7 ms·
>They have no values no morals or ethics. This is really not quite true because the companies are not run by some faceless AI -- they're run by actual people w
by dboreham 8y ago
>They have no values no morals or ethics.
This is really not quite true because the companies are not run by some faceless AI -- they're run by actual people who have to interact with other humans such as their friends and family, are concerned about being allowed into the country club and so on. So there is some back-pressure against total amorality, albeit not codified.
- nf05papsjfVbc 8y agoUltimately, people will behave as per their incentives. As long as the push back and the negative publicity from it threatens a greater loss than the profits from thing they were about to do, they'll back off. Otherwise, I don't think they'll mind letting go of a few people (maybe even to make examples of them) and push ahead.
- chooseaname 8y agoExactly. Facebook's primary objective is to return as much value (money) to investors as possible. The way they treat the users of the system, their employees, local governments, etc. is all a reflection of that.
- close04 8y agoThat's the fiduciary duty of every CEO: Duties of care, loyalty and disclosure. The loyalty is the most important one because it involves having the best interest of the shareholders in mind. This very simplified means "increase value". If this is done taking into account all available information, no info is ignored, no info is hidden, then there is nothing more to say. The CEO has done their job. There is no mandate for a business to be ethical, moral unless this is considered to be in the best interest of the shareholders. Is FB value going up or down if FB decides to be moral and ethical towards the users? That answers the question "why are only some companies moral". Apple for example decided to take the high road and be the champion of user privacy because they failed to compete with FB, Google, and the likes in the battle for users' data. So adopting a "moral/ethical" position opposing others was the way to bring value to the company. Companies are not people. Decisions are driven by profit whether in the short or long term.
- adamc 8y agoOne might reasonably think there should be mandates to be ethical, moral, etc. Society at large does not benefit from allowing companies to act as amoral predators. Which is what you describe above.
- nradov 8y agoAnd we do codify some of those ethical and moral mandates in the form of laws and government regulations. Ultimately the only way to ensure that companies consistently behave well is to elect politicians who will force them to do so.
- tareqak 8y agoWhy not add them to a company's charter? I guess it would scare away potential investors, but maybe other investors would be attracted by them.
- dgzl 8y agoI'm in the camp that doesn't believe a free society should be mandating individual morals. Edit: leaving ethics out of this.
- dragonwriter 8y agoAll laws are inherently mandates of ethics/morals. Edit: to address the parent edit to remove “ethics” and distinguish “morals” for different treatment, the division of subjective preferences into “ethics” and “morals" (and “aesthetics”, for that matter) is fairly arbitrary and subjective in any case.
- quotemstr 8y agoGood laws are conservative codifications of consensus morality. A just legal code forbids only what the vast majority would consider wrong regardless of the law. When the law forbids what people don't consider wrong, it becomes tyranny.
- dwaltrip 8y agoMonetary incentives, while very powerful and something that must be reckoned with, are not the only incentives that exist.
- pathseeker 8y agoAnd Facebook doesn't have much beyond monetary incentives at this point. There is clearly no 'greater good' they are striving for and any interesting scaling technical work can be found at any of the other big tech companies.
- coldtea 8y agoFor individuals yes. For the kind of aggregates we call public companies, no. The push there is towards profit, and humans are rewarded or replaced based on that.
- dwaltrip 8y agoI apologize for the late reply. The idea for this response came to me just now as I was absently-minded scrolling through old comments, and I wanted to try expressing it. Don't feel obligated to respond. I think we agree that individual humans are driven by a diverse set of incentives and motivations, some of which cause the pursuit financial gain, but many of which do not. It seems that you are saying that a public company is an entity that purely seeks financial gain (at least, as its meta-objective -- e.g. it may take actions that it believes will increase profits in a rather indirect way, with direct monetary loss initially), and that non-monetary incentives are not a meaningful factor. Please correct me if I don't have that right. Public companies are made up of people, so if your above argument is to hold, it requires that the non-monetary incentives driving those individuals are _utterly and completely_ suppressed, at least for any actions and decisions related to their work. I can believe that the non-monetary incentives are _heavily_ suppressed by the company, but I don't think this suppression is so utterly effective such that those incentives should be entirely disregarded. I'm not sure how much weight we should place on these other factors, but it certainly seems that it usually won't be 0.
- rayvy 8y ago> This is really not quite true because the companies are not run by some faceless AI I'd say when your #1 goal is to "return value to shareholders" (at virtually any cost), you're not too far from it
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- drb91 8y agoIndividually, maybe. But the organization having morals? It's hard to tell what that would even look like.
- dboreham 8y agoI'm talking about only individuals. Ultimately they have to go golfing somewhere, with someone. Unless they build their own golf course. Oh wait...
- coldtea 8y agoMost of the people they golf with could not care less if they suppress rights here and there. They either applaud it, or have themselves gotten rich doing similar shit...
- dboreham 8y agoAgreed, they can live inside a sociopath bubble. I doubt Sheryl Sandberg does though.
- drb91 8y agoSure, but humans have immense ability to rationalize their own behavior. I highly doubt this is a pressure comparable to profit seeking. Furthermore, SV is a bubble, and FB is one too. Why would you think there would be pressure from outside the bubble if they only hire people who are enthusiastic about FB to begin with? The people playing golf probably share a world view from the get go.
- FussyZeus 8y agoThis effect works for a small or even large business, but for a multinational super-corp? Forget it, these companies are machines designed to abstract decisions away to numbers and dissolve actual responsibility. We should not expect corporations to choose to act morally. We should regulate them so they don't have the choice.
- eximius 8y agoIf I have 10 people and 5 moral dilemmas but only 2 or 3 people care about each dilemma, then it is very likely the group will fail on all 5 dilemmas due to lack of collective action. This problem scales well to more people and problems. Corporations generally do not act morally because the number of people willing to halt the company to maintain them is well below the majority. However, they are generally all aligned to further the bottom line of the business.
- bopbop 8y agoWhy is this being downvoted? How does this not add to the discussion? The fact it's also a completely accurate and concise summary of human political behaviour is beside the point. Edit: so now this comment is also being down voted. The parents comment is a concise description of human group behaviour.
- tomhoward 8y agoYour comment is downvoted because it breaks the official site guideline to not comment about downvotes. The parent is no longer downvoted. That's one of the main reasons why we're asked not to comment about downvotes; because negative comment karma is often temporary, but comments about it are permanent.
- bopbop 8y agoThat makes sense, thanks for explaining.
- true_religion 8y agoIf ten people cannot even get majority agree on any one of five different moral issues, then those issues are not universal. At worst, they are not evem issues but someones pet peeve.
- eximius 8y agoI did not say that they couldn't agree, but they they aren't motivated to provoke action uniformly. If your manager says 'Do X.', where X is a mild violation of some one's privacy or some such, can you get the majority of your coworkers to collaborate and refuse your manager? Or will most go on with their lives because they don't care enough about that particular pet cause or 'it isn't that bad'.
- crunchlibrarian 8y agoIncreasingly some departments decision making processes are actually being run by some faceless AI. Even worse, the humans pretend the problems they created will go away if they just sprinkle some magic AI fairy dust on it. Either way it's a completely unacceptable dodge, especially for Facebook and Google.
- Pica_soO 8y agoThat is why there is a process. In the process, nobody pushes the bad button. There is a button polisher. A button ladder bringer. A button protection board builder. A goods on protection board stapler. And the one guy, who must declare that, the protection board over the button collapsed and pressed the button. We are very sorry. The only power to rival these- the state, the giant to protect our common interests, is bound, gagged and blinded today by liberal propaganda, as not to interfere with these processes.
- seppin 8y ago> they're run by actual people who have to interact with other humans such as their friends and family Who need to continue to recruit people who do have actual values. It's still a play for them
- tareqak 8y agoI disagree. These businesses are run by an AI, but one with many faces, which makes the consequences of their decisions very similar if not identical to that of a "faceless AI". It's not run by an electronic AI by any means, but it is as if each and every employee is an instance of the "Chinese room" [0]. Each individual in the system is focused on a set of local objectives, may or may not have their own individual biases, and have varying capacities when it comes to predicting the future and reflecting on the past. The leadership have de jure full granular control, but not de facto full granular control and can only really make big changes or none at all. The net result of these interactions are what the users see on the outside. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- GW150914 8y agoYou do know what the “A” in AI stands for? I’m not disagreeing with your central point, although I think given how well the incentives of the leadership are with most outcomes debates about their degree of control are not really important. At the end of the day though, if you’re calling people or a system made up people an AI, you’re bending the term past the breaking point in a way I feel obscures and distracts from your actual point.
- tareqak 8y agoThat's a fair point. What would be the correct term? A user of a website or a customer of sufficiently-large business not dealing with only one single human being, but a multitude of them behind a few human and computer agents. The user or customer could judge the system or organization's decision-making ability based on the difference between the expected and actual outcome with respect to the "humanness" the outcome.
- GW150914 8y agoGroup Intelligence? Honestly I’m not sure, I just know that it isn’t artificial in the sense of AI, sorry.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y agoThey run by lots of little people each working their small part of the picture. This creates a machine that will grind up people and spit them out in ways the little people would never themselves agree to do. If you get the attention of someone who can temporarily halt the entire process you can get humane treatment (such as people who post complaints here or on twitter that gets far more done than any amount of going through customer service), but most people don't have that luxury. How far will this system support totally amoral actions? One just has to consider cases such as Nestle and their baby formula to see it will allow immoral actions up to and including causing the death of children.
- arbitrary_name 8y agoThey are run by actual people who -must claim fiduciary duty to shareholders - Can delegate decisionmaking - Can obfuscate facts or decision factors - Are part of a country club that is full of other people of a similar mindset - Are insulated to the effects of their decisionmaking by wealth and privilege White collar crimes or misjudgements in the corporate world are barely, if ever, punished, at least in the us.
- lann 8y ago> must claim fiduciary duty to shareholders This isn't true, and I can't tell if this view has been promulgated by decision makers who want to hide behind it or the shareholders to whom the mythical duty is owed. Probably both I guess? "modern corporate law does not require for-profit corporations to pursue profit at the expense of everything else" https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-supreme-court/13-354.html https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-supreme-court/13-354.html
- chrischen 8y agoThe company people can only do what they are supposed to do. They have less control over things than you think. If there's one person that actually sets morals or ethics, it'd be Mark Zuckerberg, since he has control over the stock as well.
- charlesism 8y ago> they're run by actual people who have to > interact with other humans such as their > friends and family Human beings are very talented at rationalizing all manner of terrible decisions. It's no problem enacting shameful policies. Just dream up a narrative where "it turns out, this is actually a good thing for customers!" Then fool yourself into believing it, and you won't lose sleep at night.