4 ms·
And you have fallen into a different statistics trap. The number that matters isn't the cost of treating the patient. What matters is the increased lifetime c
by sandworm101 8y ago
And you have fallen into a different statistics trap. The number that matters isn't the cost of treating the patient. What matters is the increased lifetime costs of a paticular disease over the average. We all have to die of something. Diseases like lung cancer are cheap. The patients are either cured or dead relatively quickly. Demential is slow. Costs pile on for decades, starting often with forced early retirement long before formal medical costs are noticed. But we still have to normalize for the fact that, be it cancer, heart disease or dementia, most all of us will eventually need expensive care for some number of years.
- Spooky23 8y agoNursing homes are among the cruelest and most in humane institutions, worse than prison in many ways. Anything that avoids nursing home days is worth it’s weight in gold.
- 14 8y agoI have worked in many as a care aid providin direct care to residents. I worked for 7 years in one facility that worked with advanced Alzheimer's and dementia like condition clients. I would not describe the nursing home as cruel or in-human, though to a person with sound mind it certainly would. The people who resided there simply could not live alone. They would soon be seriously hurt or die. So yes when they enter the facility they don't have all the same freedoms as you and I. It is not safe. They leave ovens on, let strangers have access to their money, go wondering in the night no regard to weather or other important factors and so on. Now on the family side of things they have been probably spending months trying to manage their loved one and at the same time are grieving the loss of that loved one as they watch the person they once knew fade away. Every hour for the family is spent wondering if mom or dad is safe at home and eventually their lives come to a halt and they start to experience care giver burn out. The facility provided a safe harbour for their loved ones. We ensured medications were taken on time. That they would get up in the morning and put on clean clothing and wash up as needed. We tried to entertain the residents with music, games and various activities. The facility I worked at made it so the families could finally breath and know their loved on me was safe at the end of the day. I hope others find the nursing homes they deal with to be the same experience.
- tsomctl 8y agoMy grandpa spent the last several years of his life with Alzheimers in a nursing home. Furthermore, I spent several years as a telephone technician, and I worked plenty in nursing homes. My overall impression (at least of the ones in my county) is that they are poorly managed and the employees are overworked, and presumably are very underfunded. My grandpa received excellent care, but that was because my grandma went in almost every day to check in on him. There were several occasions when she raised hell because he wasn't being taken care of properly.
- saidajigumi 8y agoThere are indeed excellent facilities for elder care. But there are many horrific ones, and the difference between them can be hard for outsiders to determine (whether for families, or for yourself). Case in point: My parents had one hell of a time finding good care for my grandfolk (incl. siblings of grandparents). In their state, there is an entire industry of corrupt nursing homes, which also have all sorts of "awards" for the excellence of their care. Just the tip of the iceberg: staff physicians who never, ever appear on site, yet who collects a paycheck by prescribing tranquilizing drugs for any resident at the facility's request, all sight unseen. The facility routinely dubs its residents as "troublesome" or "aggressive" to dope them up and 1) mean they have to provide no active care, because turnips in wheelchairs/beds don't do anything and 2) ensure a relatively quick decline in all residents, because total immobility is a great slow-acting poison, especially on the vulnerable elderly. Thus quick turnover and higher profits are ensured, all while labor costs are kept low. Eventually good facilities were found, the best of which was a wonderful VA program in a home with a live-in nurse, specializing in care for those with dementia. But not before the horror shows had taken their toll.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> quick turnover and higher profits Why would turnover increase profits for a nursing home?
- MBCook 8y agoThe quick turnovers are likely caused by being understaffed and underpaying employees. Both of which would help with profits.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 8y agoThe linked pdf says that (in 2012), end of life care for Alzheimer's and other dementia patients was $110,000 more expensive than a couple of types of cancer.
- ksdale 8y agoI remember a professor talking about the tobacco industry trials and they were talking about damages that the tobacco companies should pay to the state for increased healthcare costs due to lung cancer, and he said that the supremely ironic thing was that people who die from lung cancer at 45 have much less lifetime medical spending than people who die from most everything else at old age. He said exactly what you did, that people forget we all die of something, and the older we get, the more likely we are to have repeated long hospital stays or need long term care. Obviously that isn't to say it's good for people to die young from lung cancer, but analyzing anything medical from a money perspective is tricky.
- ryandrake 8y agoThy dystopian Logan's Run [1] featured a society optimized for total lifetime cost, where everyone gets euthanized at a certain age. Not sure we want to go that way :) 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logan%27s_Run https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logan%27s_Run