4 ms·
Sending people to prison involves prosecuting people for breaking laws somehow, which isn’t easy. You can’t just send them to jail on a whim. Even if what they
by seanmcdirmid 8y ago
Sending people to prison involves prosecuting people for breaking laws somehow, which isn’t easy. You can’t just send them to jail on a whim. Even if what they did was wrong, unless there was a law against it the government didn’t really have many options here. They could make up some laws after the fact to prevent future abuse, but cannot make them retroactive.
- slivym 8y agoEven if you subscribe to the idea that there weren't correct laws in place to ensure that those who should have been criminally responsible, you then have to contend with the the corollary. Which is that instead of prosecuting those responsible, legislation should have been brought forward so that this couldn't happen legally in the future. That didn't even begin to happen- and it's not difficult to see how that has fundamentally poisoned the well in the US.
- bko 8y ago> legislation should have been brought forward so that this couldn't happen legally in the future What couldn't happen legally?
- Brockenstein 8y agoA repeat of 2008. The idea being that there wasn't sufficient laws in protections in place to prevent this sort of thing from happening again, or that people most directly involved can't just skate. Problem is though, even if laws were passed, once 2008 fades far enough into the past you'll get someone with a really bright idea, "Hey there's too much regulation stifling our economy. If we just got rid of all those pesky laws the free market would create a utopia!" Because every tom, dick and harry wants their chance to repeat history after the last tom, dick and harry have died.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoI’m all for that, and some new civil laws were introduced. Trump is busy trying to undo them ATM, but there we go. The problem criminal laws, however, is that they should be really well defined without being overly restricting. Being greedy can’t be made a crime; it has to be fraud, racketeering, or something obvious.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI think it's fairly safe to say, the conspiracy that created the collapse amounted to financial terrorism, and then (to fix things) extortion. We have the laws. What we lack if the will and the power to apply them. Economist had calculated a significant number of deaths (worldwide) resulted from the 2007 / 2008 crisis. I believe the number was approx 30,000 (but it may be higher). Editorial: If we don't have laws for such things then the elected should be shackled for their neglect and failure.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoFinancial terrorism isn’t even defined as a crime. It would have to racketeering or something, not easy things to prove even in gang/mob cases. Legislative neglect also isn’t a crime that lawmakers can be prosecuted under. You can, however, not vote for them during their reelection campaign. You can also vote for lawmakers that would bother to push for such laws. For better or worse, western countries are generally strong rule of law ones. If this was a country like China that practiced rule by law instead, I’m sure they could find something to throw them in jail on, but it isn’t.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoPerhaps. Not being snarky but how do you establish precedent if you don't try? In the context of justice, I find it troubling the (US) gov made no effort.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoYou can’t just go up to a grand jury and say: we don’t know what we can get them for, but I’m sure we will find something along the way. What does “effort” mean here? Even an investigation requires some kind of suspicion of foul play. They can’t just investigate someone because they are out to get them (well, at least they shouldn’t).
- umanwizard 8y ago> how do you establish precedent if you don't try It's unclear whether you know what "precedent" means in a legal context.
- howard941 8y agoCould have prosecuted and imprisoned for perjury dozens if not hundreds hundreds of people offering false affidavits claiming personal knowledge of loans they knew nothing about in support of foreclosures. You could have prosecuted and imprisoned all of MERS's officers for racketeering. The first happened in teensy numbers, the second, not at all. (copyedited)