8 ms·
There are some errors here: > The dramatic shift to SUVs in the U.S. is driven by consumers caring less about traditional car value metrics such as performance
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
There are some errors here:
> The dramatic shift to SUVs in the U.S. is driven by consumers caring less about traditional car value metrics such as performance.
The cause of this was exactly the opposite -- the CAFE rules classify SUVs as trucks and allow them to fall into a less stringent fuel economy standard. The result allows SUVs to be mass-market gasoline-powered large vehicles with powerful engines, which is no longer possible for things classified as cars. That factor is primarily what caused (big-engined) SUVs to replace station wagons and large performace sedans in the market, and the small car market is as strong as it ever was.
He also calls Ives a visionary more than once, but that was Jobs. Apple has done well under Ives because of his management ability, not his ability to develop new product markets as Jobs did.
Project Titan is a huge gamble. They're essentially trying to buy their way into a market where their competitors have a head start. Apple has the cash to potentially succeed doing that, but they could also spend billions and have it come to nothing, and it's not clear what they're adding that Waymo or Telsa or Uber doesn't already have. It seems to be some combination of "Google is doing it" and the fact that Steve Jobs saw that Telsa was onto something -- but there has been ten years of progress between then and now.
And the speculation that Apple will focus on personalization is odd. Their model is walled-garden, curation, single USB port on the MacBook, everything soldered and nothing modular, any color you want as long as it's black. If anything vehicle personalization is going to become less prevalant with autonomous vehicles as it makes it easier to share vehicles if they can show up at the location of whichever part-owner needs it at a given time, or be leased out for ride sharing when not in use.
- Zanni 8y agoThe iPhone doesn't stand out as customizable because, compared to its current competition, it's not. But it's massively more customizable than what was on the market before, thanks to the app store. Yes, it's software-based customization, but the hardware is so strong that that's still huge. Again, if you compare to Android, the options seem limited ... now. But compare to the then current state of the art, where you could install custom software, if you could find it, but few people actually did. Apple enabled a staggering degree of customization that we take for granted now. I don't think Apple's going to create modular cars where you can swap out hardware or that just come in a variety of form factors. If they create customizable cars (if they get into the car biz at all), it'll be through software. Tesla already hints at some of the possibilities here: on the same hardware platform you can upgrade your autopilot or performance, even your range. (I have a 60D, which has a 75KWh battery. I can order an online software upgrade to a 75D for $2K.) That's just what Tesla already does. I can't imagine what Apple might offer, but the possibilities are intriguing.
- Phlarp 8y agoThis isn't a "software upgrade" it's a "software lock" on your hardware that they will remove for $X
- madengr 8y agoYep, that’s rampant in the electronic test equipment industry. Keysight will sell you a $13k box, with $26k of hardware options to enable.
- MBCook 8y agoIt’s the business model IBM basically pioneered that rocketed them to the top of the mainframe space. It may be new in the world of consumer cars, but it’s not new under the sun.
- Zanni 8y agoIt's an upgrade from my perspective. I paid $10K less than I would have paid for a 75D. But I take your point. It's not the best example. Nor are the other two I offered. But they're the best I can come up with, and I think they hint at the possibilities for software-customizable cars.
- mtgx 8y agoYou don't think you're paying for the hardware? So you think Tesla takes a loss whenever it sells a car with Autopilot hardware for which the customers don't buy the software upgrade? If they don't, then you're already paying for it. I think it was a mistake to do it like this, and it made all Model 3's more expensive than they could have been.
- protomyth 8y agoI think some of the SUV numbers come from the classification of vehicles as SUV that really aren't SUVs in the traditional sense. I have a Kia Niro that is classified as an SUV by the manufacture and insurance company. It gets about 50mpg in the summer. I look at it and compare it to my old 1984 Chevy Citation II. It is almost the same size and the Citation was a "hatchback". Look, your crossover is a station wagon, and a lot of SUVs are just hatchbacks.
- argonaut 8y agoThe classifications are not consistent and often don't mean anything. For example, the Niro is not classified as an SUV by the CAFE standards the OP is talking about. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety also calls it a small car and a 4 door wagon (https://m.iihs.org/iihs/ratings/vehicle/v/kia/niro-hybrid-4-door-wagon/2018 https://m.iihs.org/iihs/ratings/vehicle/v/kia/niro-hybrid-4-...)
- Fricken 8y agoWhether Ive is a visionary is ancillary to the point. The vision of the robotaxi has been had by many, including myself long before autonomous vehicles were regarded as anything less than science fiction. What matters to Apple and everyone else is execution. Robotaxis will be more personalized than privately owned ones. Rather than be limited to a single one-sided fits all form factor for all your transportation needs, you'll be able to call upon the optimal vehicle depending on whether you're commuting, hauling a load, going on a road trip, spending a lavish night on the town, or sending your kids to soccer practice.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Rather than be limited to a single one-sided fits all form factor for all your transportation needs, you'll be able to call upon the optimal vehicle depending on whether you're commuting, hauling a load, going on a road trip, spending a lavish night on the town, or sending your kids to soccer practice. This is the opposite of personalization. It's commodification. Instead of your car personalized to your specifications to fit into your niche, you get a dozen generic categories and decide that today you'll be summoning Generic Touring Vehicle but tomorrow it will be Generic Multi-Personnel Transport Vehicle or Generic Light Duty Towing Vehicle. The fact that they offer fries in three different sizes doesn't mean yours is personalized because you picked the medium one.
- Fricken 8y agoWhat does personalized mean then if it doesn't mean tailored to suit your needs? What do personalized fries look like if it doesn't mean getting the size/type of French fries you asked for?
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoIt means the one you got is not interchangeable with the one anybody else got in some non-frivolous way. It's not personalization when fifty other people got exactly the same thing. Buses aren't personalized just because they each go to a different place.
- takahisah 8y ago> Project Titan is a huge gamble. Titan is not a gamble. It's a hobby. And from the eyes of a Trillion Dollar Company, it's not even an expensive one. What's the worst that can happen? They spend a few more years on it, poaching talent from Tesla and other car companies and from internal teams, and end up with nothing. Sure, they might spend a few billion in the process, but they already did that building a spaceship, and spending at that level doesn't hurt their books at all. iPhone on the other hand, was a huge gamble at the time. It had the potential to ruin the company by cannibalizing iPod sales, diluting the brand, and destroying morale of top engineers who were at the time the "best" employees they had. What's the best thing that can happen? They launch the equivalent of an iPhone in the auto industry, figure out how to scale, and change the way people go from point a to b. They are recognized as the company that pulled off something Tesla couldn't, and Tim Cook / Jony Ives get to put their names on a revolutionary product that changed the world again. So it's a low risk high return situation for them to work on it. Can they pull it off? I would say much more likely than "traditional" auto companies but less likely than Tesla. But again, it doesn't really matter to them (part of why chances of success are lower), and competition is a good thing. As a shareholder of TSLA, I don't want to see Elon Musk smoking weed on YouTube anymore. Somebody please take away his Twitter account too.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Titan is not a gamble. It's a hobby. And from the eyes of a Trillion Dollar Company, it's not even an expensive one. Gambling billions of dollars is gambling billions of dollars even when you have a trillion. And everything is tiny compared to their capitalization. They could buy General Motors and burn it to the ground for ~4% of their market cap. That doesn't make it a good idea. The question isn't what percent of their company size it is, it's whether it's a cost effective use of shareholder money. And best case vs. worst case doesn't tell you anything until you consider the probability of each.
- takahisah 8y agoTo me, a business decision is always based on _relative_ risk to reward ratio. If you're a startup hiring employee number 3 vs Google hiring employee number 739813, your risk profile is completely different, but the absolute dollar investment in one employee is about the same. In that scenario hiring an employee number 3 could be a huge gamble in a way that hiring employee number 739813 could never be. But lets leave out the technicalities. Call it a gamble, stupid investment, whatever. Yes, I agree a billion is a lot of money. Apple still needs to have this project, in order to stay relevant to competitors and current/potential employees. Even if it does fail, the side effects of having this project mainly to attract talented engineers and stay relevant make it worth the investment.
- briandear 8y ago> it's not clear what they're adding that Waymo or Telsa or Uber doesn't already have. It’s not clear what they’re adding that BlackBerry and Nokia or Motorola doesn’t already have.. — something we could have said just before iPhone arrived.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoIt's not clear what they're adding that iOS or Android doesn't already have -- something we could have said just before Windows Phone 7 arrived.
- improv32 8y agoBut it was clear what the iPhone was adding. Capacitive multitouch, big screen, desktop browser on mobile, etc...
- talltimtom 8y agoThat wasn’t clear at all. None of that was public before they launched. And when they did launch the entire industry was saying “touchscreens suck, who cares about desktop browser pages aren’t designed for that, we have WAP for that!” So no, it wasn’t clear for any outsiders that he iPhone was even going to be a success. And like plenty times before people where predicting the death of Apple due to their stupidity of going into a different market.
- argonaut 8y agoThe CAFE rules explain why SUVs emerged in the past, but over the past decade many SUVs have been classified as cars under CAFE standards. Most crossovers are now classified as cars.
- ajmurmann 8y agoAnecdotal: I prefer a sedan over SUVs, but there are so many SUVs in the US that I feel my view is frequently blocked by all the high SUVs when not in a SUV myself.
- temp20160423 8y agoThis is a big reason why people buy SUV's. That, and the belief it's safer since momentum is mass*velocity, so the winner in a crash favors the heavier car. I think we need some more taxes to punish the externalities of driving taller/bigger/heavier vehicles.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThe sad thing is that they have the math wrong. Whether you live or die depends more on what the other person is driving than what you are. Car vs. car both people live, truck vs. truck both people die. The extra mass isn't making you safer, it's just killing the other guy because there is a limit to how much total force crumple zones and other safety features can absorb.
- PHGamer 8y agoThe IIHS disagrees... https://www.iihs.org/iihs/news/desktopnews/new-crash-tests-demonstrate-the-influence-of-vehicle-size-and-weight-on-safety-in-crashes-results-are-relevant-to-fuel-economy-policies https://www.iihs.org/iihs/news/desktopnews/new-crash-tests-d... smaller cars arent as safe as bigger ones
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago
- draw_down 8y agoI’d say there’s a lot more risk in them not trying than trying. Where can a business go that’s currently hooked on selling thousand-dollar devices for which there is a gigantic maker and demand? They’re not going to make significantly more money than they do now by staying in computers/electronics. Cars are one of the only categories left that has consumers spending an amount of money that would be attractive to a huge company like Apple.
- Spooky23 8y agoYou’re missing the point on SUVs. I’m 6’5” and have 3 kids. I need a full size car that can accommodate the legally mandated safety requirements for my kids. No sedan meets that requirement. I have to buy a midsize+ SUV or minivan, period. Even for my personal use, cars are uncomfortable and painful for me to use. I drove a 1999 Accord until recently as a commuter. The 2018 Accord was too low for me (to meet the CAFE targets) and most midsize sedans has similar challenges. I ended up choosing between a Honda Fit, a Honda Pilot, BMW X3 or Chevy Tahoe. I ended up with the Pilot as a trade off between comfort/efficiency/cost. The fetishization of ridesharing in the Valley and on HN reveals the blind spot of the culture of tech — family. Try using Uber to move two adults and 2-3 kids.
- _ph_ 8y agoTo be fair: while large on the outside, the interior space of many modern SUVs isn't great either. So you need either a large SUV, a classic station wagon, a minivan or any other car designed for space. Incidentally I have a friend who is also 6'5", and he ended up with a Golf Variant, as this turned out the most comfortable car for him back then.
- asimpletune 8y ago> Ives because of his management ability, not his ability to develop new product markets as Jobs did. Did you mean Cook?
- talltimtom 8y agoYes he did. And it’s funny to see someone repeat an oppinion they’ve obviously just read but didn’t understand the contents of eg “Jobs was a visionary, Cook is a great manager” and then just assume that Ives is Cook because someone mentions him as Apples visionary.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Did you mean Cook? You're right, I was thinking of Cook. I would actually be more inclined to agree with calling Jony Ive a visionary when I haven't confused the two of them with each other. It's really still the same trouble though. It's good that they have Ive to do his piece, but they still need someone to do the separate piece that Jobs used to do.
- richardw 8y agoApple can choose to enter the market when it's good and ready. That is, when it knows it has a very solid product that brings clear advantage. If it can't find that, keep looking or stop. Tesla is on a death match to outrun the rest of the auto industry. It can't afford mistakes. If 3 doesn't work it's screwed. Musk pushes those people so hard they could well burn out first. I'd much rather be Apple than Tesla.