11 ms·
I'm a javascript developer, and I agree heavily with this article. The web experience has gotten worse these past few years. I don't want a stupid autoplaying
by vorpalhex 8y ago
I'm a javascript developer, and I agree heavily with this article.
The web experience has gotten worse these past few years. I don't want a stupid autoplaying video following me around on the damned page. I don't want Facebook to track me endlessly and mastermind what I see.
There are some really cool things the web has gained. WebRTC, ubiquitous web previews, and using mp4s to add cheap animation. I'm also glad Flash has finally been killed off.
We should be focusing on providing well crafted, clean and slim experiences that are thoughtful and not bloated. Get rid of the 10+ trackers, the kitchen sink approaches, and all the cruft that isn't directly useful. At the same time, let's maybe not have a single entity own this slimmed down platform (AMP), but have it be the normal experience.
- mynameishere 8y agoThere are some really cool things the web has gained I'd like to here about these things, if any. I'll generously assume you aren't seriously referring to "web previews" or animations. I'm also glad Flash has finally been killed off No, that's an absolute tragedy. Some of the youngsters here might not be aware, but there was a time when 99 percent of the garbage in a website could be turned off with a single blocker, all without impacting anything necessary.
- jiveturkey 8y agoyep. wishing Flash to be gone is misguided.
- steve_adams_86 8y agoI liked flash too, but it being owned by Adobe killed it. If it was open, I'd be a lot more sad about it dying.
- briandear 8y agoIt wouldn’t have died if it were open. It would have been improved and more secure.
- goshx 8y agoAsk anyone who've lived in the world of java applets how the rise of flash was awesome at the time. It was great for a lot of things, but unfortunately, like many things in life (javascript?), people abused it.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> 99 percent of the garbage in a website could be turned off with a single blocker, all without impacting anything necessary I was there and I remember no such thing. On the contrary, I remember people building whole sites in Flash. Killing that off is a Good Thing. I think the problem with the web is too much freedom given by tools for free, which leads to such maddening abuse as Flash was in the past, and modern web development is today. Publishers have too much capability, and too much control over the rendering of content.
- Chlorus 8y agoDon't forget our good friends ActiveX , ShockWave(whose relationship to Flash I've never been able to determine), and RealPlayer, which had an uncanny ability to be required for every online class assignment I ever had. If you were hapless enough to be running a Linux desktop, as I was, then have fun! The modern JavaScript experience might be a bloated disaster, but at least it's a cross-platform disaster.
- brightball 8y agoI had forgotten about real player. It was so awful...
- hnzix 8y agoShockwave was the player for content packaged for web from Macromedia Director, a product focused on creating multimedia binaries, often distributed on CD. Shockwave had much more powerful video and 3D rendering capabilities than Flash, but Director arguably died after Macromedia failed to deliver a timely OSX port.
- hnzix 8y ago> I remember people building whole sites in Flash. Like some kind of Single Page App that takes forever to download, breaks the back button and has obfuscated source code? Lucky we're past that phase!
- TeMPOraL 8y ago
- pcwalton 8y ago> No, that's an absolute tragedy. Some of the youngsters here might not be aware, but there was a time when 99 percent of the garbage in a website could be turned off with a single blocker, all without impacting anything necessary. Some of the youngsters here might not be aware, but there was a time when sites could reliably send raw TCP and UDP through a popular plugin that implemented a different, and weaker, version of the same-origin policy than the browser did. (For example, in earlier versions of Flash, any video could send anything to any port > 1024 on its hosting server!)
- sdegutis 8y agoWell designed software focused on user happiness doesn't make money. All those things that we hate, they are put in there because they make money.
- twtw 8y ago> Software was never about making users happy, it was about tricking users, manipulating them into giving you either their money or their time Calm down a bit with your generalities. If you sell the software (or the platform it runs on), there is no manipulation or trickery involved. It's only the "vast majority" if you look at freeware/ad-based.
- sdegutis 8y agoYou're right. I deleted that part of my comment. It was more ranty than I prefer to be. And I had things like Google and Facebook in mind, and 99% of the free games on the App Store or web.
- onli 8y agoOne example in the article is code.gov, the video is impressive, the loading time on the Android Go device abysmal. And this has nothing to do with earning money. It is just bad software.
- sdegutis 8y agoActually come to think of it, I've made some open source apps that people asked if they could donate to, because they were so excited by the possibilities my apps created, and by the convenience they now had because of them. I created a Patreon for this but have yet to link to it anywhere because I keep sinking into cynicism from all the ways I haven't been able to make money. But that's not the attitude I had when I created my window managers. Software that focuses on user-happiness can make money through donations. Just, probably not a full-time income. EDIT: Apparently that's not true, you can make a full time income. Godot makes $10k per month in donations. And a month ago it was $8k. Wow.
- 8y ago
- dunpeal 8y ago> I don't want a stupid autoplaying video following me around on the damned page. I don't want Facebook to track me endlessly and mastermind what I see. Those autoplaying videos and trackers are the reason these pages are there in the first place. All the free content and services on the web has to be paid for somehow, and that is the way. It's not as simple as: > Get rid of the 10+ trackers Sites like Facebook can't just do that, that's how they make money and stay in business. This is a business-model problem, not a technical problem. If anything, new technology allowed these business models to be slightly less annoying and damaging to the user experience.
- drb91 8y agoThis is an easy argument to make when there's conveniently no way for consumers to decide how they want to pay. Realistically, humans are just lazy about finding decent ways of monetizing their time. I can't say I'll shed any tears if a business relying on ads goes out of business from my ad blocker: they always could have asked me for my cash.
- buboard 8y agoi would like to see stats on that. in my experience people are very hesitant to pay even if they recognize they derive value from your service. it's just not the "thing that everyone does"
- Izkata 8y agoIMO this has already been proven to work as long as it's easy to pay. Just think of all the successful phone apps where the paid version is there to remove ads.
- dunpeal 8y ago> This is an easy argument to make For the record, I'm not making any value judgement or "argument" here. I'm pointing out that GP's complaining about issues that aren't really technical, but fundamental business practices.
- prostoalex 8y ago
- guelo 8y ago> I'm also glad Flash has finally been killed off. I actually think JavaScript video has been worse for users. Flash was easily blockable and worked fine for the majority of users. It was developers and Apple's need for control that killed off Flash.
- fouc 8y agoFlash was a battery hog. HTML5 video is less so.
- mikekchar 8y agoThe web is designed by marketing people and implemented by programmers. That's because the incentive to fund the implementation comes from the desire to sell things. One of the things that I always found interesting about the web was that as soon as there was a graphical browser, things went in that direction pretty quickly. Before that, our internet experiences were pretty technical in nature. More than the web, I remember being blown away by mail and news readers, like nn or gnus. The things we built were very practical in nature. Contrast that to the demo scene. To me, the demo scene epitomises the marriage of technical expertise and artistic endeavour. Talk about "well crafted, clean and slim experiences that are thoughtful and not bloated". Take all that and crank it up to 11 :-) Of course, not necessarily utilitarian. I'd love to see some artistically inclined people respin some of the concepts of the demo scene and build something practical that also has the ability to floor you from a technical and experience-oriented perspective. Of course, you could never fund it (that's why the marketers dominate the web), but the world of hacking has never needed funding. We're "starving artists" who aren't actually starving because we have high paying side gigs ;-).