2 ms·
yes, the basic model for good education is cooperation, with grades and evaluation just used for feedback to allow someone to improve rather than as a tool for
by joe_the_user 8y ago
yes, the basic model for good education is cooperation, with grades and evaluation just used for feedback to allow someone to improve rather than as a tool for punishment.
However, the competitive paradigm can easily be defended if one regards the education process as simply a sorting process. Suppose different people have different intelligence levels and the purpose of education is to find those with the highest intelligence. Then you don't need to have the education system teach students more than average. Students will learn or not and it is on them. And here, if the "real world" works this way, hey, you giving students a taste of this and in a limited sense that's "education".
So overall, this good, cooperative approach to teaching certainly exists and if you're a student you should seek it out. But there are reasons punitive education remains and those reasons have to do with the structure of this society and society would have to change for this go away significantly.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- _Tev 8y agoCurrent education process does not seem to be successful at sorting by "intelligence", "success in life" or any other metric I can think of. So this seems actually like a good argument to change it (maybe towards cooperation), because it fails even at one thing it is supposed to be good at.