3 ms·
Hmm, the green belt policy prevents companies from going "this bit of land needs concrete removing, lets just use a fresh field for our block of flats" which le
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
Hmm, the green belt policy prevents companies from going "this bit of land needs concrete removing, lets just use a fresh field for our block of flats" which leads to settlements spreading excessively often encompassing large "dead" areas. House price problems are down to landlords being able to earn a living by doing nothing other than owning land.
Green belt also protects farm land, which when Brexit hits is going to be a major thing for us again; if we'd been able to sell out all our farms for housing developments then we [or the poor at least] would be a considerably more dangerous position when food import prices rise.
Of course housing developers instead of spending the money to properly develop on flood plains, if they needed to, decided as they weren't living there and the government was turning a blind eye that they could get away with it. So now we have tighter laws on building in flood prone areas -- though they still get ignored somewhat, in my area of the UK for political reasons a school has recently been built on land marked as "by law you can not build here, high flood risk" (idiots!).
- 7952 8y agoGreen belt is often not particularly special. You tend to get a mix of golf courses, ugly stable blocks, compound style houses, and garden centres. It is a blunt instrument to prevent urban sprawl that completely ignores the specifics of the location in question. A good development in green belt should be possible. You should be able to avoid sprawl using other methods which could be applied to the entire country. There are hundreds of towns that are sprawling that are outside of green belt. It is a terrible policy. Also, some agricultural fields are not particularly valuable for food production or as habitat for nature. People just see green and assume that it is special and important. We need to actually judge these things in a scientific way.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoAh, you should be able to use more finesse; and probably could except property development is full of bad actors who will exploit any edge they have. All those stables ... in my parents rural village developers put animals in a field, apply for planning for a "feed shed" or "stable". Which gives then legal reason to put in utilities. Then they need a workers cottage and in the space of 10 years you turn a £4k piece of rubbish field in to £600k+ of triple-garaged greenbelt housing.
- ben_w 8y ago> House price problems are down to landlords being able to earn a living by doing nothing other than owning land. Only 21% of the UK rents. I rented for ages because houses were too expensive to buy. Then I inherited some money from my grandmother and was finally able to buy the fourth cheapest flat in the set of all in every town, city, or village within 45 minutes cycling distance of work. This was only a few years ago, and I moved out because of Brexit and became a landlord myself because the alternative was selling and I still don’t think I understand enough German to know what my responsibilities would be as a property owner here in Germany. Rents are exactly what the market bears. Charge a million a month and nobody rents your place, charge a hundred a month and you fire your estate agent. House prices follow rather than lead rental rates: follow, because if it’s cheaper to rent then people are less interested in buying (and vice versa); not lead, because rental rates are always and solely about maximising revenue and therefore influenced only about what the competition charges, not how much the assets are “worth”. Build more houses, get more competition, rent and prices both go down. On the other hand, speculative house purchases and people who buy with the expectation of selling for more, they did raise house prices; indeed, that’s pretty much what “speculative bubble” means.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoYes, I misspoke, my intention was "owners of land" not only renters. House flipping became the national sport for the middle-classes for some time (just hold a house for 3 months, "earn" £30k). In addition, in my UK city high-street shop rents are through the roof because owners have no pressure to rent out - they're making money holding the premises, so they can wait years and maintain high rental. This helps kill the high-street.