10 ms·
Probiotics labelled 'quite useless'
- sschueller 8y agoIsn't the idea to give probiotics to people who do not have a healthy gut? Such as someone who had been taking antibiotic for a prolonged period of time? So why did they give the probiotic to 25 healthy individuals? Also 25 seems like a very small sample. Edit: it appears they also did a study on 46 people after taking antibiotics but that I still find to be a small sample size.
- andreygrehov 8y agoDid you even read the article? --- The research group also looked at the impact of probiotics after a course of antibiotics, which wipe out both good and bad bacteria. Their trial on 46 people, also in the journal Cell, showed it led to delays in the normal healthy bacteria re-establishing themselves. Dr Elinav added: "Contrary to the current dogma that probiotics are harmless and benefit everyone, these results reveal a new potential adverse side effect of probiotic use with antibiotics that might even bring long-term consequences." ---
- olooney 8y agoThis type of comment is explicitly mentioned in the Hacker News Guidelines: > Please don't insinuate that someone hasn't read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- genomer 8y agoHow else do we dissuade people who don't read an article from jumping to ignorant conclusions and filling the message board with tripe?
- pvg 8y agoAlso described right in the comment you are replying to.
- genomer 8y agoAre you insinuating that I didn't read the comment? I take such offense to this.
- ghostbrainalpha 8y agoThe comment you are referencing is in accordance with this section of the guidelines. >>Please don't insinuate that someone hasn't read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that." It is ok to point out facts from the article. We just try not to go overboard with it. I know it might seem pedantic, but over time it really does result in a better community.
- NikolaNovak 8y agoIn Canada at least,probiotics are largely bought of the shelf by healthy people. Last week I accidentally bought a bottle of water from seven eleven,which turned out to have probiotics added. Cost the same as regular water too...
- genomer 8y agoI was surprised by a probiotic addition the other day as well. It was added to a vegan protein powder I bought off the shelf.
- bena 8y agoDo you think it's really an addition or something that was in there already they could market as a probiotic? Like how a lot of things became "gluten free" despite not containing gluten to begin with.
- joshuagross 8y agoGluten free also refers to processing. If something is made in the same facility / alongside a product with gluten it’s a serious problem with people with Celiac.
- WalterSear 8y agoIME, most things in 7-11 have probiotics added.
- travisjungroth 8y ago25 and 46 are plenty large sample sizes for something that should have a large effect. I agree that I've always thought of probiotics only for recovery after antibiotics or stomach illness.
- guelo 8y agoIn the article it mentions that they studied using probiotics after antibiotics and it actually did more harm than good.
- Someone1234 8y agoDoes this potentially also have consequences for fecal transplants? That has been an upcoming area of research and relies on a similar idea: You can colonise bateria. If they aren't going to stick around via probiotics, they may also not via fecal.
- WalterSear 8y agoDifferent bacteria, different condition, different delivery methods. As the article states - "The researchers said probiotics of the future would need tailoring to the needs of each individual."
- Havoc 8y agoI'd conclude the opposite. If in half the cases the newly introduced bacteria "lingered" before being expelled then that demonstrates some kind of traction. e.g. You might just need to combine that with a diet that favours the new bacteria you're trying to introduce. i.e. Some sort of effect in 50% of the cases is better than I expected honestly
- jpmoyn 8y agoI mean maybe, but that's just speculation, and it really doesn't get us anywhere. The main point of the article is that off the shelf probiotics don't do the wonders they are toted to. You would have to have probiotics tailored to the unique bacterial composition inside of your gut.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The main point of the article is that off the shelf probiotics don't do the wonders they are toted to. That's the main claim. OTOH, they didn't test any off-the-shelf probiotic products in isolation, they tested their own custom probiotic mix.
- WalterSear 8y ago> During the probiotics phase participants consumed Supherb Bio-25 bi-daily, which is described by the manufacturer to contain at least 25 billion active bacteria of the following strains: B. bifidum, L. rhamnosus, L. lactis, L. casei, B. breve, S. thermophilus, B. longum sbsp. longum, L. paracasei, L. plantarum and B. longum sbsp. infantis. According to the manufacturer, the pills underwent double coating to ensure their survival under stomach acidity and their proliferation in the intestines. Validation of the aforementioned strains quantity and viability was performed as part of the study. https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(18)31102-4?_returnURL=https%3A%2F%2Flinkinghub.elsevier.com%2Fretrieve%2Fpii%2FS0092867418311024%3Fshowall%3Dtrue#secsectitle0075 https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(18)31102-4?_re...
- gdubs 8y agoYea, I agree. I'd also add that we know so little about the gut biome at this stage that it feels presumptuous to assume that just because the biome looked 'different' afterwards, means that it's a 'bad' outcome. Even among healthy individuals there seems to be a lot of variability in the gut biome, and I'm wary of claims that one is 'good' and the other is 'bad' without more evidence. On the other hand, seems like we can say with a high level of confidence that antibiotics are devastating to bacteria :)
- Bucephalus355 8y agoDoes anyone believe anything these articles say anymore? About two weeks ago, two somewhat prominent doctors from Harvard Medical School got into an enormous disagreement over whether or not coconut oil was “healthy” or “killing you”. No one knows anything under the current system. There is absolutely no way the public can reasonably believe yay or nay on any new thing about healthy living.
- ChrisSD 8y agoThere hasn't been any truly new thing in healthy living in decades. Everybody knows they should exercise regularly and eat a variety of fruits and vegetables. Everything else is purely of academic interest at the moment.
- chadash 8y agoI'd expand those recommendations a little bit: - Exercise regularly - Eat a variety of fruits and veggies - Don't overeat, especially junk food (we can argue over which foods are good or bad for you, but a lot of our diets consist of things such as potato chips that are obviously bad for you, at least in large quantities) - Stay hydrated - Don't be too stressed
- bosie 8y agoSleep? ;)
- always_good 8y agoYeah, the whole appeal of the supplement industry, exercise infomercial contraptions, and insulin regimens for T2 diabetes is that they don't require lifestyle change which is the whole challenge of being healthy.
- castlecrasher2 8y agoThere are a few things that have been useful, though I'm not sure if they were recent but considering how we in the US were raised to eat they've helped me quite a bit: the effect of low-carb diet and intermittent fasting on insulin resistance are the two that have helped me recently.
- yeahdef 8y agoone yakult a day has been highly beneficial to me.
- PaulHoule 8y agoProbiotics always struck me as one of those pills that mother gives you that don't do anything at all. These products were developed commercially based on what they could make and not on any analysis of what a person's intestinal flora should be, nor any proof that the deliver system worked.
- willio58 8y agoAll commercial products are developed based on potential profit.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoWouldn't be a problem if the producers weren't also lying about their effects. And people ask why so much hate towards marketing industry...
- PaulHoule 8y agoThen you need alignment. One of those cases where the patent model works is the development of prescription drugs. The possibility of monopoly profits leads pharma companies to develop and test drugs and run them through a regulatory gauntlet. Critics say it is expensive, but it does work in the sense that new drugs get invented and some of them really are a boon. For something like fish oil you can do the research but it benefits everybody else who sells fish oil, which, oddly enough, lowers my blood triglycerides like a drug although having put up no real benefits other than that for years.
- cwkoss 8y agoThis article is a great example of how scientifically illiterate modern society has become.
- chadash 8y ago> "The research group also looked at the impact of probiotics after a course of antibiotics, which wipe out both good and bad bacteria. Their trial on 46 people, also in the journal Cell, showed it led to delays in the normal healthy bacteria re-establishing themselves. Dr Elinav added: "Contrary to the current dogma that probiotics are harmless and benefit everyone, these results reveal a new potential adverse side effect of probiotic use with antibiotics that might even bring long-term consequences." If you only read the first few paragraphs (where they discussed the effect of probiotics on healthy people) you might have missed this important piece of information. This discovery is hardly surprising. Probiotics aren't regulated by the FDA as drugs, but rather as "food supplements", which basically means they have the same standard of regulation as regular food [1]. [1] To be sold as a drug (i.e. pharmaceutical) a product must undergo rigorous trials to show efficacy and find any unintended side effects. Clinical trials typically cost around $60-80 million, which is part of the reason drugs are so expensive.
- foobaw 8y agoOne of my friends who has severe dietary/gut problems did several isolated experiments on himself with different probiotics and found success from very specific ones like PHGG and GOS..
- maxxxxx 8y agoIt may also depends on how you get them. For example somebody told me that turmeric helps with joint inflammation. Bought some turmeric capsules and they did nothing. But then I used it in cooking and it definitely makes a difference for my joint pain. It comes back while traveling and I don't get turmeric. But as soon as I get home and eat my own food the joint pain gets better. It also gets worse when I stop using turmeric in my own cooking for a while.
- pc86 8y agoThat's very interesting, is your joint pain from arthritis, injury, or something else? Does anything other than turmeric help? Does your OTC pain reliever of choice like advil/aleve/tylenol help?
- maxxxxx 8y agoIt's inflammation which then makes everything worse. Cooling the joints often helps. Avoiding sugar is very important. It gives me a lot of pain. Pain relievers don't seem to help much and I also don't want to live on a daily diet of them.
- mrfusion 8y agoDo you buy a special brand or will generic tumeric from the spice shelf at publix work?
- maxxxxx 8y agoI get it from Mountain Rose Herbs and grind it myself. I keep the powder only for a few weeks.
- 8y ago
- sorokod 8y agoLooked at a actimel (https://www.actimel.co.uk/faq_about https://www.actimel.co.uk/faq_about) and yakult (https://www.yakult.co.uk/ https://www.yakult.co.uk/) and was surprised by how little they attribute to the "good bacteria". Yakult promises that: is scientifically proven to reach the gut alive (!) Was that always like that?
- TeMPOraL 8y agoFrom the days I was a teenager and we had TV at home in Poland, I remember the brand "Actimel" being all about "good bacteria". So this must have changed recently. My guess is, the EU told them to stop spewing bullshit in commercials. EDIT: This might indeed have had something to do with 2007 change in EU's health regulations, as per https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Actimel#Debates_surrounding_health_claims_on_probiotic_foods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Actimel#Debates_surrounding_he....
- sorokod 8y agoThis is from yakult us, boy this is underwhelming: Because everyone's biological make-up is unique, each one of us may experience our own unique health benefits Generally speaking, Yakult may help balance your digestive system.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoI'm pretty sure it's solid science that probiotics definitely help at treating or preventing certain digestive tract disorders/diseases. For instance, SIBO: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28267052 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28267052 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3329544/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3329544/
- WalterSear 8y agoInteresting science. But, I don't feel that the second is a legitimate use of meta-analyses. Due to publication bias, the conclusions it draws are only useful if the efficacy of probiotics is a forgone conclusion. Moreover: I have a huge question regarding their primary measure, specifically regarding their use of number from this study: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14608267 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14608267 Which show up as the 8th line of their risk-ratio calculation, but whose results have no relation to the values on that graph. Moreover, this isn't peer reviewed, as far as I could see.
- harshreality 8y agoIt doesn't seem very surprising that if you keep eating mostly what you normally eat, your microbiome is already well-adapted to that diet and will out compete almost anything new you try to introduce. I would expect if they tried limiting their diet to foods compatible with the probiotics, they'd get more significant results, because the existing microbiome colonies would be stressed from lack of their usual junk/meat/fat and be weaker. (Almost all standard probiotics, other than dairy varieties [yogurt etc], are veg-carb-loving.) Before refrigeration, there couldn't have been many probiotics consumed in isolated form rather than as fermented foods. Give the new bacteria some food to eat when they're trying to out-compete your existing (bad parts of your) gut microbiome. One of the most likely good foods for them to eat is what they've been cultured on. It may not even be necessary to eat probiotics, if you already have some of the bacteria you want, you merely need to encourage it to out-compete bad microbiome bacterial strains. Eat food compatible with the good bacteria. But it's such a hassle to change diets, everyone wants a pill or a powder or one serving of probiotics they can add to their diet, keep everything else the same, and have the bad bacteria / imbalance miraculously disappear. Is it any surprise that's less likely to work?
- LinuxBender 8y agoProbiotics used incorrectly can have mixed results; and thus, there will be endless religious debates on the matter. If the reason you are taking them is to cull dangerous bacteria such as H.pylori, you would first have to bring their numbers down to a point where the probiotics have a fighting chance. This is typically either done with anti-biotics, or a combination of supplements such as aged garlic, mastic gum, coconut oil, etc... to first kill things off. Then after taking the probiotics, the candida overgrowth has to be purged with garlic extract. Very few people will take the time to go through the right steps throughout the days/weeks required to balance things out. This lends itself to a wide variability in results.
- blacksmith_tb 8y agoH. pylori isn't a yeast? Or did you mean that the probiotics would include yeasts (possible, certainly, like S. boulardii, but it dies off by itself pretty quickly). Though of course the process you describe is similar to what anyone taking a course of antibiotics to treat an illness could do, I was hospitalized after being hit by truck and given lots of kefir along with my antibiotics.
- LinuxBender 8y agoH.pylori is a bacteria. When you add bacteria in large amounts to compensate, they will cause candida overgrowth which is a fungus. The fungus has to be killed off.
- ghostbrainalpha 8y agoI had chronic I.B.S. for many years, which I talk about here way too much. Basically I used to poop my pants weekly and couldn't work in an office. Probiotics and keeping my eating to an 8 hour window (Intermittent Fasting) basically solved the issue for me. However it makes sense to me that probiotics wouldn't do anything for someone who already has healthy gut bacteria.
- kazinator 8y ago> Basically I used to poop my pants weekly and couldn't work in an office. Any office? Even the U.S. Patent Office?
- dragonwriter 8y agoIt's funny that this research claims is spin to prove that supermarket probiotics are useless, but instead of broadly testing actual supermarket probiotics products, or even testing a single such product, it tests a single specific custom blend product created by the research team. At best, they've shown that blend to be quite useless as tested.
- yellowapple 8y agoSeems like a pointless study if you're only sampling people who are already healthy. "Probiotics don't do anything if you already have a healthy gut." Yeah, no shit, Sherlock.
- Jeff_Brown 8y agoThe main purpose of probiotics I've heard of is to repopulate a gut that's been wiped out by antibiotics. This experiment was performed on 25 healthy subjects; its results don't seem to bear on that purpose.
- evolve2k 8y ago“These are very innovative studies, but they are preliminary findings that need replicating.”