7 ms·
If I buy a game from Steam then contractually that is a rental, but it behaves like a purchase. I can install it anywhere I like, I can back it up to a physical
by wongarsu 8y ago
If I buy a game from Steam then contractually that is a rental, but it behaves like a purchase. I can install it anywhere I like, I can back it up to a physical disk, and most importantly I can redownload it in perpetuity; even if the same item is no longer for sale on Steam.
The only risk in comparison to a physical copy is that Valve fundamentally changes or goes bankrupt. Both seem unlikely. This makes any purchase on Steam basically as safe as a physical purchase, resulting in Steam basically replacing physical game purchases on the PC.
- afandian 8y agoI don't know anything about Valve. But if I cancel my Amazon account, I doubt that I would be able to keep all the books I bought.
- androidgirl 8y agoAs an aside, some games on Steam are DRM free and/or can be run without steam. Stardew Valley and Kerbal Space Program spring to mind. There is also GOG, which sells DRM-free games. I just keep backups of my games on my NAS.
- plussed_reader 8y agoHow often do you replace the NAS?
- kipchak 8y agoA concern I've heard brought up is if games are no longer supported on a new version of Windows, but steam and steamworks DRM is no longer able to run on an old version of Windows that the game is compatible with. Sometimes games like this are removed from the Steam store, like World in Conflict, and can be made to work with some tweaking. But for a decent number of people that can be a problem, and there's no guarantee that will always be possible. To be fair this is dependent on the specific DRM type, if the game receives any kind of fan/official updates to solve the issue, and there's not exactly an easy way out for Valve. Plus games that have to phone in to a central server to work are going to be more of an issue anyway so by comparison Steamworks DRM is doing pretty well.
- patmcguire 8y agoOr you file a chargeback, or someone playing on your account uses an aimbot, or anything else that attracts their unilateral ire.
- eslaught 8y agoOr they delete your account. I'm not sure about Steam, but there are plenty of horror stories on the internet about "bought X on Y platform and then Y revoked account". The majority of users may never experience this, but the fact is that when you use a service like this you're at the mercy of the service provider, even for basic things like maintaining access to your account. What I'd like to see is some sort of movement towards "if it looks like a purchase, then it is a purchase". That is, if I pay a one-time up-front free for access to something (even with DRM), we should pass legislation to make it behave like a purchase and limit the shenanigans that providers can pull. (Granted this is a very ill-formed idea and there are lots of details to work out in order to implement it.)
- Analemma_ 8y ago> I'm not sure about Steam, but there are plenty of horror stories on the internet about "bought X on Y platform and then Y revoked account". The worst part about this is that it often happens when consumers exercise their legitimate rights to e.g. chargebacks. And yes, Steam does it too: if you chargeback a Steam purchase, even a fraudulent one where the CC company sides with you after the investigation, usually this will result in your account getting locked and held hostage until you undo the chargeback and eat the cost.
- felix_nagaand 8y agoThat's when it's time to sue.
- Analemma_ 8y agoThe Steam user agreement includes a binding arbitration clause preventing you from suing: https://store.steampowered.com/subscriber_agreement/#11 https://store.steampowered.com/subscriber_agreement/#11. There is no escape.
- olzd 8y agoActually there is: be a EU resident. It's even explicitely stated there.
- slezyr 8y agoSteam can lock your games too. https://www.reddit.com/r/Steam/comments/3fsms1/psa_how_the_steam_region_lock_works/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Steam/comments/3fsms1/psa_how_the_s...
- diffeomorphism 8y ago> The only risk in comparison to a physical copy is that Valve fundamentally changes or goes bankrupt Or that somebody phishes your login data or that your account is banned for some reason or that the drm servers for a game you bought are now offline (you still have the installer, but can't use it anymore)... . I also like steam, but it is still very much "all eggs in one basket" and while some of the games on there are drm-free many aren't. gog.com is better in that regard.
- komali2 8y ago>back it up to a physical disk Really? How? It still needs the steam client to run, yea?
- craftyguy 8y ago> This makes any purchase on Steam basically as safe as a physical purchase, resulting in Steam basically replacing physical game purchases on the PC. Not entirely, since there's still some dependency on their client to put the game in 'offline mode', which requires phoning home to Valve. A better example would be gog.com, which gives you the game binary/installer to download and no requirements for phoning home or any other shenanigans for being able to install/play it.
- thirdsun 8y agoIt's my understanding that the DRM and phoning home is completely optional and up to the developer. Steam is happy to deliver your games DRM-free and without any dependency on their client if the developer/publsiher chooses to do so.
- Lorkki 8y agoThey don't really advertise it, but there's no requirement to use DRM on Steam: http://steam.wikia.com/wiki/List_of_DRM-free_games http://steam.wikia.com/wiki/List_of_DRM-free_games
- always_good 8y agoI found out the hard way that you can't play a single Steam game if you haven't connected it to the internet in 30 days. Nothing clarifies the difference between purchase and rental when you try booting Steam up on a laptop for a 12 hour bus ride across Mexico and you can't play a single game. You just have this "meh, hasn't affected me" mindset.
- gspetr 8y agoWouldn't adjusting the system's clock circumvent this? I do agree with your point that this is a bad thing in the first place.
- xg15 8y agoI might be wrong, but don't modern TPMs have their own internal clocks to prevent exactly this?
- always_good 8y agoThat's the first thing I tried but it didn't work. Maybe it would've worked before I booted Steam in the first place, but you'd think Steam would've coded around that obvious circumvention.
- mcguire 8y agohttps://www.makeuseof.com/tag/im-longer-buying-games-steam-opinion/ https://www.makeuseof.com/tag/im-longer-buying-games-steam-o...
- xg15 8y agoYes, and those rentals-that-feel-like-purchases seem to be increasingly how new products and services are distributed whenever the providers can get away with it. You don't just see them with games, but also with movies (as described), music, e-books and, more recently, software suites, IoT devices and cars(!). Which makes sense: For the involved businesses there are enormous upsides to this kind of deal: Instead of giving your product out of hand, you enter a long-term relationship with the consumer, you get the money and remain in full control over the product, you can define in unprecedented detail how your customers are permitted to use the product, you can use that control as leverage in contracts with other businesses, etc, etc. Consumers usually don't mind because, indeed, it feels like you own the product. Until stuff like the OP happens and they realize it was a lie.