6 ms·
I have lived in NYC since long before Uber and co were on the scene. I used to call a car service switchboard and give them my location and destination and they
by tootie 8y ago
I have lived in NYC since long before Uber and co were on the scene. I used to call a car service switchboard and give them my location and destination and they'd have a car there in 5-10 minutes max. They'd bring a car seat if I asked. The driver would get my number and call me if he was stuck or couldn't find me. Price was reasonable, drivers were pros. It was literally just one lady answering a phone. And now Uber/Lyft/Didi are employing like 10,000 highly-paid developers and providing a marginally better level of service. The biggest value-add by far is that they have a consistent name and brand that can provides drivers anywhere instead of having to pick a car service off of yelp. It's mind-boggling how over-engineered these businesses are in order to justify their status in Silicon Valley.
- type-2 8y agoYOur opinion
- oblio 8y agoObviously, everything I write is my opinion. Uber, Didi, Lyft are free to prove me wrong by turning a profit. So far, that doesn't seem to be happening.
- ghaff 8y agoIn all fairness, that is NYC (and mostly Manhattan in particular) which is very atypical. On the other hand, the cost structure seems insane and, like many "businesses" in .com 1.0, you have these services that are being subsidized until they "make up for it in volume" rather than simply accepting that their cost structure makes them relative luxuries--as in the case of black cars in Manhattan.
- tootie 8y agoThis wasn't for Manhattan. It was a part of Brooklyn that never gets yellow cabs. There's car services in most suburbs too. They're just less saturated because most people have cars.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoThe fact that Uber has several of orders of magnitude more users, and that there cultural shift has been so great that cities around the world are struggling with how to regulate ride hailing services, suggests that there is something a bit more than "consistent name and brand" that is driving users in droves to these services where they didn't use your "one lady answering a phone" service.
- majani 8y agoYes, they sell their services at a loss, so of course people will flock to them.
- wafflesraccoon 8y agoThe biggest shock to me is how fast culture changed, I go to the bar on the weekends a lot and we had a DD rotation for years. Once we figured out that we could pay $12 for an uber anywhere in town we started having so much more fun.
- talltimtom 8y agoUber didn’t succeed because they cut prices, if that had been all they would have been just a moderately more successful taxi company. They succeeded because they realized that cutting prices and a bit of branding would mean unlocking a huge untapped market. They became the way Evereyone got too and from every club/party/pub, where taxis where just never an option.
- reaperducer 8y agoThere's a little more to it than that. In some cities, the taxis refuse to leave the city center. In New York, for example, hailing a hack outside of Manhattan or the trendy boros was virtually impossible. "Car service" became a thing because cabs left more than half the city unserved. But even those were limited in availability in some areas. In Las Vegas, it was rare to see a taxi outside of the entertainment corridor. If you called for a taxi, they'd ignore you. The new state taxi commissioner even tried it, himself. He phoned three times for a taxi from a mall just a mile from The Strip, and every time he was ignored. That's why Uber works in many places. And the app showing the position of the other cars encourages drivers to fan out into underserved areas. Some people have even done that math and found that Ubering around town is cheaper for them than owning+maintaining+insuring+fueling a car.
- aesthesia 8y agoThis is very NYC-centric. A big part of the value of Uber/Lyft is that they provide a similar service in many places where it simply wasn't available before. The automation and deprofessionalization played a big role in making that possible.
- _e 8y agoYes, aesthesia makes a very important point. Uber/Lyft & Co. standardized the UX just like you can expect what a Big Mac tastes like at any McDonalds in the world.
- Silfen 8y agoIt's not just homogeneity. Cab and car services basically didn't exist in many US cities prior to ride sharing. I'm a carless transit fanatic, but 10 years ago I'd probably have to buy a car to live comfortably in my current neighborhood.
- mabbo 8y agoNot only NYC-centric, but affluent NYC-centric. One of the advantages of Uber is that you can get your ride to wherever you need to go, whoever you are and the drivers have far less to worry about. I've heard many stories about people saying that cabs and private hire companies simply wouldn't go to <neighbourhood> or pick up people who sounded non-white-affluent, meaning a large swath of people were discriminated against and couldn't get rides. With Uber/Lyft, the driver doesn't know what I look like, what I sound like, or where I'm going until I'm in the car. And the driver has no reason to discriminate because he's getting paid regardless.
- misiti3780 8y agoonly in NYC --- move to a place like buffalo ride sharing has literally revolutionized the way the denizens live their lives and go out.
- jartelt 8y agoThings are much better in SF now too. I remember ~8 years ago, we would call for a cab in SF after going out at night. We typically would end up standing at a street corner for 30 minutes waiting for the cab and it usually wouldn't show up. This would sometime leads to missing the last caltrain of the night, which was always a bummer...
- claytonjy 8y agoit's done all that in the <12 months Buffalo has had Uber/Lyft?
- misiti3780 8y agoyes, my family is from them, more people go out to dinner, less drinking and driving, more people are in bars, etc.
- 0xcafecafe 8y agoOn the other hand, here in Atlanta, it was horrible before these rideshare services came along. I remember as a poor student in the last decade, I had to spend 4 hours each day to travel 24 miles (12 miles each way) for my internship. While for you uber might be redundant, it certainly provides a valuable service for cities with worse public transit options.
- ghaff 8y agoWould it be as useful if it weren't being subsidized? Say 2x the current costs? It varies by city of course but there were at least two largely orthogonal issues with cabs in a lot of places. General crapiness (unreliable, hard to get dispatched, won't go some places, credit card readers broken, etc.) and high cost. e.g. I get a car to and from the airport were I live. It's comfortable and reliable but not cheap.
- jonknee 8y ago> Would it be as useful if it weren't being subsidized? Say 2x the current costs? Yes. Outside of a few markets in the US it was a gamble to get a cab at any price. You'd call and it would be something like "30-45 minutes" and then an hour later you'd call again and hear the same thing. And this just on a regular night, forget about it if there's an event going on.
- ghaff 8y agoFair enough. I admit to rarely taking cabs (especially outside of standard traveler routes, e.g. airport to hotel) even when I'm traveling, as I do frequently, so I don't have a lot of experience.
- 0xcafecafe 8y agoDefinitely yes. I can see the student me taking advantage of the uberpool even if it was 2x the cost (since it would have saved me 2-3 hours each day).
- 8y ago
- jnordwick 8y agoNYer here. Where did you live? Downtown Manhattan? Pre-Uber try getting cab service like that in Harlem or the other boroughs. You mostly rely on gypsy cabs who were always sketchy and always tried to cheat you. Coming back from the airport one time, one driver even tried to put my bags in another cab and tell me he'll finish the ride. If the pre Uber cab service were so great, Uber wouldn't be such a popular success there right now. And God help you if you were black and trying to get a ride.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> Coming back from the airport one time, one driver even tried to put my bags in another cab and tell me he'll finish the ride. Sounds like you weren't dealing with a TLC-licensed driver, which all medallion cabs and all legal black cabs (including Lyft and Uber) are.
- tootie 8y agoI was doing this in Ft Greene/Bed-Stuy. They don't know what color you are on the phone.
- simonrobb 8y ago> and they'd have a car there in 5-10 minutes max The introduction of low-cost options for Uber/Lyft were arguably as important a development as their original ride-hailing app ideas. Once the fleet was no longer constrained to professional drivers, and anybody with a spare hour or two (and a car) could go online, the size of the fleet exploded. That meant the likelihood of having a car near you - no matter where you are in a city - dramatically increased. Sure, call your local car service from home when you're heading to JFK and he'll be there in 10. How about when you're in the Village at 1am? How about Red Hook? Not to mention this allowed the service to be provided in cities all over the world which didn't previously have a car service at all. > 10,000 highly-paid developers Uber probably services more than 10,000x the number of rides than your car service did. I suppose you could try employing 10,000 "ladies with a phone" to handle that volume - but of course human dispatch quickly becomes unable to handle those kinds of volumes. Sorry, those developers are necessary for scale. > and providing a marginally better level of service Car-sharing with strangers was impossible before Uber/Lyft operated at scale. Share a car to work with some of your colleagues, who happen to live near you, sure. But to car pool anywhere at any time requires a huge fleet, and the technology to match riders who are taking the same route. That is an very difficult problem to solve, and yes it takes capable engineers. That car pooling allows fares which are probably around a third of what your car service charges. More improvements are on the way which should see short-medium trips of a comparable cost to public transport. Not to mention providing this service in under-served and otherwise unprofitable areas, to minorities, at all times of day, all across the world. Plus of course a consistent name and brand, by far the biggest value-add ;) Now integrate with other modes of transport - public transport, bikes, and yep even scooters. These companies are positioned to shape entire cities' transit systems (they already have, for better or for worse). They're not the same as your small car service, and they're not over-engineered. They're certainly not setting out every day worried about justifying their Silicon Valley existence.
- a-dub 8y ago> Sure, call your local car service from home when you're heading to JFK and he'll be there in 10. How about when you're in the Village at 1am? How about Red Hook? New York is a bad example. The system that was here before was pretty exceptionally good. Standard protocol if you were in the boroughs was to simply ask for the local car service number. Restaurants, bars and bodegas all had it ready. If you were in the city, just flag down a yellow. A car was rarely more than a few minutes away.
- majani 8y agoYes, this is the inherent issue at play nowadays. Investors are throwing silly money at startups in an attempt at global domination. What then happens is that the start-ups rely on pricing at a loss to get the majority market share and absorbing the loss through their silly money funding. End result is that simple business models end up getting destroyed because the customers are now sensitive to any price hikes above the loss making prices. The funded company now has to pursue a mish mash of money making strategies to try and break even. It remains to be seen whether this strategy will work long term.
- Karrot_Kream 8y agoUber is 9 years old, "remains to be soon" makes you wonder how long it takes for investors pumping money into hypothetical winner-take-all markets to get tired and leave.
- majani 8y agoPerhaps sunken cost fallacy affects even the most brilliant investors.
- xaranke 8y agoI hate talking on the phone, I'd much rather prefer an app. The fact that The Oatmeal[1] has a comic on this means that it's more than just me. [1]: http://theoatmeal.com/comics/phone http://theoatmeal.com/comics/phone
- aquadrop 8y agoThe appeal of the apps for me is: - I don't need to make calls, I have list of places I go to most often and calling a taxi is couple of clicks away - I don't need to worry about payment, it's just "Thanks, bye" and you go out of the car. - I know what car will come to me - I can see where the car is while it's coming to me - When abroad it's so much easier to to use an app instead of talking to a driver who barely speaks English (like Thailand) So it's much more than just a brand.