6 ms·
So, the strongest and most common objection against the English rule is that it would prevent the poor from suing even if they had a good case; they just couldn
by jessriedel 16y ago
So, the strongest and most common objection against the English rule is that it would prevent the poor from suing even if they had a good case; they just couldn't afford a 10% chance of owing thousands of dollars. I am very sympathetic to this objection.
But can't this be (mostly) solved by having the lawyers take on the risk?
Already, lawyers will offer to work for free unless the plaintiff wins. ("You pay nothing unless we recover on your behalf.") That is, they risk their own time--but will do so only if they think there is a good case. This makes sense because it is the lawyers, not the plaintiffs, who are best able to assess the likelihood of winning.
So then couldn't lawyers also take on the risk of paying fees if the litigation is unsuccessful? Is this legal in the US or elsewhere? Is it done?
(Also, I think I heard somewhere about a guy who couldn't afford to sue a large company which stole his invention. Apparently, he had an IPO to offer stock in the lawsuit. He won, and both he and his investors were paid. Anyone remember this or have a link?)
- sxdfvgbnhjhgbv 16y agoBut then it's not based on the chance of winning it's based on the likelyhood of a quick settlement and the amount they are likely to get. Suing a council/schoolboard/hospital - likely to win (they don't defend strongly) and likely to be a big pay out (it's not their money). Suing a large corporation with their own expensive laywers = not worth the risk.
- roel_v 16y ago"Already, lawyers will offer to work for free unless the plaintiff wins." In the US, yes. Not in Europe. Here in the Netherlands, it's actually prohibited by the rules of the (loosely translated) National Bar Association to take a case on a 'no cure, no pay' basis. This article is misinformed and misleading. The legal culture is very different between the US and mainland Europe. The claims that are being made in the article are largely misrepresentations of what actually happens; for example, her in the Netherlands the amount a judge can (but doesn't have to, and often does only in part) award the loser to pay for the legal costs of the winner is based on a quotum, i.e. not on the real costs, but on a fictitious per-hour amount, which is lower than actual commercial rates (one notable exception is for IP infringements, where the full cost can be claimed).
- ElliotH 16y agoHere in the UK it is incredibly common, especially with cases like injury at work. Known as 'No-Win No-Fee' in adverts.
- iuytguyhj 16y agoIt's getting less common now that local councils are actually fighting the claims. Before suing a local council or the NHS was a guaranteed win, often out of court - so the lawyer couldn't lose and it was worth taking a no-win no-fee. Now that they go to court a lot of them are demanding the client pay a hefty insurance premium up front - of course that's not a 'fee'.
- Silhouette 16y ago> So, the strongest and most common objection against the English rule is that it would prevent the poor from suing even if they had a good case; they just couldn't afford a 10% chance of owing thousands of dollars. I am very sympathetic to this objection. That is very unlikely. Courts are not generally required to award costs to the winner of a case here in England, it is more of a default in most cases instead of adopting "everyone pays their own costs" as in the US. I am not a legal expert, but I doubt a court would award crippling costs to a little guy who brought a case with genuine merit against a big guy but lost, where the little guy incurred only modest costs but the big guy brought the whole legal team to bear. Likewise, I doubt a big guy bringing a punitive law suit against a little guy and incurring lots of costs when they could have settled things in another less expensive way would get much sympathy, which is why the US seems to have certain Big Media organisings effectively extorting settlements from innocent people for thousands of dollars, while such behaviour is unheard of in this country. > Already, lawyers will offer to work for free unless the plaintiff wins. I guess you're referring to so-called "no win, no fee" agreements? If so, it's not quite as simple as that (the lawyers also stand to gain more if they win than they would in a regular case), but your general argument still works.
- jessriedel 16y ago>Courts are not generally required to award costs to the winner of a case here in England, it is more of a default in most cases instead of adopting "everyone pays their own costs" as in the US. Thanks, I didn't know this. I'm still not convinced that the threat of legal fees wouldn't convince a non-insignificant fraction of poor plaintiffs not to sue. > I guess you're referring to so-called "no win, no fee" agreements? If so, it's not quite as simple as that (the lawyers also stand to gain more if they win than they would in a regular case)... I know. In effect, the lawyer is selling insurance to the client. The client will get less in case of a win both because (a) he bought insurance, which brings his variance down (and so, his total payout in case of a win is lower) and (b) the lawyer collects a premium for absorbing the risk.
- irons 16y agoI am not a legal expert, but I doubt a court would award crippling costs to a little guy who brought a case with genuine merit against a big guy but lost, where the little guy incurred only modest costs but the big guy brought the whole legal team to bear. That's a whole lot of conditionals. In places where the judiciary is thoroughly corrupted by electioneering (coal interests in West Virginia, for instance), relying on judges to respond non-punitively can be an unsafe assumption already. A libertarian loser-pays movement only slants that further.
- jsmcgd 16y agoIsn't the fact that you are guaranteed to pay legal fees, which the poor will always find expensive, to be the greater obstacle to suing? I think the 'English rule' would encourage many poor people to litigate if they believed their case was strong.
- jessriedel 16y ago> Isn't the fact that you are guaranteed to pay legal fees, which the poor will always find expensive, to be the greater obstacle to suing? With correct insurance/lawyer-agreements, the poor can set it up so that they have no chance of paying anything. In effect, they sell part of the expected value of their suit to decrease their variance to the point that they do not pay money in any circumstance. >I think the 'English rule' would encourage many poor people to litigate if they believed their case was strong. Well, to be precise, it would encourage many poor people to litigate if their lawyer (or their insurance company) believed their case was strong. And isn't this exactly what we want? That justice is pursued?
- georgecmu 16y agoWith correct insurance/lawyer-agreements, the poor can set it up so that they have no chance of paying anything. It's not obvious that loser-pays would prevent them from setting it up as well.
- joe_the_user 16y agoI have friend who cases against the police and others on a contingency basis. Believe me, they do not have any capital to invest to indemnifying their client against a judgment. None. The possibilities of losing a fair amount of money in case of this sort would essentially write the police a blank check to engage in whatever without threat of lawsuit.
- georgecmu 16y agoI don't think the commenter I replied had these types of cases in mind. I think he meant "We don't get paid unless we get money for you" ambulance chaser type of lawyers.
- dantheman 16y agoPerhaps an insurance system would develop where you pay a portion of your winnings to the insurer if the suit wins, and they pay out if it loses. In this way we can leverage market forces to help determine the validity of cases.
- jessriedel 16y agoExactly. I only suggested lawyers offering the insurance, but as you and someone else in this thread mentioned, it's also plausible for their to be dedicated agencies. It's not clear to me which would be more efficient.
- Tangurena 16y ago> So, the strongest and most common objection against the English rule is that it would prevent the poor from suing even if they had a good case; they just couldn't afford a 10% chance of owing thousands of dollars. The majority of cases where the litigant is "poor" involve contingency fees (the lawyer gets nothing unless they win), and contingency fees are considered unethical (to the point you'll get disbarred) in most European countries. I would add the issue where if contingency fees are any part of the lawyer's payment scheme, the lawyer would also be jointly and severally liable for the legal fees of the winning party. I see three possibilities for this outcome - every case gets settled on the courthouse steps (as opposed to about half these days) or the lawyers fight everything to the bitter end (and there will be no more settling on the courthouse), and finally, much less litigation. At the moment, the "rediculous" judgements that people complain about (one poster child is the McDonald's coffee case) are acting as a subsidy for lawyers. Without this subsidy, far less cases will be filed I've strongly considered running with this idea as a ballot initiative in my state.
- extension 16y agoI would encourage you to look at the details of the McDonalds coffee case before using it as an example. Particularly, that the plaintif was hospitalized for 8 days and underwent skin grafts, and that McDonalds serves their coffee significantly hotter than culinary taste demands, despite hundreds of reported injuries and previous settlements. That doesn't necessarily mean the outcome was justified, but it certainly wasn't a frivolous case.
- loewenskind 16y agoShe also didn't get millions. She initially won big but it was later overturned on the grounds that McDonalds was being singled out for being successful (i.e. having deep pockets to pay that kind of damage).
- Tangurena 16y agoI know it was not frivolous. That does not stop people from attacking it as an example of "what is wrong with the world."
- joe_the_user 16y ago"But can't this be (mostly) solved by having the lawyers take on the risk?" I suppose the stereotype of the trial lawyer as some deep-pocketed capitalist still prevails up to the present day. It's not so anymore. There's been a lawyer glut for some time and the lawyer who makes their living suing for the "little guy" or even the medium-sized-guy has no extra equity to invest in extra risk taking, they're mostly barely earning a living. " That is, they risk their own time--but will do so only if they think there is a good case." Perhaps you could think about this - lawyers risk their own time because ... they have it, not necessarily having a whole lot of the business. A similar lawyer won't risk their own money because ... they have children to feed as well as offices to rent, etc...