13 ms·
CEO Says Launching Satellites Without FCC Permission Was a ‘Mistake’
- paulsutter 8y agoIs anyone familiar with space law? What are the specific rules? If they had used a ground station abroad would they still need FCC approval? EDIT: Thanks walrus01/mirashii for the EAR/ITAR points, very helpful
- robotmlg 8y agoAccording to the article, the FCC "regulates all satellite launches by American companies, whether they occur on U.S. soil or elsewhere."
- plopz 8y agoIs it the launch of the satellite or the operation afterwards in regards to communication back to earth that the FCC regulates?
- lbriner 8y agoThe article says they have power over all American companies so probably yes. If they were a foreign company with a satellite over the USA, that would be a more interesting question.
- rdlecler1 8y agoRedomicile to Cayman?
- Majestic121 8y agoUS laws tend to be very extraterritorial, for exemple any bank using dollar at any point in a transaction between two countries unrelated to the US are still bound by US laws. It might work if they get the whole company outside of the US, with no connexions left whatsoever, but then it will be harder to get VC money
- stcredzero 8y agoUS laws tend to be very extraterritorial That's been precisely the point of having the US Navy and the US Marines for well over 200 years!
- walrus01 8y agoIf you need to buy ITAR controlled items it doesn't really matter where you're incorporated, Cayman Islands, Isle of Man, Cyprus, whatever. With a supply of ITAR controlled satellite tech cut off you're unable to manufacture. There are purely european based ways of manufacturing satellite stuff but with everything ITAR-related taken off the table, the market choice of components/subassembles is drastically reduced.
- mirashii 8y agoMost components for commercial space have been reclassified to EAR from ITAR in the last few years, so this is not nearly the concern that it was in the past.
- richardcrossley 8y agoA British Overseas Territory. Pretty sure that would be outside the FCC's remit. http://www.gov.ky/portal/page/portal/cighome http://www.gov.ky/portal/page/portal/cighome
- philliphaydon 8y agoYeah cos still American company.
- taksintikk 8y agoSo incorporate outside America and focus on the trying to monetize your services abroad. This type of mesh network wouldn’t really be useful in America anyway.
- kodablah 8y ago> So incorporate outside America and focus on the trying to monetize your services abroad. Still, as evidenced by the statement of the supporters who put these on the Indian rocket, there are still many cross-nation gentlemen agreements about satellite placement. This should be viewed as a good thing (even though many nation states themselves can usurp the rules they set for their private sectors), but one assumes a more formal body will have to be introduced as the satellite count triples soon. > This type of mesh network wouldn’t really be useful in America anyway. Disagree unless I misunderstand the purpose of Swarm's tech specifically. But in general, satellite provided internet is currently the only high speed option for a significant rural population, many of which are paying over urban rates for much less. Or even as IoT sensors, again, rural settings benefit, something the US has a lot of. Where it that type of mesh would be less useful is in places with better terrestrial coverage. Also wise to approach the profitable markets first.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> a more formal body will have to be introduced as the satellite count triples soon This is the ITU [1]. Its rules say countries are responsible for satellites (a) built by their companies and, to a more limited degree, citizens and (b) launched by their rockets. India was supposed to check the satellite's clearance with the American government. If this satellite had caused any damage, the company, the U.S. government and the Indian government would have been jointly liable. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Telecommunication_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Telecommunicatio...
- tyldum 8y agoTo complicate matters, the satellite was inside a cluster launcher from NanoRacks and not a direct payload.
- alphakappa 8y agoSeems like a total dick move to launch anyway and hope that approval is obtained later. What was the plan if approval was not obtained after launch - did they have the facilities to bring down the satellites? This story reads like Silicon Valley hubris - break rules anyway because we know better. Why even have the FCC when random startups can create their own rules?
- Majestic121 8y agoAccording to the article/CEO, it happened before that other companies got the approval after launch. There's not much more details than that though, and no confirmation from FCC
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoShe received an outright rejection before launch though, and she did it anyway. I think the "other companies got the approval after launch" story is either bullshit or at the very least a gross misrepresentation of how it applied in her case.
- stale2002 8y agoWell, it was also only 4 satellites. The FCC is also probably just happy that they are being consulted at all. If this was done by a fully foreign company (or perhaps sold to a foreign shell company), then there would be nothing that the FCC could do about it.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> If this was done by a fully foreign company (or perhaps sold to a foreign shell company), then there would be nothing that the FCC could do about it If this were done by a fully-foreign company, the American taxpayer wouldn't be liable for its damages. If an American satellite crashes into a French satellite and the American can't pay, ITU rules make the U.S. government liable.
- dmitrygr 8y agoThis is typical today, sadly. Move fast and break things. Do whatever you wish and simply apologize later. It's a scary world we've created for ourselves
- mdpopescu 8y agoYes, things are definitely much better under the careful gaze of bureaucrats. /s
- kankroc 8y agoBureaucracy is a very real problem in many fields, but when we are talking about launching potentially untrackable satellite in space, having some form of oversight is probably good.
- hef19898 8y agoCertain things (health care, transportation, aerospace,...) yes. And even if not, if there are regulated markets, or markets with a high degree of rules applying to it, it's usually not to smart for a company to just ignore them. Challenge them, maybe. Ignoring them not so much. There are quite a number of examples proofing that point in sometimes ugly ways.
- chris_wot 8y agoIt worries me this was what Theranos was doing.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI still fear the Silicon Valley ethos of "move fast and break things" is infecting areas where this is outright dangerous: healthcare, self-driving cars, satellite launches. It's one thing if your social networking app goes down for a bit or someone's favorite feature is broken, it's quite another to do something that can have severe negative consequences (in this case, for humanity at large) if something goes wrong.
- sova 8y agois that a valley slogan or a fb slogan?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- unit91 8y agoFB slogan, Valley mindset. Lest we forget, many in the Valley have worked at FB, want to work at FB, or want to be FB.
- garmaine 8y agoMany is not all, or in this case even most.
- caymanjim 8y agoIt's certainly not limited to Facebook. Uber, Lyft, AirBnB, Theranos (to a lesser extent), and countless other companies are operating with a mindset of "ignore the regulations, break the law, society will catch up." Regardless of whether or not you agree with the regulations being broken, they are largely in place for a reason. Sometimes it's a good reason, sometimes it's not. The penalties are rarely enough to deter people chasing a profit. Let's stop treating "the rules don't apply to me" like an innovative business idea, and call it what it is: behaving like a child.
- basch 8y ago
- bbarn 8y agoThe reason quoted by the article for FCC dismissal was that they are too small to be tracked, and thus avoided. Is this a legitimate concern? Even with a thousand up there, is there real concern for collisions with the amount of space involved? I know the "technically correct" answer must be yes, as there's some increase in chance, but what realistically is that chance?
- raverbashing 8y agoIf you can put a satellite into orbit that's definitely NOT "too small to be tracked"
- antsar 8y agoThese sattelites are tiny; presumably the concern was not totally unwarranted. However, as stated in TFA, the satellites turned out to be quite trackable. Live tracking: https://platform.leolabs.space/catalog/L19943 https://platform.leolabs.space/catalog/L19943
- mirashii 8y agoKeep in mind that this is live tracking by a commercial company, where the US Government is more interested in whether it can be tracked by US Government systems. JSpOC has a variety of detection hardware, but much if it is quite dated at this point. It's quite likely that the object is too small to be tracked by JSpOC who coordinates Space Situational Awareness, and so it still may have posed problems.
- antsar 8y agoWell, the article says: > the SpaceBees have shown themselves to be easily trackable by the Space Surveillance Network, as well as by LeoLabs, a California-based company that provides orbital data to commercial-satellite operators and others in an effort to prevent collisions. I'm not sure if "Space Surveillance Network" is the same thing as "Space Situational Awareness", but it does sound like the US Government is capable of tracking these things.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- benmowa 8y agoNice!! pirate satellites anyone? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirate_radio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirate_radio
- ilamont 8y agoI've heard that quite a bit of venture money is flowing into "satellite IoT" to support things like precision agriculture, monitoring oil pipelines for leaks, etc. It seems that global regulatory, safety, and security planning are still at the early stages.
- chris_wot 8y agoThere was nothing mistaken about what this CEO did. She knew exactly what she was doing.
- howard941 8y agoShe's quoted as relying on some understanding that others received permission retroactively. Not mentioned in the article is whether others have in fact received retroactive permission, whether it was post-denial, and whether the launcher ignored the FCC's reasonable concern, launched anyway, and still received permission.
- chris_wot 8y agoAnd? She was told by the FCC that they were very concerned about the hazardous nature of the satellites. I'm sorry, but it costs an enormous amount to launch a satellite, you have to be somewhat worried if this organization couldn't even address the issues raised by the FCC before they launched!
- howard941 8y agoAnd nothing. She shouldn't have launched without resolving the issue raised by the commission. You're either misreading my comment or my comment was unclear. I'm assuming the problem was my lack of clarity.
- chris_wot 8y agoI apologise, I think I must have misinterpreted what you were saying :-) the fault is on my end, not yours!
- howard941 8y agoMy bad for leaving any ambiguity at all - especially because I agree completely with your position but failed to make it clear. I apologize. You're gracious for following up and I appreciate it.
- fipple 8y ago“HN user ‘fipple’ says punching Mike Tyson in the face was a ‘mistake’”
- ergothus 8y agoVaguely related point: I noticed a decade ago or so that my renter's insurance explicitly does not cover damage from a falling satellite. The reason for that might be: http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/2011/09/does_my_insurance_cover_falling_satellites.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/20...
- jackweirdy 8y agoI'm curious about the economics of that decision. Was it mentioned specifically or as an "act of god"? It seems to me (obviously a layman) that the cost of bad PR that would come out of that would outweigh the cost of paying out in the incredibly unlikely circumstance it happened? Of course, the cost of bad PR is also pretty immaterial since it's so unlikely to happen so I can't imagine it was given much thought.
- ergothus 8y agoIt was quite explicit - one of 6 explicit omissions, IIRC (it was a ~decade ago) in addition to the more general "Act of God" category. I don't recall all of the other explicit ones, but I believe a nuclear reactor accident was another of them. I was reading to look for flooding, which WAS covered. FWIW, this was renter's insurance and not homeowners. > the cost of bad PR that would come out of that would outweigh the cost of paying out I think you overestimate the impact of bad PR, but if the appropriate foreign govt is paying, they could likely dodge any problem. Also, they can always choose TO pay if the PR is bad enough.
- harshulpandav 8y agoKapton tape might not work if this collides with International Space Station.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> It’s not clear whether the inquiry will result in disciplinary action against Swarm, and it’s even less clear what the nature of that would be Replicate SEC civil penalties. Swarm gets fined, the company that brokered the launch gets fined, and the person who submitted the FCC application (hopefully the CEO) gets fined. In addition, the person who submitted the application and the company are barred from registering new satellites for N years. If the CEO represented, to the broker or the Indian government, that she had the necessary approvals I'd also hand the case to the DoJ for criminal prosecution under anti-fraud statute. I'm a huge believer in the commercialization of space. Going renegade in LEO is like flying around without registering a flight path (EDIT: bad analogy, more like drilling in a city without a permit). Eventually you'll have a horrible disaster, and it will have been because you were impatient with a straightforward process.
- sandworm101 8y agoActually, aircraft dont need to register flightpaths. A transponder code and generalized flying time is all that is needed in vfr situations. Even in ifr conditions, with filed flight plans, those plans are not meant or used for collision avoidance. Radar and human eyeballs keep aircraft apart.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- godelski 8y agoActually you don't even need generalized flying time. You can take off, fly, and land however you please. You can talk to no one the entire time. The only thing you need to do during VFR is make your calls around the airport (call before you enter a runway, downwind, and other landing calls (and if you're going from private airport to private airport, you don't even need to do that)). If you're staying out of controlled airspace you don't need to talk to anyone, but you should make a few announcements. Rules are very different if you're outside A,B, and C airspace.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoAir travel is a bad analogy, unless you only think of ATC activity near the runways. Unlike airspace, things put in orbit are permanent on the operational timescales. They also have limited, if any, capability to dodge other objects. It's more like development of a zoned piece of land, except if you build too close to another structure, both buildings explode.
- elronster 8y agoI know this deals with a US company and the FCC, but suppose a small country which doesn't belong to any international agreements decides to launch a satellite into orbit for whatever reason. Who is to stop them? Does anyone have the right to stop them?
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> a small country which doesn't belong to any international agreements Look at the map of ITU member states [1] and tell me where you'll find this spacefaring nation. [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/33/Member_states_of_the_International_Telecommunication_Union.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/33/Member_s...
- owenversteeg 8y agoLooks like Taiwan is not an ITU member and has a space program, several active satellites and their own launch vehicle in the works.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Taiwan is not an ITU member "Taiwan, Province of China, is not listed separately in the UN M49 but included in China." [1]. It is an unofficial member, however, which is why you can dial +886 to get to Taiwan [2]. Practically speaking, with the U.S. providing Taiwan its security umbrella, enforcement mechanisms for a Taiwanese breach of ITU protocol would be straightforward. [1] https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Statistics/Pages/definitions/regions.aspx https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Statistics/Pages/definitions/re... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_relations_of_Taiwan#Telecommunications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_relations_of_Taiwan#Te...
- tyldum 8y agoAnd their space program is more or less American.
- 8y ago
- garmaine 8y agoSome missing context: Only bitcoin eclipses the amount of regulatory uncertainty that surrounds satellites in the US. There are clear international law reasons that the US government approval is required for launch, but there is absolutely no statute that gives the FCC authority to deny the launch on the grounds that they did -- it's a regulatory power grab on that agency's part, trying to assert regulatory authority they were never granted. The FCC rejected the launch on the basis of tracking ability, which is something that FCC doesn't do and doesn't have any insight into assessing. If it was spectrum or comms, my assessment would have been different. However right now the satellite regulations are really in flux due to the rise of commercial space and uncertainty about space force reorganizations, etc. FCC asserting authority over orbital trajectories (vs. say, the FAA or US Space Command who HAVE been the point of contact on those issues for decades of military and NASA space launches) is an inter-agency regulatory power grab. FCC has handled domestic issues regarding geosynchronous satellites, because those are nearly all communications related. Now they're trying to unilaterally extend that to ALL Earth-orbital trajectories. What do you do when your local Parks & Rec department sends you a letter rejecting your claim of special tax status on your import/export business? That's basically what happened here.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoThe FAA has never cared about what a payload or spacecraft does once it is in orbit. They care about licensing the launches themselves and clearing the airspace, but once your vehicle is in space they don't care what you do with it (they also license reentries, but only for things that aren't meant to burn up in the atmosphere). US STRATCOM does space situational awareness work now (US Space Command was dismantled in 2002 as part of post-9/11 reorganizations, and most of its responsibilities were handed off to STRATCOM). STRATCOM _is_ currently legally mandated to interface and share data with commercial entities for traffic management purposes. However I don't believe they have or ever had any regulatory or licensing powers. STRATCOM also seems eager to pass their situational awareness responsibilities off to either the FAA or DOC. The FCC has been making the argument since the 90s that their charter to regulate in the "public interest" lets them take orbital debris mitigation into account when licensing satellites communications, and it's been codified into their administrative law. If congress or the president considered this a power grab, they've had more than a decade to do something about it. Trump is trying to make the DOC a "one stop shop" for commercial space licensing. However, I believe his executive orders still leave the FAA, FCC, and NOAA's current regulatory roles intact. edit: initially had 2012 instead of 2002 for the year that US Space Command was shut down
- craftyguy 8y ago> When I asked Spangelo why she didn’t stop the launch when the FCC denied Swarm’s application, she said, “Others have been granted applications after launching their satellites, so we were still hopeful at that point.” Is this true?
- michaelt 8y agoEven if it wasn't before, it is going forward!
- mirashii 8y agoYes, it's true. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17953025 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17953025
- craftyguy 8y agoThat definitely takes away some of the 'stunning-ness' of their actions... As the comment you linked points out, I wonder why companies are even allowed to launch in the first place if they have no approval (regardless of whether there was an initial rejection or not)..