11 ms·
Loser-Pays makes lawsuits fairer in Europe. It could work in US, too
- shasta 16y agoOr how about a day-long hearing, early into the process, where a judge looks at the balance of evidence and decides who's going to be paying for the next phase of the trial?
- shib71 16y agoDoesn't the US already have a form of this, in that losers are sometimes required to pay their opponents' litigation fees?
- tzs 16y agoThe article fails to take into account the different role of government in Europe compares to the US when it comes to ensuring civil rights. The US approach tends toward creating a civil cause of action for civil rights violations, and then leaving it up to the victim to enforce the law via a lawsuit. Most of the rest of the world tends toward having the government deal with civil rights enforcement. Your employer denies you a promotion because of your race, sex, or religion? Complain to the appropriate government agency and they deal with the problem. Landlord won't rent to your kind? Take it to the bureaucrats. Lawsuits are almost always risky, even if you have a pretty good case. If we had a loser pays system, that would greatly discourage the poor (and probably much of the middle class) from pursuing litigation when their civil rights have been violated. The potential monetary losses are just too great. A lower pays system might work, if coupled with a rewrite of all the laws that were written to rely on private enforcement were revisited and revised appropriately to ensure that those who are not wealthy would still be protected in fact, rather than just in theory. Or get rid of civil rights laws. "Reason" is a libertarian publication, so that would probably be their solution.
- jessriedel 16y agoI like your main point, that if the US has used litigation to in place of government protection, then we can't replicate the benefits of loser-pays without increasing government intervention. But I have to quibble with your specifics. >Most of the rest of the world tends toward having the government deal with civil rights enforcement. Your employer denies you a promotion because of your race, sex, or religion? Complain to the appropriate government agency and they deal with the problem Maybe I'm reading this wrong, but I think this exactly what you do in the US. See http://www.eeoc.gov/facts/qanda.html http://www.eeoc.gov/facts/qanda.html . From that link: > V. Who Can File a Charge of Discrimination? > * Any individual who believes that his or her employment rights have been violated may file a charge of discrimination with EEOC. > * In addition, an individual, organization, or agency may file a charge on behalf of another person in order to protect the aggrieved person's identity. > VI. How Is a Charge of Discrimination Filed? > * A charge may be filed by mail or in person at the nearest EEOC office This is in addition to the ability to sue the employer without penalty (unless your litigation is "abusive", which is very rare).
- dminor 16y agoHow about loser pays except in civil rights lawsuits?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoFTA: "A common fear about loser-pays is that the side who loses a routine dispute will get handed a bill for 10,000 hours from Cravath, Swaine & Moore. But European courts are well aware of the danger that successful litigants will overinvest in their cases and gold-plate their fee requests. They carefully control the process to prevent that danger, giving the losing side a full chance to dispute a fee award, requiring that work be reasonable and necessary, providing that elite lawyer rates not be paid if a Main Street lawyer could have done the job, and so forth." "One way Europeans have adapted to the residual risks of loser-pays has been through personal legal expense insurance, which covers a variety of legal risks including that of finding oneself a plaintiff in a lawsuit. The aggrieved party takes his case to his insurer, which, if it finds the case strong, provides a lawyer and absorbs the risk of owing the opponent a fee....If the insurer screens cases carefully, it will collect more in fees for its lawyer than it will pay to winning opponents." I don't know if these claims are true, having no experience with European legal systems. If true, they would appear to address your criticisms.
- jessriedel 16y agoSo, the strongest and most common objection against the English rule is that it would prevent the poor from suing even if they had a good case; they just couldn't afford a 10% chance of owing thousands of dollars. I am very sympathetic to this objection. But can't this be (mostly) solved by having the lawyers take on the risk? Already, lawyers will offer to work for free unless the plaintiff wins. ("You pay nothing unless we recover on your behalf.") That is, they risk their own time--but will do so only if they think there is a good case. This makes sense because it is the lawyers, not the plaintiffs, who are best able to assess the likelihood of winning. So then couldn't lawyers also take on the risk of paying fees if the litigation is unsuccessful? Is this legal in the US or elsewhere? Is it done? (Also, I think I heard somewhere about a guy who couldn't afford to sue a large company which stole his invention. Apparently, he had an IPO to offer stock in the lawsuit. He won, and both he and his investors were paid. Anyone remember this or have a link?)
- sxdfvgbnhjhgbv 16y agoBut then it's not based on the chance of winning it's based on the likelyhood of a quick settlement and the amount they are likely to get. Suing a council/schoolboard/hospital - likely to win (they don't defend strongly) and likely to be a big pay out (it's not their money). Suing a large corporation with their own expensive laywers = not worth the risk.
- roel_v 16y ago"Already, lawyers will offer to work for free unless the plaintiff wins." In the US, yes. Not in Europe. Here in the Netherlands, it's actually prohibited by the rules of the (loosely translated) National Bar Association to take a case on a 'no cure, no pay' basis. This article is misinformed and misleading. The legal culture is very different between the US and mainland Europe. The claims that are being made in the article are largely misrepresentations of what actually happens; for example, her in the Netherlands the amount a judge can (but doesn't have to, and often does only in part) award the loser to pay for the legal costs of the winner is based on a quotum, i.e. not on the real costs, but on a fictitious per-hour amount, which is lower than actual commercial rates (one notable exception is for IP infringements, where the full cost can be claimed).
- jrockway 16y agoDoesn't this have downsides? Say I want to sue the government for some legitimate reason (denying my FOIA request, etc.). They rack up their legal bills on the taxpayer's dime, and then I lose. Then I owe the government eleventy billion dollars. This possibility means that it's not worth the risk to sue the government, even when I don't want its money. And if you can't sue the government, it can do anything it wants to. Everyone loses. s/the government/a big corporation/ and it's the same thing. Really, it's bad both ways. Legitimate lawsuits should be free.
- koenigdavidmj 16y agoThe government, being sovereign, cannot be sued except by its own consent.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- grellas 16y agoThe loser-pays rule can often work hardship on average people caught up in the court system. Fee awards can be devastating to a middle-class person. I once had a case come to me after some homeowners had lost at trial in a dispute with their mortgage lender over some technical provisions of their mortgage. The amount at stake was perhaps a couple of hundred thousand dollars. However, on losing, the court awarded the lender almost $400K in fees (it did so under a contract provision providing that the prevailing party in any dispute would receive an award of such fees). It seemed pretty clear that the court had rendered some doubtful rulings in the case and that the case would likely be reversed on appeal. However, in order to get to an appeal, the losing parties needed to get a stay on execution of the judgment. To get the stay, they had to post a bond in an amount equal to no less than one and one-half times the amount of the judgment. Since this was beyond the financial means of the losing plaintiffs, they found themselves being subjected to liens, attachments, garnishments, and the like in ways that basically ruined their day-to-day lives long before they could await the outcome of any appeal. As a result, though they were probably right on the merits, all it took was the harsh acts of one judge to render them helpless in asserting their rights by being able to pursue their case to its proper outcome. They had scraped to pay their own attorneys to prosecute the case but they were overwhelmed by the attorney-fee award that crippled their case midstream. That example involved, not poor people, but those who had homes and jobs and who felt they needed to try to undo a wrong that had been inflicted on them by a lender. The result was that they folded their case, borrowed from wherever they could to pay the lender's fees, and dropped their appeal, walking away licking some pretty heavy wounds. Based on many such situations, I would say that a loser-pays rule could easily work hardship on average people seeking access to the courts. I will grant that such a rule sounds attractive in principle and our courts are full of abusive litigation that needs to be curbed. But I'm just not sure that this is the right approach to reforming the problems.
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoWhile certainly catastrophic, this is anecdotal at best, and similar anecdotes can be found for the companies with deep pockets using their lawyers to suck individuals dry. Unfortunately, these are the scare-type comments that keep any reform from happening. If the US became a less litigious country as a result of loser-pay, then the system would be a benefit, IMO. The legal tax required to do business in the US is too high.
- blahedo 16y ago...read read read... ...read read read... ..."a million marks or francs"... Wait, what? Oh, it's from 1995. I guess I should have seen it in the URL if I'd parsed it out, but isn't there a convention around here to post the year in the HN title for older articles like this? EDIT: Um, or the subhed right up at the top of the article. Sheesh. I claim... banner blindness?
- drblast 16y agoThis seems like the potential downsides are almost as bad as the potential wins. The obvious problem with our system is that the party with the deepest pockets can drag a case out until the opposing party cries uncle and gives up. There's a simple solution that seems fair; both sides pay into a pool for legal representation and the pool is divided equally. So if Megacorp wants to sue Joe's Startup, Joe can afford the same representation that Megacorp can. I'm sure there are downsides to that system that I'm not thinking about, but it seems like it would be pretty fair.
- notahacker 16y agoThis isn't a bad idea at all, though some ability to alter the allocation of the pool at the discretion of the judge would be helpful (mainly to stop the potential for self-representing entities to launch frivolous suits purely to earn an equivalent amount to the legal fees BigCorp spends on defending themselves)
- drblast 16y agoRight, that's a potential downside. Makes me think the personal injury attorneys would be more likely sue big fish in an attempt to win the legal lottery. Of course, the smart company has a defense against this tactic: only use the funds provided by the opponent. This would eventually bankrupt the frivolous lawsuit trolls, since it would cost them real money to continue the case at the risk of losing it all while costing the defendant nothing. The more I think about it, the more this seems like a system that provides an incentive to only sue when you have a legitimate claim. Anything else wouldn't be worth the risk for either side.
- notahacker 16y agoBut if I'm a troll representing myself I don't spend any money (only time, which I don't bill for if I'm a non-practising entity) in filing lawsuits claiming $10million in damages On the other hand BigCorp which stands to lose a claimed $10m in the unlikely event of losing the suit needs to retain the services of a lawyer, which will probably not be a cheap one as they have a lot more at stake. So BigCorp will certainly need to put enough money into the pot to cover their own expenses, and the troll will pocket half of that even if the case gets thrown out.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- tsotha 16y agoOh, of course it could work in the US. But it will never happen - national and state bar associations have far too much political clout.
- redwoods 16y agoThe ABA are the last people to listen to on this subject. Their mortgage payments are inextricably linked to the status quo and thus cannot be expected to enjoy an objective perspective.
- annajohnson 16y agoI can't speak for England or Europe but here in Australia it's typical for judges to 'award costs' to the winning party. In other words, the judge determines whether or not it's appropriate for the losing party to pay the legal costs of the winning party. It is not mandatory for judges to award costs but it is so common as to be expected. In principle, awarding costs is 'fair': if Party A has caused Party B to incur legal costs in enforcing their legal rights then it's only fair for Party A to compensate Party B for their legal costs. A positive consequence of 'loser pays' is that there is far less litigation - and certainly less spurious litigation - in Australia than there might otherwise be. On the other hand, while the practice seems fair in principle it can be very unfair - and financially crippling - in practice. You can imagine a situation where Party A is actually in the right, tries to appeal the judge's decision, but can't do so because they are financially in the hole because of having costs awarded against them! So, while I still favour the idea of awarding costs, other mechanisms are needed to account for situations where parties are appealing decisions and the like.
- bugsy 16y agoYes, it makes sense that whoever has the most money to pay lawyers to drag the case through appeals until the other side is bankrupt should also then be able to pin the bill for the whole thing on the peasant they have defeated. For too long have the disenfranchised had equal access to the court system.
- stretchwithme 16y agoPeople (or their lawyers) who have a pattern of frivolous suits should pay the costs of dealing with a frivolous suit. People can bring great stress and costs using the legal system. Its not just a tool for justice, whether it is used by the rich or by the poor. Everybody that uses the legal system should think twice about whether their suit is truly warranted. Of course, there should be standards by which this is judged. And damages should not ruin those bringing suits. Its not even necessary to me that all costs be covered, but that some real cost be felt by those bringing the suit. 5 or 10% of one's annual income seems not unreasonable.
- jpr 16y agoAnd here I had always thought that loser-pays was a universal rule. This explains almost everything that is crazy about US.
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoWhat a complete bullshit. Making the case for something based on it having a long tradition. Great. We can stop any debate then. Let's just do what the Romans did or the Greeks or ... Apart from that, as a European, I know how I and the people I know think. It's simple. Never sue a financially stronger opponent and when you're sued, give up immediately unless you have insurance. The risks are very uneven. One side risks their entire existence. For the other side it's just a blip in their legal budget. Civil law in Europe is a farce. It's an exclusive playground for the rich and for large corporations.
- mayutana 16y agoI too feel that the Loser-pays scenario is much better. This leads to all parties trying to amicably solving the issue before going to court. Here in Germany, the person suing needs to send a minimum number of warnings before taking the case to court. This provides the defendant with a chance to pay off if he in the wrong, instead of having to go to court and paying the additional lawyer fees for both parties.
- protomyth 16y agoI am all for tort reform, but this can get a little extreme and stop several types of legitimate suits. Just because you lose doesn't mean the suit was totally without merit. One of the simplest reforms would be to limit lawyer's cut of lawsuit rewards to keep them actually about the damaged parties. Look at the recent case where the school spied on the students. The lawyers got well in excess of their clients. Making it less attractive to take a chance on suing is good, but the focus should be on what will keep companies from screwing people and what will keep costs to innocent / small mistake companies down.
- loewenskind 16y agoWell, this attacks one of the problems with the US justice system. The other problem is the fact that someone like O.J. Simpson can murder two people and then hire a team of expensive lawyers to get him off the hook. Now imagine if the government even ended up being the one who had to pay those guys!
- Uchikoma 16y agoFunny. Europeans talking about the US system they only know from TV. Americans talking about the European system they only know from TV - if even.
- nimblegorilla 16y agoIt's kind of ironic that the GOP is pushing for changes to make our legal system closer to Europe's, but they are quick to vilify similar attempts regarding health care.