5 ms·
Former hedge fund manager here. It's a good summary, but there's a big piece missing. Setup costs are higher now, a lot of it due to regulatory changes. One of
by lordnacho 8y ago
Former hedge fund manager here. It's a good summary, but there's a big piece missing. Setup costs are higher now, a lot of it due to regulatory changes. One of my contacts (and former customers) told me with recent European changes coming in, you need a good few hundred million bucks AUM to make it worthwhile.
A fair few potential founders would be able to find a few tens of millions from friends and family, but a lot fewer can find a hundred bucks. If you're backed by a big name this isn't a problem, hence you still get the occasional massive launch.
The part about the fees is also pretty important. 2/20 is from tales of yore. Any significant ticket will ask for a discount as well.
So it's just that much less attractive to launch.
- whatok 8y agoYeah, none of the MIFID compliance stuff is easy and it's to the point where you don't want European investors if you're an American entity.
- jason_slack 8y agoDo you have any sort of documentation about this (although I am in the USA)? I'm starting a mini hedge fund now with so much less money (under 6 figures) and perhaps I'm missing something?
- arthurcolle 8y agoIIRC Hedge fund has to be funded by accredited investors, and usually have significantly more capital than under <1mm, but I'd imagine you would want to co sult a securities/specialist legal counsel for a question on forming a fund
- jeletonskelly 8y agoYou might want to consider classification as a "Proprietary Trading Firm" instead of a hedge fund
- jason_slack 8y agoThis actually makes more sense, I am discovering. Thanks for bringing it up as I just sort of made up mini hedge fund as a term
- charlesdm 8y agoHow can you make money with a mini hedge fund? I've looked into setting up something, and at the minimum you'd need a few million (and that's even keeping everything super lean) for it to make sense money wise.
- jason_slack 8y agoWell, so far everything I am doing is 99% automated based upon my own tools, etc. Edit: Dr. Ernest Chan has written 3 really good books on Quantitative/Algorithmic trading. Essential reads.
- ColanR 8y agohave they been useful yet, or just sounded good?
- jason_slack 8y agoExtremely useful. Plus Dr Chan was helpful when I emailed him with a few questions about concepts in his books.
- ColanR 8y agoawesome.
- bizkitgto 8y agoWhat platform are you using for trading/algo?
- jason_slack 8y agoA few dideferent platforms. AlphaVantage, Interactive Brokers, other data platforms too.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Havoc 8y agoDepends on who's money your accepting really. Outside money = lots of red tape
- yellowstuff 8y agoMore anecdotal evidence in support of this: a friend of mine with a lot of experience in the finance industry looked into starting his own fund, and determined that you'd need $150mm and a full time compliance officer on day one for it to be practical. Another friend did start a fund with a few million under management, but essentially just to establish a track record so he could raise enough money to be worth it.
- charlesdm 8y agoI guess it depends on how serious you are? If you're just one person managing money, including a significant amount of your own wealth, then I guess you can do things relatively cheaply. If you want to grow big however, with a decent size investment team, the expenses all adds up quickly.
- whatok 8y agoInstitutional investors are not going to allocate capital to a team of one. You can outsource a decent amount of back office functions but you are still going to need to manage some things in house.
- charlesdm 8y agoYes, I am aware. But family offices will if you have proper relationships with them (essentially F&F money). You can raise small funds (i.e. $5 to $50m) from family offices. If you can take 20% of an annual 10% gain on $50m, that's a million a year -- pretty great lifestyle wise for a one person band.
- ecshafer 8y agoThose are horrible returns, that is borderline nearly unethical. You would have higher returns and pay less than 1% just putting it in the vanguard 500.
- 8y ago
- osrec 8y agoSetup costs aren't that much to be honest. Some prime brokerage depts at banks will even help you get started, often for an ongoing portion of your fund's management fee, so there isn't anything to pay at the start. They'll even handle compliance, monitoring and accounting for you. Generally, you can get your fund going for under a 100k GBP in London, providing you have the required regulatory capital (if you're going down the regulated route, that is). Hiring people, office etc etc gets expensive, but a lot of 'funds' we've helped set up are 1 or 2 man bands, working out of a co-working space with colo'd execution infrastructure in Equinix, based out in Slough.
- whatok 8y agoTalking about "colo'd execution" makes me think you are thinking of a particular strategy which the costs make sense for but not the rest of the majority.
- konschubert 8y ago> A fair few potential founders would be able to find a few tens of millions from friends and family, Rich kids
- alanmeaney 8y agoThere's data that disputes the couple of hundred million to break even story. Source: https://www.hedgeweek.com/2017/07/11/253832/emerging-hedge-fund-managers-are-profitable-below-usd100-million https://www.hedgeweek.com/2017/07/11/253832/emerging-hedge-f... “The key finding of the survey is that these managers can be profitable at a small size. One third of managers surveyed said they were profitable with less than USD50 million. We therefore dispute the claim that you need USD200 million or more to break even. We think there is tight evidence that you can do it at a lower AUM number,” asserts Capstick. Breaking it down by strategy, the survey found that global macro funds need the most assets to break even: USD132 million, followed by event-driven (USD108 million) and multi-strategy funds (USD98 million).
- whatok 8y agoNo one goes into this business to breakeven. I'm very doubtful that a majority of these smaller funds survive very long but really no great way of knowing. Macro funds until this year have just been sucking. Let's say you're getting 1/15 on 132mm and returned 10% (10 is generous given how a lot of these funds have performed) for the year. That's 1.32mm management fee and 1.98mm in incentive for 3.3mm total. That's really not a lot of money to go around to get startup hedge fund talent.
- princetontiger 8y agoI agree with you. I know plenty of smart friends who have left the industry. There's about ~9,000 hedge funds in the US, but I would personally avoid any fund with less than $1B+ in AUM unless you got several percentage points of the fund's profit generation or a chance to run a book. That takes the list down to maybe 600-750 hedge funds in the US that are worth working for... that list will probably get 50% smaller in the next couple years. A lot of people are down this year against the S&P 500 up 10% and the Nasdaq up 20%