luxury resorts like colleges in the U.S., but they do provide good educations for 95% of the population.
The idea that the U.S., the single wealthiest country in the history of civilization, "can't afford" to make college affordable is just plain wrong. In fact, it was affordable until just a few decades ago. The only reason it isn't affordable now is because the profit motive has been introduced into a space where it doesn't belong.
- Swizec 8y agoImagine how much college you could pay for if you curbed your half trillion dollar budget just a bit. But say that and people get upset.
- outime 8y agoAnd in fact, in many of these countries, private (paid) universities have quite bad popularity - it’s where people who can’t pass in the “free” one go, with very few exceptions. I mean, there are so many examples of fully or almost fully covered tuition around the world that it makes me wonder how such meme is still alive.
- mszcz 8y agoI get the same feeling here in Poland. I attended a "free" university and one time I got to talking with one of the professors teaching AI about other schools, private colleges in particular. She said that she does a few classes there and the level is way lower than at the "free" university. She shared a felling she had that since the people there pay for the classes they expect the teachers to magically make the knowledge and skills appear in their heads instead of putting in the work themselves. The sentiment of paying for admission because you couldn't get in on merit alone was shared among a sizeable amount of my colleagues and other professors.
- mcguire 8y agoWhat are the requirements to attend a public, "free" university in Poland? Or, what percent of applicants are accepted?
- mszcz 8y agoThe percentages depend heavily on the specific university and on what you want to study. How this works is that you have a set number of spots. Each person that applies for a spot gets points for high school grades, additional achivements, social conditions (I think), etc. Everyone gets sorted by points. If there's 100 spots, top 100 applicants, point-wise, get in.
- firic 8y agoA big issue is that in America almost everyone wants to study in college even if they want to study a master's in gender studies and later work in Starbucks. In most countries with free colleges (at least the ones that I know), it is free because not enough people want to study in colleges, and the ones who do want to study, for the most part, have a realistic plan on how to get a career based on the degree.
- kasperni 8y agoDo you have anything to back this up with. I have a _very_ hard time believing that american youth is so different from the youth in the rest of the world. Also, it is not free because not enough people wants to go to college. In Denmark, for example, we have educations where 95% of applicants are rejected.
- imgabe 8y agoSee, that would imply it's not free for everyone. It's free for 5% of people who are able to get in. What happens to the people who don't qualify?
- tormeh 8y agoThey go to a less prestigious institution.
- rixrax 8y agoWhy should it be available for everyone? Why should a person that doesn't pass equal opportunity entrance exam be allowed to study to become a lawyer or civil engineer or a medical doctor for free/on tax payers money? Call it accountability maybe? And for those who don't qualify for particular masters program, well I guess they will either try harder next time over, or face the music and look for some other areas where they might be a better fit.
- imgabe 8y agoThey shouldn't. But then one also shouldn't claim "We value education so much that we pay for everyone to go to college" when in fact only 5% of people go. It's misleading. I bet you could find approximately 5% of people in the US who are able to qualify for full scholarships.
- fzeroracer 8y agoThe US is only allowed to export ideas to the rest of the world. Because we're the best country on Earth and everyone should follow our example. The moment you dare suggest we follow the example of other countries you get a lot of handwringing about how the US just isn't like those other countries and it would never work here. Maybe if we privatize college more eventually it'll work better, don't worry about all those millions of people deep in debt.
- imgabe 8y agoWhat percentage of the population is able to take advantage of the free college? What are the job prospects like for those who don't go to college?
- estomagordo 8y agoI can examplify with Sweden, which I know, where 43% of people aged 25-64 has "some" amount of higher education, and 27% has at least 3 years of higher education. But way more than this are "able to", as you put it. In order to be eligble, one needs passing grades in a high percentage of high school subjects, including some mandatory ones. But failing that, one can always study for that credit later in life.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> I can examplify with Sweden, which I know, where 43% of people aged 25-64 has "some" amount of higher education, and 27% has at least 3 years of higher education. Just for contrast, that's much lower than the US, where 44% of the population has completed an undergraduate degree equivalent. And as pointed out by others in this thread, Sweden (like other European countries) does not have a great track record when it comes to ensuring equality for people of different racial and ethnic backgrounds. Yes, in theory, these programs might be available to everyone, but when stratification occurs in the education system from a very young age, it makes for much larger differences down the line.
- throwawayjava 8y agoTaking Germany as the example I know about. > What percentage of the population is able to take advantage of the free college? About 30%. Note that this is roughly the same as the percentage of Americans with a college degree. So it's not some crazy cut-throat system and is not a lottery. Basically, people who know they want to go to college, plan ahead, and apply themselves, can mostly do so. People who want the opportunity sometimes don't get it, but that's true everywhere. And there are a ton of stories of people moving from the non-university track into the university track even later in life. So there's a lot of mobility if you apply yourself. > What are the job prospects like for those who don't go to college? See the example OECD dataset here for "upper secondary; non-tertiary": https://data.oecd.org/unemp/unemployment-rates-by-education-level.htm https://data.oecd.org/unemp/unemployment-rates-by-education-... tl;dr: quite good. Better than or comparable to the US.
- swebs 8y agoPlease read the article and not just the title. It is not stating that tax funded college is infeasible. It is describing gotchas of various state's subsidy programs.
- keiferski 8y agoI did read the article, thanks. HN comments do not, and have never been, solely limited to the exact topic highlighted in the article. Indeed, some of the best comments in the history of this site were tangentially-related to the link.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoThere are certainly downsides to those programs that progressives in the US would hate, though. For example, in Germany, part of why it works is that they have a fairly strict "tracked" system post-elementary school that's kind of classist, that makes gaining admittance harder. Plus they don't really 'support' students in terms of counseling or special programs or anything the way US universities do; it's expected that you're an adult, and if you can't hack it, you're out. In practice, lack of support means students who come from more affluent, educated backgrounds have a large advantage over first-generation college students.
- fifnir 8y ago> In practice, lack of support means students who come from more affluent, educated backgrounds have a large advantage over first-generation college students. I'm pretty sure poor students would prefer no support and no debt over a bit of support for huge debt.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoSome would. But if you come out of it with no degree because of a lack of support, "at least it was free for you to get nothing" may be cold comfort.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoWell, it's still better than having gone into debt to not get a degree. The support is only worth the money if it was the difference between you making it and not making it. That will be true for some people. Others won't make it even with the support. For them, "support but expensive" is worse than "no support but free".
- Arnt 8y agoThey do incur debt. Or work part time, or both, because they have to live while studying. What's this support that German students don't get?
- Dylan16807 8y agoI feel like a 'luxury resort' could take that 130 square foot dorm bedroom and put fewer than four people into it.
- Junk_Collector 8y agoWell, part of it is just the sheer scale of US education institutions. If we define University students as everyone enrolled and seeking a Bachelor's or higher then the number of University students in the US is greater than the total number University students in all of Europe. Also about 70% of high school graduates in the US go on to at least attempt a Bachelor's according to the NCES where as in Germany, for instance, only about 30% do. Germany has the highest number of University students of any EU member nation. On top of all this, a typical American university education is more expensive than its European counterpart. So to start providing this education at no personal cost we would have to come up with a rather large sum of money that is not currently being allocated. Roughly on par with the total educational costs of Europe. What do you cut or where do you raise taxes to make that allotment? It would be a huge readjustment.