8 ms·
Everything You Need to Know About WPA3 Things I know about WPA3: - None of my routers support it, and I'm not gonna buy all new routers. - My printer doesn't
by reaperducer 8y ago
Everything You Need to Know About WPA3
Things I know about WPA3:
- None of my routers support it, and I'm not gonna buy all new routers.
- My printer doesn't support it. Heck, it doesn't support WPA2.
- None of my IOT doohickies support it. Not gonna buy all new devices.
In this instance, I feel I'm more aligned with Joe Lunchbucket than Zap McTechburg. I still use my PSP. It's 14-years-old and not going to work with WPA3. My wireless printer is 15-years-old, and doesn't even do 5GHz.
By the time the average person upgrades all their gear to WPA3 stuff, it'll be cracked and we'll be on WPA5.
- bcaa7f3a8bbc 8y agoThings I know about WPA3... - I can install/upgrade some packages on my OpenWrt router/computers to enable it. - I can leave a WPA2 SSID for my old gadgets. > By the time the average person upgrades all their gear to WPA3 stuff, it'll be cracked and we'll be on WPA5. Perhaps vendors can implement a WPA3/WPA2 mixed mode? Or just use the dual SSID hack...
- jandrese 8y agoI have a modern router for WPA3 and an older router that does WPA1 but is firewalled from the rest of the network and only allows access to a small range of IPs.
- txcwpalpha 8y agoIf you're on a network that has both WPA2 and WPA3 enabled, are you really even benefiting from all of the WPA3 security improvements? Any attacker can just fall back to your WPA2 SSID and crack your network that way. And once they have access to your network, unless you're doing some advanced network segmentation, does it matter which version of WPA you're using?
- sieabahlpark 8y agoCongrats, you have realized that most people don't understand this. I guess you could section off a guest SSID which is a dmz or something like that.
- bcaa7f3a8bbc 8y agoObviously not all, but at least it would benefit from the forward secrecy of the new handshake, even if the user does nothing else. For ordinary users, setting a strong passphrase is all they need to do to have network with improved security, even in the mixed mode. In addition, you can isolate the WPA2 SSID away (for all those printers, Internet of Trash, some old smartphones that are never going to receive security updates, etc) from the rest of the network, and use strong, and independent passphrases for each network, the compromise of WPA2 would not affect WPA3 to a large extent.
- reaperducer 8y agoFor ordinary users, setting a strong passphrase is all they need to do to have network with improved security, even in the mixed mode. Then what's the point of even developing WPA3? Why not revise WPA2 to just require really long passwords?
- andrewshadura 8y agoThat's basically what WPA3 is, it is an improvement to WPA2, not a completely new and separate protocol.
- Jonnax 8y agoIsolate my printer from the rest of the network? How do I print?
- jopsen 8y agoAllow connections to the printer from other decides, but not connections from the printer to your devices..
- greglindahl 8y agoMany wireless networks have multiple segments to them, for example a company has a "guest" network and a company network. Make the WPA2 network like a guest network, i.e. it's basically like being outside the company at a coffee shop. This isn't advanced, it's pretty common.
- txcwpalpha 8y agoI think you overestimate what is "common". It might be "common" for the network admins or highly technical people browsing this website. It is not common whatsoever for the vast majority of the public that uses WPA for home networking or small businesses. Security is significantly decreased for everyone if it's only practical for those that are highly technical. It would be great if it actually was common, and such features came pre-configured out of the box for users. Unfortunately, most of the routers I'm aware of that are given to users from ISPs don't even support guest modes.
- greglindahl 8y agoUh, sure, if you're only talking about home users then of course current and future products are a disaster. That's more a function of the markets than the standard.
- txcwpalpha 8y agoYou're right, and that's a problem even for companies. Security is a game of weakest links. Your company can spend billions of dollars accomplishing 99.99% vulnerability coverage on their networks, but it will be meaningless if your employees go home and connect their work laptops to a compromised home network. I don't think there's an easy fix for this and I'm not criticizing WPA3 or anything. Ideally we could just update/throw out old, incompatible devices, but realistically I know that's not going to happen. I'm just pointing out that the suggestion to "keep WPA2 enabled for your old, WPA3-incompatible devices" kinda misses the point about WPA3 in the first place.
- 8y ago
- dikkechill 8y agoIf you're using something like OpenWRT, you most likely don't need to buy new hardware. The WPA3 functionality is already added to hostapd and wpa_supplicant [1]. Look for the terms SAE (Simultaneous Authentication of Equals), DPP (Device Provisioning Protocol) and OWE (Opportunistic Wireless Encryption). The current experimental wpa_supplicant Debian package has this enabled [2]. I think the main challenge is upgrading clients, especially when vendors no longer provide updates. [1] https://w1.fi/cgit/hostap/log/?qt=grep&q=SAE https://w1.fi/cgit/hostap/log/?qt=grep&q=SAE [2] https://packages.qa.debian.org/w/wpa/news/20180722T152029Z.html https://packages.qa.debian.org/w/wpa/news/20180722T152029Z.h...
- reaperducer 8y agoIf you're using something like OpenWRT, you most likely don't need to buy new hardware. Awesome! Point me in the direction of the firmware upgrade portal for my 15-year-old wifi printers, computers, and game machines from companies that no longer exist.
- dikkechill 8y agoI agree, you have a good point with respect to a large amount of older hardware and I do not have a solution for that problem. What I can say is that I try to buy hardware which has support for open source software and has a community around it. So far this helped me to extend the life of these devices, as it does not depend on the vendor alone. I'm not really sure how to interpret your 'Awesome!'. If it was meant snarky and if you're willing to, please have a look at the HN guidelines for comments [1]. We can then improve the quality of the discussion. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- reaperducer 8y agoI'm not really sure how to interpret your 'Awesome!'. If it was meant snarky and if you're willing to, please have a look at the HN guidelines for comments [1]. We can then improve the quality of the discussion. You're right. I'm sorry about that. Sometimes I forget which web site I'm posting on.
- acdha 8y agoThis is a good point but how certain are you that WPA3 can’t be shipped as a software upgrade? At least Eero appears to be claiming that will happen and I’d be surprised if they were the only ones because the vendors also know that upgrade curves are glacial if it requires new hardware. I do think we’re going to see more mixed networking with modern access points supporting multiple networks so you can have your primary devices stay secure while the botnets controlling your IoT fridge and TV duke it out on a different SSID.
- reaperducer 8y agohow certain are you that WPA3 can’t be shipped as a software upgrade? I'm pretty sure that the wifi devices I own that were EOL'ed a decade ago aren't going to get a software upgrade. Nor are the ones from companies that are no longer in business.
- berti 8y agoRunning EOL hardware means you're likely open to a bunch more things than just an old wireless security standard..
- jplayer01 8y agoSo I should just never use my Vita?
- acdha 8y agoIs everything you own EOLed? If your router is that old you’re probably open to security issues and definitely leaving performance on the floor. For most people, I’m expecting primary devices (phones, laptops) to get updates along with newer routers (at least the higher end ones). The big question is how common the practice of segregating old devices will be since it’s still easy to find things which don’t even do 5GHz and that includes a majority of TVs, Android devices, etc.
- radicaldreamer 8y agoNone of this applies to most people though... and the thing you need to know is that the vast majority of humanity is better served with updated standards than people with “IoT” devices and know what routers are.
- dagenix 8y agoSo we should just declare wireless done and never change it again?
- dgzl 8y agoI mean, you will support it eventually. We're not sticking with WPA2, and we're certainly not going back.
- tibu 8y agoSometimes you have to spend money on security. You can decide whether you use daily your 50 years old oldtimer BMW or you buy the latest Volvo (or whatever) with the best security package available. At least you have to option to choose.
- IntelMiner 8y agoThe problem in this case, is that you have to buy the "latest Volvo" And then you have to buy a new garage to put it in, because the old garage was too small And you have to digitize all your CD's because it only has a phone connection Except you have to replace your phone, too, because it's too old for Android Auto (or the iPhone equivalent) It's the ripple-on effect of having to migrate all the devices that vendors don't bother to "fix"
- saagarjha 8y ago> the iPhone equivalent CarPlay. The more you know…
- TeMPOraL 8y agoAlso: the "latest Volvo" may have lots of UX regressions compared to your "old Volvo". Like, all that cloud SaaS bullshit and bloated vendor apps home printers now ship with. So, beyond having to upgrade everything else around you, you may be simply facing the problem of degrading your experience to keep yourself secure.
- iscrewyou 8y agoPSP. The memories. I gotta buy a used one.
- Bayart 8y agoI get an old man yelling at clouds vibe from this ;)
- gdrift 8y agoprinter is 15-years-old Seriously, I want to know what printer is that. Of all my printers in the past 20 years none has lived from more than three years. I had the cheap ones as well as the more expensive ones with 3 years warranty.
- bjoli 8y agoMy HP laserjet 1010 still works like a charm with cups (windows drivers that work are hard to find). I have had zero issues with it since the first purchase in 2003 (?), despite printing hundreds of pages per month.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoLaserjet 4050 here. Last B&W model before the reign of Carly destroyed quality.
- msh 8y agoI have a 14 years old Lexmark laser printer that still works great.
- gdrift 8y agoThanks for the responses. Note to self: buy laser printer not inkjet.
- kayoone 8y agojust keep a different Wifi open for the older stuff, or just don't upgrade as you clearly are not interested in having secure networking.
- another-cuppa 8y agoHey, why not just stop all development? WEP was fine. IE6 was fine. I'm sure you still run Windows XP too.
- unethical_ban 8y agoI don't get the downvotes; that is essentially what the parent post said. Counterpoint would be that "WPA2 is fine" - but still, for HN I don't understand how a reactionist non-technical comment is at the top of an article about new crypto specs.
- ksec 8y ago>None of my routers support it, and I'm not gonna buy all new routers. I think we are moving into the future where ISP provides the router to you, or basically a Unit that combines Modem / ONT / Wireless Router into one. So you will (hopefully) get upgraded every 5 - 8 years.
- jacksproit 8y agoThey’ve been doing that forever and it’s a $15/mo charge for a device that costs maybe $100. You think educated consumers want to pay $15/mo for 60 months = $900? Fewer and fewer fall for that trick.
- ksec 8y agoAt least I expect the way forward will be ISP giving them for free. The price difference for an ONT / Modem or ONT/Modem + Wireless Router are minimal.