4 ms·
Personally, I'm entirely ok with normalizing marijuana usage. It has been legal all year here in SF, and de facto legal for years before that. Nothing bad happe
by wpietri 8y ago
Personally, I'm entirely ok with normalizing marijuana usage. It has been legal all year here in SF, and de facto legal for years before that. Nothing bad happened. I'd love for the rest of the country to get over the moral panic on it.
That said, I think Musk's move was colossally dumb. Tesla's valuation is based in large part on future expectations, and those expectations are deeply tied with Musk personally in a way that's true for very few other companies.
If Tesla were in the black and shipping lots of cars, he could have done this happily. But people have a lot of very reasonable concerns about Tesla. One of those concerns is that the CEO is getting erratic under pressure. Publicly dating and breaking up with a pop star. Spending his time shitposting on Twitter. Calling a hero of the Thai cave rescue a pedophile, and then doubling down on it. Announcing he was taking the company private and then changing his mind.
Given that, video of him smoking weed would have been foolish on its own. Doing that at the same time Tesla announced two executive resignations? Absurd. And given that one of those resignations was the Chief Accounting Officer leaving after 29 days? Plain dumb. It makes him look entirely irresponsible.
Is he being irresponsible with the business? Who knows. But Musk knows better than anybody how much of Tesla's valuation is based on his own very personalized PR efforts. He should go find a crisis communications consultant. And then listen to them.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y ago> He should go find a crisis communications consultant. And then listen to them. What I don't understand is, why isn't the board putting him under severe pressure to do this? Something like: Musk old buddy old pal, you need to pull your head in for another year or so, then maybe he can go on a "sabbatical", without your Twitter password, and have a massive bender.
- GW150914 8y agoAs I understand it, the board is set up to require something like a 90% vote for something like that, and it’s loaded with his friends. It’s a good setup for getting things done in a hurry in accordance with one man’s vision, but now... it’s pretty much useless.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y ago> and it’s loaded with his friends. All the more embarrassing for them!
- MBCook 8y agoIsn’t tesla one of those companies were the board and voting rights on the stock were set up in such a way that the board has very little control, sort of like Zuckerberg and Facebook? ?
- dragontamer 8y agoThe board of any company is selected by the shareholders, and the biggest shareholder of TSLA is Musk.
- anticensor 8y agoDoes constitution of Tesla lack rule of exclusion for board elections? Musk should not have been able to vote for himself.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> If Tesla were in the black and shipping lots of cars, he could have done this happily. But people have a lot of very reasonable concerns about Tesla. There is also this business with the short sellers. That may explain at least part of this lately -- all people regularly do random small-scale unwise things but most of the time (even for celebrities) nobody cares. But take some rich short sellers who already kind of dislike you and publicly challenge them to a duel, when they already had a profit motive to cause your company's shares to decline, and is it any surprise if they put their dirt finding and publicizing apparatus into overdrive? That still doesn't excuse Musk's behavior. Especially since this should have been a predictable consequence of challenging them so he should be keeping his nose extra clean. But it isn't an implausible explanation for the sudden rise in bad press.
- wpietri 8y agoI have no sympathy here; the short-sellers are Musk's own creation. Even after the big selloff, Tesla's market cap is still higher than GM's. Its valuation is extraordinarily high in large part because Musk has hyped it to the heavens. That has given him an amazingly low cost of capital and enormous free advertising. But the downside is that people who aren't drinking the koolaid can reasonably think that the valuation is too high, and want to bet accordingly. GM has 1/10th the short position because most people think the stock is priced correctly. Tl;dr: Musk's hype made some people go long and some go short. That's what talking a stock up does. The rise in bad press isn't primarily due to the short-sellers. Plenty of reasonable analysts are concerned about Tesla's repeated failure to meet projections, long-running manufacturing issues, and bad cash position. That's a good chunk of the press. But I think the bulk of it comes from a) the inevitable turning of the hype cycle, and b) Musk's own public antics. Short-sellers didn't make him call a hero a pedophile. They didn't make him spend a lot of time shitposting on Twitter. They didn't make him sell flamethrowers or date Grimes or have Azlea Banks over. They didn't make him smoke weed on camera. They certainly didn't make him write to a reporter to double down, calling the cave diver a "child rapist". [1] I feel bad for the guy; I know from personal experience that entrepreneurship is high stress. But he knew what he was getting into, and he could be handling this a lot better. [1] https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/elon-musk-thai-cave-rescuer-accusations-buzzfeed-email https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/elon-musk-thai-...
- pm90 8y ago> Chief Accounting Officer leaving after 29 days? The narrative seems to be that the person joined, and then left because of Musk's erratic public behaviors. What really concerns me is what the guy found out to leave so quickly. Or what Musk did to him that made him leave. Not sure if its different for C-level folks but changing jobs is a huge personal decision that people generally don't take lightly. The person had to have know about the erratic public behavior before, so maybe it was something else.
- icc97 8y agoOne of Tesla's PR angles is that they are anti-establishment and different from the corporate automobile industry. So Musk smoking weed plays into that well. Controversy is not always a bad thing, even when your company has problems.
- jameskegel 8y agoIf the CEO is appearing erratic under pressure, we might investigate where it is being applied and who is applying that pressure. > Investors are nervous because CEO appears erratic under pressure. > Investors apply pressure in response to erratic behavior. If an investor truly believes that he’s acting erratic under pressure, then the best response is not changing the type of pressure to societal and financial pressure.
- sokoloff 8y agoThe best response for the investor who loses confidence in the CEO of a company they’ve invested in where the CEO is personally a large part of the valuation of the company is to salvage as much value as they can and GTFO. The investor isn’t interested in what’s best for the CEO or company further than the extent to which that’s good for the investor.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The investor isn’t interested in what’s best for the CEO or company further than the extent to which that’s good for the investor. Someone who owns shares in a company like this has multiple options. One option is to sell your shares and be done with it, assuming you think the problem is insurmountable. But if you remain invested, you can still do things that reduce the problem or things that exacerbate the problem. The last one seems particularly counterproductive.