9 ms·
You can't play Bach on Facebook because Sony says they own his compositions
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pfooti 8y agoHeadline seems demonstrably untrue [0]. Better framing should be, "contentID incorrectly identifies YouTube sample as being part of a totally legally copyrighted recording of a Bach work". (Bracketing for now the rightness or copyright at all, I suppose) 0: https://youtu.be/ddbxFi3-UO4 https://youtu.be/ddbxFi3-UO4
- srtjstjsj 8y agoAnd it's Facebook, not Youtube contentID
- petermcneeley 8y agoThis is simply due to an over zealous copyright detection algorithm. That being said does any remember Napster and the good old days? Makes me feel old and yearn for a more innocent time.
- gamesbrainiac 8y agoIs there any penalty for being overzealous regarding the protection of your copyrights? I understand that individuals could litigate, but I would assume that to be a long winded process.
- jcranmer 8y agoFiling a DMCA takedown notice for stuff you do not own copyright for is perjury. (Filing one that ignores fair use considerations does not fall under that category, though). Youtube's Content ID system is not related to DMCA takedowns, though, so there is no legal repercussions to making fallacious claims outside to violating whatever terms of service the system has.
- NSAID 8y agoAlmost perjury. There's a good faith clause, so if someone believes in good faith that their magic black box AI correctly identifies their IP and never issues incorrect takedowns, it's not perjury.
- Thiez 8y agoIf only a judge would rule that such faith in the magic black box is no longer 'good' once it has made, say, 3 mistakes. At that point the user of the AI should understand that it isn't perfect and be obligated to manually check all future results.
- krapp 8y agoYou don't understand the purpose of these systems if you believe accuracy is that important. They're designed to pacify copyright owners, to prevent lawsuits against the platform and keep licensed content on the platform... the heavy-handedness and opaqueness are intentional, as is the bias towards false positives.
- Mindwipe 8y agoContent ID is not a DMCA system. The DMCA system is manual. Content ID is a private system, operated by YouTube, to improve Google's liability risks and relationships with major rights holders. It is not regulated by the DMCA. It is not supposed to be regulated by the DMCA. Google decided to give some companies the right to do the things Content ID does. And Google does that because it saves them money on running a free hosting service and people get what they pay for in that regard. There is no logic that a judge would touch this scenario. The only argument is that YouTube has near monopoly status, but that isn't an argument for regulating content ID, it's an argument for breaking up YouTube.
- jcranmer 8y agoThe good faith clause does not apply to the condition I mentioned. Good faith applies to believing that the material in question infringes your copyright; it does not apply to believing that you actually own copyright on the allegedly infringing copyright. 17 USC §512 (c)(3)(A)(vi): A statement that the information in the notification is accurate, and under penalty of perjury, that the complaining party is authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed.
- raxxorrax 8y agoIs there any penalty? In most laws there is a penalty if you don't have regular disputes about your patents and rights. But nobody wants to starve patent troll lawyers. There is a complete industry which we should get rid off, because it doesn't do anything productive.
- poulsbohemian 8y agoI have to wonder - isn't the response to this kind of ridiculousness to simply not post on YouTube, for example: http://allofbach.com/en/ http://allofbach.com/en/ ? Yes it's not going to get you the audience YouTube might, but if their platform isn't serving legitimate artists then what good is it anyway?
- nugget 8y agoYouTube is probably most afraid of Twitch. I’d stream/post there instead and see what happens.
- metafizikal 8y agoEyeballs, basically. The eyeballs are on YouTube already, so if you want an audience and you're off YouTube, you're fighting an uphill battle. But classical music, sad to say, largely is a niche pursuit. Niche content can always find a home somewhere and users will seek it out. And I haven't followed the news closely, but if the EU is indeed going to mandate Content-ID style systems, theoretically these niche sites that don't have one will be under some level of legal and regulatory exposure? Not quite sure how any of that would work in practice.
- ars 8y agoIf someone tells me "Bach #xyz is amazing, you have to hear it", I'm going to type it into youtube to listen to it. I'm not going to search for it elsewhere because it's not a core interest of mine. Devoted fans will find content anywhere, but casual viewers will just look in the default spot.
- poulsbohemian 8y agoMaybe it is a generational thing, as I’ve always and continue to find YouTube nothing more than a cesspool and i would never think to go there first for something
- ars 8y agoI don't know what generation you are from, but I don't see how that makes any difference. Youtube is an everything-pool. It has garbage, it has wonderful. Generalizing about a site that large is foolish. You may want to Google "Sturgeon's law".
- tomhoward 8y agoRecent related discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17884215 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17884215
- anonytrary 8y agoConstructions like this are living proof that maybe the system we've decided to implement isn't as smart as we thought it was. Humans have a knack for thinking they can control things they don't actually understand -- and we end up with contradictions like this situation. I'll leave these here: > I am not an advocate for frequent changes in laws and Constitutions. But laws and institutions must go hand in hand with the progress of the human mind. As that becomes more developed, more enlightened, as new discoveries are made, new truths discovered and manners and opinions change, with the change of circumstances, institutions must advance also to keep pace with the times. -- Jefferson > That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. -- Declaration of Independence
- pavanlimo 8y agoI tend to agree with Elon Musk's idea that every law should come with an expiry date. So that there is debate before it is renewed.
- mey 8y agoOur (assuming US) federal legislators can barely pass a budget. At best they would simply rubber stamp the existing laws. More likely expiring laws would be used as political hostages. Granted, that is pretty much the existing status quo. Not sure it would change the behavior in a positive direction.
- salawat 8y agoThat was Thomas Jefferson oriiginally actually. It was also intended as a soft limit to the number of laws that would be passed, as it would ensure that only the most important would generally be reaffirmed.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- ekianjo 8y agoYou dont have to use Youtube to host things though. Youtube is not the Internet. We should go back to decentralizing things again.
- tokyodude 8y agoit does feel to me you do mostly have to use YouTube. I can afford to host video if it becomes remotely popular.
- true_religion 8y agoYes, it costs money to give things away for free. Now you can have YouTube do it, and play by their rules which help them keep costs low... or you can do it yourself. Personally, I would put up a snippet, the serve a torrent. If it gets popular, its popularity will support it. Otherwise, I can support my hobby with a seed box for 15 a month.
- ipsum2 8y agoI'm curious, how much bandwidth does a popular video take, assuming its encoded? I picked a random Youtube video that was 5 minutes long, downloaded it in 1080p, 53MB in size. The video got 100,000 views, which takes 5TB to transfer. I'm not sure about other cloud platforms, but on DigitalOcean (I haven't found any reputable hosting thats cheaper) the transfer cost is $0.01/GB, so it would cost $53 dollars, which doesn't include CDN. If you made ate least $0.0005 per video watched, you would make up your bandwidth costs. You can probably 20x this price for CDN/other cloud providers, so if you were making at least a penny per view, you would break even. Some simplifications made: 1) Didn't include peak bandwidth/if the pipe is big enough at peak hours. 2) Assumed all viewers watched the video from beginning to end, instead of stopping 20% of the way through.
- mlang23 8y agoBeen there. I was, and still am, surspised that we allow for automatic algorithms to do copyright claims. non-free algorithms deciding about the faith of real people sounds like the stuff from dystopian scifi novels, but that is what we already allow to happen in real world.
- yason 8y agoIt seems to me that the content identification works as advertised: it's the metadata that is missing essential information due to inadequate process. If Youtube knew that the author is Bach and not Sony it would know not to flag the soundtracks featuring Bach songs. However, the problem is that at some point Sony lied to Youtube and claimed ownership of these songs even though they are in public domain. So there should be reviews or penalty for flagging copyright on someone else's works. Sony could claim they have copyright on the very Bach recording they uploaded themselves but if content id system can't differentiate between Sony's Bach and anyone's Bach, then for practical purposes there probably aren't much basis for the recording to be eligible for a copyright by Sony.
- fipple 8y agoHuh? If Youtube’s black box AI can’t tell the difference between recordings by Glenn Gould and Murray Perahia they should be equivalent in the eyes of copyright law?
- js8 8y agoYes! If you can't tell a difference between a true Mickey Mouse and its (slightly different) clone, and yet the other is not allowed by law due to being not sufficiently different work, then I would say the guys who just aren't sufficiently different from Bach should not be subject of copyright. The truth is, copyright on interpretation is about the same category as copyright on a work of a plumber in my apartment. I understand that's how some people make money, though, so it's painful to change.
- mikekchar 8y agoOK. We need to back up here as there are some conclusions being rendered that don't quite hold up. For music, there is more than one copyright. There is the copyright on the original composition. There is the copyright on the modification of the original composition (for example to use modern notation, etc). There is the copyright on the recording. Sony has a copyright on some recordings of Bach music. They may also have a copyright on modifications of the original compositions, but I don't know if they do or not. They do not hold a copyright on the original composition, because that is in the public domain. It is difficult to record classical music without infringing copyright because the modern printed scores are all modified. You can use the original scores, but they are actually very difficult to understand and are akin to a different language. In fact, as far as I can tell this is the reasoning behind allowing a copyright on the modern scores -- they are essentially translations (and translations of creative works are allowed new copyrights). There are some scores that are both modern and in the public domain. Kimiko Ishizaka has been doing some good work on this front with her "Open Source Bach" series (and you can even get unmixed versions of her recordings under a CC license!!!). However, initiatives on this front are few and far between (consider throwing some money her way as she is worth supporting). If you have a score for which you have a license to record (or which is in the public domain), then you can make a recording of it. It doesn't matter one bit if it sounds like a recording of a Sony recording. However, it is quite difficult to find such scores and often performers do not know enough about copyright law when they start doing their own performances for Youtube.
- frgewut 8y agoOn the other hand YT is full of various Peppa Pig videos (inverted colors, mirror images and all kinds of other weird transformations). YouTube's algorithm apparently can't detect such copyright violations. And the really annoying part is that these videos often rank higher than the original ones.
- bryanrasmussen 8y agobut are the copyright violations then, there has been significant alteration done to the original work.
- Rjevski 8y agoI would assume the characters themselves are copyrighted.
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoI guess trademarked.
- lozenge 8y agoAs the alterations are not transformative the existing copyright will still apply.
- srtjstjsj 8y agoIt's an interesting technical question, why video is so easy to change fingerprint, but audio isn't. I suppose it comes down to a few things: * Video has higher dimensionality * Distorted videos often have distorted audio (usually dialog) that would ruin the work if the audio was the primary value of the work.
- haser_au 8y agoHN Title and article title are wrong. It was Facebook, not YouTube. Source: https://twitter.com/JRhodesPianist/status/1036960208776519680 https://twitter.com/JRhodesPianist/status/103696020877651968...
- dang 8y agoOk, we've s/YouTube/Facebook/'d the title above. Thanks!
- pasta 8y agoThere are two types of copyright at work here: 1. The music (score) 2. The recording of a performance of the music For old music nr.1 has expired. But nr.2 can still be copyrighted. The question is: how does Facebook know the performance is under copyright by Sony? I guess they don't..
- Piskvorrr 8y agoThat's a hard problem to solve. So every content-id system out there hacks around that - by not solving it, and merely pretending that whoever claims the rights first actually has them. Convenient for the platform and whoever has deeper pockets for lawsuits.
- jondubois 8y agoThe government keeps introducing new laws all the time. The system is becoming bloated and exceedingly restrictive. Maybe they should focus on removing old laws. Or at least focus on adding more laws to restrict the rights of corporations instead of people.
- em0ney 8y agoCan't wait until they bachflip on this decision http://weknowmemes.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/bachflip.jpg http://weknowmemes.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/bachflip.j...
- tempodox 8y agoI had better not let Sony know that I play Bach in my home without their kind permission.
- xntrk 8y agoWhat is the smallest text fragment that can be copyrighted?
- srtjstjsj 8y agoThat's an empirical question, not theoretical, so it's "has been", not "can be". Interesting question. Like the Bust Beaver function, apparently unknown. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/copyright-trademark-titles-words-short-phrases-joshua-g-graubart https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/copyright-trademark-titles-wo...
- buboard 8y agoSo their network generalizes well - Good! But they use it to identify recordings - Bad. Stupid humans.
- bovermyer 8y agoI'd like to see a debate on whether copyright itself is a good thing.
- gwbas1c 8y agoThe last time I reviewed copyright law, fraudulently claiming ownership of someone else's work is a very big deal. This is something that can be handled with a class action lawsuit.