6 ms·
It does seem tame, but a quick search suggests it may be an anti-semitic dog whistle.
by CharlesW 8y ago
It does seem tame, but a quick search suggests it may be an anti-semitic dog whistle.
- sheepmullet 8y agoIt seems like every comment by someone the left doesn’t like is a kind of dog whistle.
- Kye 8y agoDoesn't mean they're wrong. There's a reason they don't like those words/phrases.
- sheepmullet 8y ago> Doesn't mean they're wrong. If you have watched Alex Jones before you will know he happily speaks his mind and is not afraid to come across as offensive or crazy. It is not in his character to hide secret meanings in his content.
- Kye 8y agoHe was put on notice by Twitter with a week ban. That's the exact circumstance where someone like him would start using coded language to try and avoid a ban while still promoting his ideas. That's the purpose of coded language.
- nichochar 8y agoAh. the good old: lets criticize a generalization by making a generalization. Always a strong argument :)
- ravenstine 8y agoSince when does the broadness of an observation or argument have any impact on its validity? Who made up that rule?
- happytoexplain 8y agoI'm confident that people tend to extrapolate anecdotal negative experiences about groups of people in bad faith, and that, as the group size increases, this tendency increases relative to the availability of more objective observations. If that's true, the broader the group subjected to a negative generalization, the more likely it is that the observation is as I described. Combined with intuition about the nature of the negativity, I can sometimes feel confident expressing an opinion about the observation one way or the other (e.g. "I think X people are less conversational" vs "I think X people are mostly violent thugs").
- beat 8y agoComparing Jews to rats is a classic Nazi trope. It's actually a dog whistle, for real and true.
- dragonwriter 8y agoI'm not sure it's subtle enough to be a dog whistle; it's more like a train whistle, really.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- happytoexplain 8y agoAt least the grandparent comment had the decency to generalize about a smaller, more ideologically narrow group of people than "the right" or "the left".
- slg 8y agoSome insults are simply worse depending on who they are targeting. It is the difference between calling GW Bush a monkey because he occasionally looked like a monkey and Obama being called a monkey as a racial slur. The former is a childish insult that is easy to ignore. The latter is a form of bigotry that shouldn't be tolerated.
- ziroshima 8y agoGauging the degree to which insults are insulting or offensive (based on context!) is always going to be problematic. I find your comment a little bit disturbing because it reminds me of the Roseanne fiasco. The woman she was insulting really does look like she could have been in the planet of the apes films. Is it racist to publicly observe a similar appearance? If someone believes that Obama has a monkey-like appearance, as you believe GW Bush does, are they racist? In other words, intent is often not the same as the interpretation, which as long as we are doing trial by public opinion, I am not comfortable with.
- slg 8y agoThe person calling a black person a monkey or a Jewish person a rat is either ignorant of the history of those slurs or they aren't. If they are ignorant of that history, they can easily be excused. The ignorance is usually obvious based on their history of behavior because the accusation would likely be an isolated incident. Considering the history of accusations against Jones and Roseanne, I am pretty confident in saying they are both aware of how their words could be interpreted. If that person is aware of the history of using those comparisons and isn't racist, what is the reasoning is still using that specific language? You can call Obama any number of insults and not be called a racist. Why would you choose an insult that you know will draw racial comparisons?
- noobermin 8y agoContext is important, as is learning history.
- ryanobjc 8y agoPower dynamics are real, and the legal system deals with context all the time. So do humans, they handle it quite well in fact (hence why our languages are not context-free). I know computer people want consistency in rules. However, do you want to have a simple-minded consistency (with full invocation of Emerson intended here), or do you value full inclusion and reparative actions to restore full humanity to everyone who shares your DNA, yet were considered non-human in the past? (and still are by many people, who are actively attempting to return the past to the future.) Slavery is ugly and MOST people don't love thinking about that era. Some people DO love thinking about it, and are actively attempting to bring it back. To quote a choose your own adventure: - If you want to turn your back on historical realities, turn to page 55 - If you embrace the uncomfortable and pledge to work for the betterment of all, turn to page 100
- yitosda 8y agoMuch of the point of a dog whistle (as I understand it) is plausible deniability. The parent comment stands: shutting it down over something that "may mean something" -- even though with context you may be quite sure -- is a bad look. The next step is simply to point at the myriad of other times anyone called someone a rat on Twitter and Twitter is left to defend a position of shutting people down over what they were thinking when they wrote something. They should have used one of the many better reasons they had for this this case.
- staticassertion 8y agoOr we should just be willing to call dog whistles what they are and stop feeling the need to respond when people cry 'but that person used the word rat over there!'.
- yitosda 8y agoIt's possible I've been living under a rock, but while I'm aware of rat being pejorative, I'm finding out in this thread for the first time about the anti-semitic undertones. It's pretty clear that the difference is context, but I also don't think there can be clear guidelines if Twitter is expected to delve into the context for each tweet its users make. In fairness, context typically doesn't provide smoking guns as pungent as this one. I'd still say it's not beyond reasonable doubt (and I'd guess most would be ok with that for a Twitter ban -- it's not prison or death). So, sure, everyone should call it a dog whistle on the preponderance of evidence, but there were almost certainly better grounds for the ban. I doubt there will ever be a good ban target whose only giveaway is dog whistles.
- MBCook 8y agoI was aware of it, but I couldn’t have told you about it without prompting. I didn’t remember it that well. As soon as someone mentioned what it was it made perfect sense to me. Yeah, that’s the complex part of all of this. As you said context is king here, and Jones is very well known for making implicit or explicit derogatory remarks about Jewish people. There really isn’t room for him to claim “I didn’t know that“. > there were almost certainly better grounds for the ban I think you’re right that this was sort of a cherry pick. He’s done way more than enough stuff in the past to earn him a ban but they never acted on it. After the hearing and his behavior immediately after I’m guessing they were tired of defending him and having to answer these questions AGAIN. But it would seem especially strange/capricious just say “that thing you did three months ago that we gave you a pass on? Now you’re out.“ So I think they just chose the latest thing as their “instigating” incident and said that plus the totality of his previous behavior meant a total ban. Even though the most recent thing is not as bad (relative to his previous ‘highs’).
- AdmiralAsshat 8y agoIs Oliver Darcy Jewish?
- MBCook 8y agoDoes it matter? If this kind of behavior is against the platform rules, should the rules only apply if someone can prove that the person didn’t make a mistake in who they were targeting?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- theseatoms 8y agoThere's a funny irony in suggesting that one heard a dog whistle.
- uptown 8y agoThat’s kind of the point. It’s a message intended to be “heard” by a certain audience but not everyone the same way dogs hear a dog whistle but most humans do not.
- bachbach 8y agoI am not a fan of Alex Jones but he is not an anti-semite. In fact I suspect you have it backward. Jones will be intimately aware of (some of) the far left and (some of) far right anti-semite culture - it takes some character to see the big picture and in my personal exhaustive experience with that world most people exposed to those cultures would become anti-semites fast. Jone's nemesis is altogether more abstract - he sees himself as crusader against a modern meme similar to communism or fascism.
- noobermin 8y agoI've seen clips of Alex Jones deriding Brian Stelter, zooming into his face, calling him a "devil" and a "demon" of all things. It was rather surreal. What could Alex Jones possibly getting at with that? I think it's possible many people don't have much experience with anti-semitism so it seems unrelated (as for me) but given Jones' track record and other clips I've seen of him, it's pretty clear he plays with anti-semitism.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bachbach 8y agoI have a lot of experience with anti-semitism - I've followed many extreme forums over the years and it's one of the most consistent patterns - even in oppositional ideologies. Alex Jones is influential enough that he could, to use the parlance 'name the jew' and most of his followers would follow along with it or he would get new ones. If you think that he would find himself marginalized you are absolutely wrong - that would only occur at one level of society and the polite part isn't close to being meaningful - there is a huge market for this. Throwing all people you find objectionable into one bucket is an error.
- drfuchs 8y agoQuite. See, for example, the 1940 Nazi propaganda film "The Eternal Jew." Quoting Wikipedia: "The film utilizes a montage that juxtaposes these images of ghetto Jews with images of rats to draw an analogy between the migration of Jews from Eastern Europe with the migration of rats. For example, one of the shots shows a pack of rats emerging from a sewer, followed by a shot of a crowd of Jews in a bustling street of the Łódź Ghetto. Close-ups of those in the crowd reveal sickly, malformed facial features. The narrator states that, as rats are the vermin of the animal kingdom, Jews are the vermin of the human race and similarly spread disease and corruption."
- T4NG 8y ago"anti-semitic" really dude?