4 ms·
Generally speaking, ad networks don't sell personal data. That's their secret sauce - selling it is largely counterproductive. I can't call up Yahoo, and ask to
by vkou 8y ago
Generally speaking, ad networks don't sell personal data. That's their secret sauce - selling it is largely counterproductive. I can't call up Yahoo, and ask to buy the personal data of "forapurpose". If I could, it would take me a few million dollars to build a clone of their most valuable asset - their user database.
What they sell is ad spots in webpages, when those webpages are visited by people who satisfy some demographic matrix. The data itself, generally, does not get sold.
- forapurpose 8y agoThanks. How does that apply in this case? Does GDPR allow the collection but ban the selling of data? Also, per the article, the complaint claims that the collected information is shared with many other companies. How does that square with what you are saying? Are they sharing it with partners but not selling it to them? Does that make a difference under GDPR?
- kasey_junk 8y agoThe OpenRTB spec does contain data that many assume will be found to be personal under GDPR. The IAB is an industry group for people that use OpenRTB. They have built a standard on how to gather and transmit the GDPR consent requirements from publisher through the OpenRTB ecosystem. You can find it at http://advertisingconsent.eu/ http://advertisingconsent.eu/
- idunno2468 8y agoUsed to be in adtech- google didn’t provide these things to us. Maybe there were other products we could have purchased, but google just gave us a userid and all the tracking was done on our side. There are definitely third parties we could buy this data from. I left pre gdpr but my vague understanding is google has nothing to worry about in rtb but the adtech companies are at fault here if anyone. Especially if you consider the amount of lawyers google pays vs brave
- pacala 8y agoWhile it is technically correct that ad networks don't sell personal data, it is also irrelevant. It's not the bits that matter, it's what one does informed by the bits. Ad networks sell _actionable insights_ informed by personal data. An ad network answers the question 'what is the best way to spend $$$ and win this election' _using_ personal data of millions of people, but not _revealing_ the personal data to the paying customer. The paying customer is highly unlikely to have the technical acumen to turn personal data into actionable insights anyways, service readily provided by the ad network. The fact that personal data was not revealed is irrelevant, the end effect was bought by anyways. The evil is in collecting personal data to begin with, not in the technical manner it is used against the people it belongs to.
- fixermark 8y agoWe're going off into the weeds of philosophy, but... Do you mean it's evil to collect the personal data for the purpose of selling ad impressions of it's evil to collect personal data, full-stop? I want companies like Google collecting my personal data to, for example, provide me context-relevant search and map navigation results and voice-assistant actions. So it doesn't seem like evil-full-stop passes the smell test.
- Nasrudith 8y agoWhile there is some evil involved with targetted advertising there is a significant difference between that and direct data selling. The latter would be way worse. One tries to sell you weird stuff after you look up the infamous giant barrel of lube after hearing about all of the joke reviews. The other gives the lines of an honest man to hang you with to anyone willing to pay and spin you as a colossal pervert. It is why video rentals were protected information. That and the sublime trolling of reading Robert Bork's video rentals into official record after he stated there was no constitutional right to privacy.
- pacala 8y agoFair enough. N:M surveillance is worse than N:1 surveillance from a personal perspective. Though unclear if that also holds at scale. They are still both evil and much worse than no surveillance.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoThe trackers that generate analytics data for the ad networks do sell personal data and it is made available to anyone who wants to pay.