5 ms·
Anyone know what videos or tweets were 'abusive'? Twitter didn't say which ones they were. Twitter needs to be more transparent about this stuff. Especially wh
by dmix 8y ago
Anyone know what videos or tweets were 'abusive'? Twitter didn't say which ones they were.
Twitter needs to be more transparent about this stuff. Especially when banning one of the most influential conspiracy theorist in the world.
Not to mention a vague and/or arbitrary banning policy is always a bad idea.
- twmb 8y agoWouldn't drawing attention to bannable offenses be Streisand effect-y?
- espeed 8y agoYes. Jones and Trump both subscribe to the philosophy of "there's no such thing as bad publicity...all publicity is good publicity." Jones was overjoyed when Clinton referenced him publicly in her campaign.
- maxander 8y agoTwitter isn’t going to broadcast or link to tweets that were bad enough to merit a ban, for obvious reasons- they’re banning it precisely to avoid having that content be propagated any further.
- tomohawk 8y agoThis is circular reasoning, and it conveniently excuses any abuses or hypocrisy by the company by disappearing the evidence and not allowing anyone else to judge for themselves. From an outside observer, there is no way to distinguish between the claim that the ban is for "good reasons", or that the ban is a result of bias on the part of the company.
- LocalH 8y agoThis is the same reasoning that leads to people getting banned from a service for a reason, and then given a cold shoulder and absolutely no information about why. Perhaps this is fine in situations where the banned entity is a malicious actor, but it presumes a zero false-positive rate. My opinion is, if even one person is wrongly punished without recourse (other than rolling the dice with social media) then the whole system is unjust and should be reworked.
- craftyguy 8y agoWho, other than you, says that twitter must be just? The world would be a completely different place if companies were required by law to be just.
- alexozer 8y agoWhat makes you think that they said that Twitter must be just? Why not simply should be just? Why would you not want a platform as large and integral to modern open communication to be just?
- craftyguy 8y ago> integral to modern open communication Why do you assume that it is integral to modern open communication? (hint: it's not, for plain reason that twitter does what's best for twitter)
- LocalH 8y agoGiven that the collective output of Twitter users has risen to the level of having massive influence, perhaps it's time we rethink how "freedom of speech" meshes with "private service". For example, when it comes to publicly-available services such as this, we often hear about people referring to "Twitter's freedom of speech" in terms of censorship of its users, which boggles my mind. Twitter provides a publicly-accessible service that allows users to post short entries, and when they prevent someone else from posting something, it basically amounts to "Twitter's right to free speech is more important than the user's ability to speak" and that seems a bit counter-intuitive. If Twitter's policies are unjust, then Twitter does not deserve the level of influence that it has. My opinion is that such a service could not have been foreseen by the writers of the Constitution. In their day, the greatest threat to freedom of speech was the government. Remember, they had just fought for their independence from England. I don't think they could have envisioned a world where the greatest threat to free speech would come from the private sector. And if we're not careful, we're about to be making it worse. As it stands, platform operators are not generally liable for the things they automatically publish on behalf of their users, outside of certain highly egregious things (such as child abuse imagery), and even then only if they don't follow the proper procedure with regards to reporting to law enforcement, etc. If that ever changes, expect freedom of speech to be null and void in context of the Internet.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- timClicks 8y agoNo it's not, because Twitter itself has presumably reviewed the messages itself. As a service owner, and therefore an arbiter, it doesn't need to allow anyone to judge themselves.
- ergothus 8y agoYou are correct. However, Twitter is not a govt with checks and balances for the purposes of accountability. It is a company and their judgement, like most companies, is part of the product. What transparency would you find acceptable? Do you hold other companies to that level? I dont know the books for my local grocery store, I dont know their justifications or reasonings for what they do or dont stock, when they decide to hire, or what rules they hire for. I'm not trying to be antagonistic or dismissive - I am far from an "anything goes" libertarian (or a libertarian of any kind) but if rules about rules are arbitrary, then we're just doing what we complain about.
- jaydz 8y agoI imagine the videos where he harasses the CNN reporter and the females protesting Kavanaugh were the last straw. This was from his Periscope live stream. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0dcSvuyZm-U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0dcSvuyZm-U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrZuQqtABUo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrZuQqtABUo
- yters 8y ago<sarcasm> Yeah, that doesn't help Alex Jones' cause at all, does it? </sarcasm> It also seems quite arbitrary when there are plenty of very abusive people on the other end of the spectrum.
- JauntyHatAngle 8y agoWhat spectrum? he's a conspiracy theorist telling fabrications, he "fits" on the right wing, but no sane conservative would associate with him.
- yters 8y agoMy point is there is a clear bias as to which extremists get banned from Twitter. I'm not saying Alex Jones is representative of the right.
- happytoexplain 8y agoI haven't seen evidence of this personally, so to me it's not "clear", but I also think there's a sparsity of data (these bannings are mostly few, high-profile cases). However, I absolutely do not doubt that it COULD happen, given the chance. Do you have anybody in mind that you would consider his opposite, politically, but comparable in the damaging/far-reaching nature of his rhetoric?
- yters 8y agoOne example that springs to mind would be Spike Lee posting the home addresses of a couple that had nothing to do with the Zimmerman case. It wouldn't be licit even if he had the addresses correct. And in general I see very virulent rants directed against pro-life people, with death threats and the like.
- orf 8y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ne_wFdA-1oU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ne_wFdA-1oU This is where he compared a journalist eyes to a rats, which I believe is what caused the ban?
- lettergram 8y agoHis "How are you doing Alex?", gives me the impression he gets this a lot lol
- lsiebert 8y agoI mean, didn't he call sandy hooks a false flag attack or something?
- colordrops 8y agoThat's not abusive behavior though. It's just a conspiracy theory.
- happytoexplain 8y agoSince the "abuse" in abusive behavior online is not defined as physical abuse, but rather mental, e.g. harrassment, I don't see how there could be any room for doubt that this horrific, insane lie is abusive to the many people affected.
- colordrops 8y agoA double digit percentage of Twitter comments are abusive by that definition.
- krapp 8y agoIt encourages abusive behavior. Victims of mass shootings have been harassed by Alex Jones fans trying to call them out for being "crisis actors."
- boxspam 8y agoKill your fans.
- krapp 8y agoBut then my room would be too hot.
- colordrops 8y agoHe didn't even call for any harassment of these alleged "crisis actors" let alone call for their murder. If you are going to blame mass shootings on ungrounded speculation then we've got to censor half of the internet. Your line of reasoning is no different from blaming video games for mass shootings.
- newnewpdro 8y ago> Twitter needs to be more transparent about this stuff. Why? Unless being opaque harms their bottom line, I don't see the business case.
- Aunche 8y agoThere's no upside in being transparent in what is bannable. They don't want to encourage people to post what is barely allowed. Inevitably, there is going to be some inconstancy in the way borderline cases are handled, and then everyone will get even angrier.
- rtkwe 8y agoHaven't seen the CNN video but it was his stunts at the Capitol I see most places saying it was the video where he harassed a CNN reporter for ~10 minutes streaming it on Periscope. > Ironically, it was the initial CNN story—or rather, Jones' unhinged response to it—that proved his eventual undoing. On Wednesday, just before Dorsey was set to testify at his second congressional hearing of the day, Jones approached Darcy as he waited in line with media colleagues to be let into the hearing room. Jones, flanked by his entourage, cornered Darcy, jabbed a phone in his face, and harassed the reporter for more than 10 minutes about his work, his employer, and his looks, saying he has the "eyes of a rat." The entire ordeal streamed on Periscope, which is owned by Twitter. https://www.wired.com/story/twitter-bans-alex-jones-infowars/ https://www.wired.com/story/twitter-bans-alex-jones-infowars...
- boxspam 8y agoThe Periscope video was the last straw. Jones was angry and ranting, because that journalist had claimed that his campaigning/efforts lead to Jones' ban on social networks. > Important to note that tech platforms did not enforce their own rules and take action against Alex Jones / InfoWars on their own accord. > It took media outlets to point out for weeks that InfoWars was skirting the rules on these tech platforms for them to enforce own standards. Previous offenses include: "dehumanizing trans people". That looks very bad on paper, so you search for the video, and you see him discussing an over-the-top drag queen reading a book for children in a public library. To me, with the long nails and the thick make-up and the wig, the drag queen really looks demonic/ridiculous/freaky and he remarks on that. You should have the right to call that abnormal and refuse to want to see that normalized. Look at what happened with Pewdiepie when a media company goes on a crusade with an agenda, it is very similar. The bottom line for this decision is not harassment or abuse, it is the political preference of Twitter's employees. Maybe it is not a good idea to have a left-leaning workforce police online debate, even if it is their platform. For all the talk about diversity, SF companies sure could do with some more political diversity. They should have banned Alex Jones from public discourse when he had this crazy conspiracy theory that high-ranking politicians and businessmen workship Moloch and child sacrifice. They should have banned Alex Jones when had the crazy conspiracy theory that chemicals and pesticides in the water change the sex of frogs. They should have banned Alex Jones for saying that Lady Gaga turns satanism into a performance and flirts with illuminati symbology. They should have banned Alex Jones for stating that weather manipulation is still a thing after the Environmental Modification Convention.