11 ms·
How the EU may force all artists to use Youtube forever
- tj-teej 8y agoCopyright law, Net-Neutrality, it sometimes feels that our current Governments cannot bring forward decent legislation on complex tech issues. Regardless of whether the cause is ignorance or cynicism; have there been other examples of times in US or EU history that governments passed such clearly 'anti-people' (for lack of a better term) laws?
- GW150914 8y agoHistory is mostly a record of just those kinds of “anti-people” laws. In the UK their history is practically defined by them, with arguably the most famous being Acts of Enclosure dating back to the very early 17th century. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inclosure_Acts https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inclosure_Acts They hang the man and flog the woman Who steals the goose from off the common Yet let the greater villain loose That steals the common from the goose. In fact the history of European and American law tended to emphasize draconian punishments for minor crimes against the landed gentry, nobility, and aristocracy. If you want a present example consider the real impact of the war on drugs, and cui bono. The Nixon campaign in 1968, and the Nixon White House after that, had two enemies: the antiwar left and black people. You understand what I’m saying? We knew we couldn’t make it illegal to be either against the war or black, but by getting the public to associate the hippies with marijuana and blacks with heroin, and then criminalizing both heavily, we could disrupt those communities. We could arrest their leaders, raid their homes, break up their meetings, and vilify them night after night on the evening news. Did we know we were lying about the drugs? Of course we did. John Erlichhman
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- QasimK 8y agoWhile there may be negative examples as you are asking for. There are also many positive examples, I think GDPR is an excellent one. I would also ask for people to share the positive ones, lest we go to sleep in misery.
- arcbyte 8y agoGDPR as a positive example? Huh?
- jimnotgym 8y agoFor a person it is a really great law yes. For a data-farming corporation, less so, but that is not what he OP asked
- paxy 8y agoLarge data-farming corporations can and will continue operating in Europe, since they are the only ones that have the resources to understand the law, find limits and loopholes, pay fines, make major changes to their systems etc. Smaller companies and startups are the ones who will suffer.
- gpvos 8y agoOnly if they want to data farm. And while there are probably loopholes, I'd be interested to hear of any.
- darawk 8y agoAs far as I can tell the only impact GDPR has had on my life is that there are a lot more annoying popups for me to mindlessly click 'accept' on.
- StavrosK 8y agoReally? Then you aren't using it at all. The impact it's had on my life is that companies have to tell me what they're doing with my data. If I say no, they have to refrain from using it, they can't just say "well tough luck, we have it now". If I give my email for a contest, they can't keep spamming me with crap. If I tell them to forget I exist, they have to do it. If I want to see what Facebook knows about me, it has to tell me everything. As someone who runs dozens of side-projects with thousands of users, I didn't even have to change anything. All it took was to not be shitty to begin with.
- lbarrow 8y ago20 years later, the DMCA in the US actually seems pretty decent. It's not perfect but it strikes a pretty good balance between the interests of copyright holders and allowing for innovation.
- kosievdmerwe 8y agoOnly issue I have is that there's not enough penalty for false reports or none that I've ever seen applied.
- confounded 8y agoReally? Jail time for circumventing DRM?
- saagarjha 8y agoIn my experience, it's been used to threaten people who reverse engineer software to find bugs and take down content that is not remotely infringing. Not a "pretty good balance" in my book.
- williamscales 8y agoIt's true that it does not contain adequate protection for reverse engineering, however, I think the underlying premise of offering a safe harbor predicated on responding to abuse complaints is an effective one.
- rhino369 8y agoThat is a downside. But it also makes it very difficult to sue a website/service for the actions of its users.
- zjaffee 8y agoBecause no one would make music, movies, or television anymore if DCMA didn't exist? I just don't believe that to be true.
- joering2 8y agoHow many complains did you file?? Few companies I work for have their stuff stolen and posted on youtube constantly. It took 3 months to get any response from Youtube. That times goes down to 3 weeks IF you have attorney representing you. Over 70 vidoes I have worked with lawyers to get removed, we always been looked at as the real criminals; we have to upload and prove all sorts of things just to get pass by the submit form. Longest case took us 5 months and $3,000 to remove a 45 seconds of stolen material. Yes, DMCA works pretty decent; for lawyers that charge per hour.
- dustingetz 8y agoIf the purpose of government is to ensure stability (and particularly to ensure the stability of the people in power), that would seem fundamentally at odds with disruptive innovation and exponential progress. I don't think it can be stabilized, more likely it shatters under the strain, and something new and different emerges from the wreckage
- simcop2387 8y agoAs much as I disagree with her politics, the Ayn Rand novel Anthem somewhat explores an extreme version of this idea. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthem_(novella) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthem_(novella)
- mandelbulb 8y ago>it sometimes feels that our current Governments cannot bring forward decent legislation on complex tech issues. No, the issue is not advanced technology but special interests. When the later take priority over resolving troubling consequences, you get results like those two articles. Politicians are not meant to understand the areas they regulate. Even if they were IT professionals, they still would not understand all the other professions.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gregknicholson 8y agoPoliticians have no incentive to understand complex tech issues. Most voters don't vote for a candidate on the basis of the candidate's tech-literacy. Most voters don't understand complex tech issues themselves, so they couldn't even if they wanted to.
- drdrey 8y agoIt's hard to take the story seriously when it uses hyperbole such as "this is an extinction level event"
- cm2187 8y agoThis is what happened with banks, where the regulatory requirements are so onerous that they constitute a massive barrier to entry to new competitors. That's both a curse for banks (it's not fun to be regulated to death) and a blessing (it does't matter how badly your service sucks, as long as it is about as bad as your few competitors).
- s_dev 8y agoThe specific legislation in mind that relates to these banks in the EU is PDS2: basically banks have to make their data both machine consumable and portable for the user. Basically they have to make a public API.
- hannasanarion 8y agoThat's true, but those same regulatory requirements reduce the impact of monopolizing on consumers. Youtube has already achieved a monopoly without the responsibilities of public service and consumer protection that usually come with them
- imperio59 8y agoThe point is moot as soon as someone builds an API to take your user's uploaded video and run it through copyright detection. The software doesn't have to be good, it just has to do what the law asks. This article is pretty off the mark.
- Aeolun 8y agoYou can be pretty certain a EU law will be fairly specific in what is required. And I doubt it will be simple. Either way, it’s still an absurd idea, regardless of whether it’s doable in reality.
- bjt 8y agoDefinitely an exaggeration. You don't need every single startup to build a $60 million Content ID equivalent. You just need one startup to build Content-ID-as-a-Service. Which actually looks like a pretty good startup idea right now.
- confounded 8y agoChange the world!
- bubblethink 8y ago>Content-ID-as-a-Service Some torrent trackers have pretty good databases of content. They can make some side cash instead of relying on donations. Win-win for everyone.
- jacob019 8y agotorrent trackers don't database content, they index it
- IronWolve 8y agoI cant even get Shazam to work on many songs in tv shows, due to music sold from companies that produce music for content creators and not the public. Also noticed this trend is now happening into youtube creators using leased music from their creator company or 3rd party youtube music provider. How the heck is Youtube able to identify music if Shazam cant?
- pedro_hab 8y agoThis is one more reason for innovation to keep dying in Europe. They are working on this regulations that stifle tech and are losing. The EU had 16B VC investments agains 60B in the US, the market capitalization of Top 500 companies has been declining. [1] Of the 50 countries studied in the Digital Evolution Index, which tracked the levels of digital development and attractiveness to global businesses and investors, the bottom 9 were European. [2] From the video [1]: "Loser: Europe, which is becoming irrelevant when it comes to innovation. Only six of the world's most valuable companies are based in Europe, and venture capital funding has declined." 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UiTz-NTEXAM&feature=youtu.be&t=42 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UiTz-NTEXAM&feature=youtu.be... . 2. https://hbr.org/2015/10/europes-other-crisis-a-digital-recession https://hbr.org/2015/10/europes-other-crisis-a-digital-reces...
- IdiocyInAction 8y agoAnother big reasons are language barriers and more importantly, vastly different tax codes and laws between EU countries. But the regulations don't help either, that's true.
- pedro_hab 8y agoYou are right, I've been looking into EU taxes and the Netherlands, which was dead last in the list above, has a nice 30% tax cuts for expats. The EU seems to tax quite heavily compared to the US, and also the salaries are also quite lower there too, I checked the cost of living in some EU cities compared to Austin and the salaries are not great. I am only looking into Europe because the immigration system there seems to be much better than the US, otherwise the US would be much better option. In a related note Teachers salaries don't seem that different.
- rahkiin 8y agoDon't forget to calculate the money you are left with every month after paying taxes, health insurance, housing and basic needs. I read that health insurance in the US costs 1000$+ per month, and even then you pay thousands out of pocket. Same for social security. I believe that if you take this into your calculations the difference is not so bad
- hk__2 8y agoWhy remove “How” from the original title? "How the EU will force all artists to use Youtube, forever". Edit: even the original title is misleading: it should be something like "How the EU may force all artists to use Youtube, forever, if that EU proposal is approved".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThere is a character limit. I'm on my phone, so checking character count isn't convenient for me at the moment, but that's a common reason to drop words that add little meaning.
- 37 8y agoA very brief look at the HN homepage tells me this is not the reason.
- 1337biz 8y agoI have had countless times these problems with the hn character limit. It is really tricky deciding which words to cut out or how to reframe titles when the hn limit sets in. Somebody is always going to be unhappy (if the submission ever makes it ot the front page).
- hk__2 8y agoBut the original title doesn’t even come close to the character limit. "How the EU will force all artists to use Youtube, forever" is 57-characters-long while the submission limit is 80. A quick look at the current homepage shows that exactly a third of its titles (10 out of 30) are longer than 57 characters.
- dang 8y agoLooks like the submitter was helpfully trying to adhere to HN title conventions. But in this case I don't think "How" is so bad. Also, we'll put "may" above, since you make a good point there.
- djrogers 8y agoThis sounds like a horrible law, with some really bad consequences. That said; > This is an extinction-level event for the internet, folks. Hyperbole like this doesn’t help, and in fact often turns off people whom you might be able to sway to your cause. The immediate reaction of most people to an absolutist phrase such as that is skepticism, which naturally leads to disbelief and scorn - not what you’re likely looking to foster in your readers.
- drb91 8y ago> Hyperbole like this doesn’t help, and in fact often turns off people whom you might be able to sway to your cause. I disagree; sometimes hyperbole is an effective way of waking people up to how they perceive the world. In this case I think it's fairly effective, and also worth it.
- komali2 8y agoBut it's false. The loss of net neutrality didn't end the internet like everyone said it would. Instead, it's going just like the realists said: every couple months or so, Comcast and co do a new little fucky thing, slowly becoming shittier and shittier while dangling out carrots (that are later revoked) so people don't realize it. It's the same as why asking kavanaugh whether he'll overturn roe vs Wade is a pointless question. I think we should tell people what they realistically should be looking for. I think doing otherwise just gives opponents more ammunition. "See, net neutrality was repealed and nothing happened!"
- Johnny555 8y agoBut it's false. The loss of net neutrality didn't end the internet like everyone said it would It seems too early to tell how that's going to play out since it's such a political change -- I wouldn't expect providers to make any significant changes to take advantage of Network Neutrality at least until the midterm elections are over, no point investing in a business model if it's likely to change with the election.
- mahgnous 8y agoWouldn't it be easier to just kick Europe off the net since they can't play nice?
- opportune 8y agoCan someone explain which large organizations within the EU are pushing for article 13 and why? The more I read about this law the more stupid it seems. GDPR compliance isn’t that hard but Article 13 is bad enough that it gives a compelling reason to just ignore the EU market for lots of applications. And it’s really going to up the costs of unseating internet incumbents
- barry-cotter 8y agoPublishers of newspapers, books and music. The old content industry.
- jowiar 8y agoThere's some irony in posting this here, given this is a user-generated site and all, but I'd love to see all the safe-harbor provisions be seriously rethought. It would wreck the tech industry, but save the internet by decentralizing it, and kill off cesspools where idiots wreck society while profiteering scum become billionaires amid the carnage.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThat would do massive harm to transparency due to making it harder to find anything. Not to mention the effective end of anonymous speech - either they host wrote or reuploaded it and either way they can be attacked for it. Which means vanishingly few would upload content from another. Really the tear it down and build something new mentality is faulty. You don't tear your house down and then build a new one before you die of exposure, you build the new one then abandon or tear down the old one.
- jowiar 8y agoWe had a (mostly) working house, then money happened to it, driven by legislation which let the VCs and their friends avoid the liability that prevented others from doing the same before. What we needed was tools to make it easier for people to publish to the shared internet. What we got was a centralized mess -- the bastard child of AOL and the advertising industry. The past 20 years of growth in the internet have been a mistake. Not a "small, needs a bit of tweaking" sort of mistake, but a "burn it all" mistake. Twitter is a garbage fire. Facebook is a garbage fire. The world would be better without them. Not a "slightly modified" version. Burned to the ground. The liability insurance required to hold data on a billion people should be unaffordable. Services at that scale should not exist.
- INTPenis 8y agoPlease correct me if I'm wrong but I did read these articles back when the vote was up a few months ago and my interpretation was not that it is a requirement to have an automated evaluation system. Sure youtube will of course implement an automated system but my point is that if you setup your own Peertube instance you can still screen content and let users report possible copyrighted content to you for manual screening. So small scale, self-hosted or themed instances will still be possible but they will have to moderate their content and they will have to act on received copyright violation reports. The author seems to be pointing out that small players cannot compete with Youtube because Youtube will have the means for automated large scale content screening. Well small players can do it manually. It will only work up until a certain level but it still enables people to host small themed instances of peertube for example.
- dx87 8y agoFrom what I remember, you're right that it doesn't strictly require an automated system, but the only way to practically do it is with an automated system. With current safe harbor provisions in the DMCA, if someone uploads copyrighted content, the host isn't liable as long as they take it down when notified. The new EU rules would make the host liable for any copyrighted content uploaded by a user, no safe harbor provisions. So you're options are automated filtering/blocking of all uploaded content, or roll the dice and hope that if a user uploads copyrighted content, that you find out before you get sued by the copyright owner.
- nyxtom 8y agoThis is how centralization and sweeping censorship/fascism seems to work in the new modern era we live in. Govt bodies react to pressing problems by increasing regulatory footprint so much that only companies like Facebook, Google/YouTube, Twitter, could possibly comply with. At the same time, these companies are at increasing pressure both from frequent public outrages to politicians to do something about users and types of content shared on their network. It’s easy to dismiss how these companies comply with regulatory bodies and react to public pressure to ban certain types of content and users so long as it is possible to create alternative networks. With stuff like this, it’s not so far fetched to imagine it increasingly difficult to launch platforms similar to YouTube and Facebook/Twitter, if not prohibitive without special deals and partnerships with major media companies. We need a new internet
- balt_s 8y ago> We need a new internet Let me know when it's done; seems you've got your work cut out for you..
- black6 8y agoMost people will always flock to the “free” option that all their buddies are on. It’s entirely possible for me to host streaming video on my web server that I pay for. Hell, it may even be within my skill set to deploy it. But if you watched my video(s) on my sever, there would be no easy, one-shot way to populate similar videos on all my friends own web servers. The same applies to (micro)blogging services like Facebag and the Tweeter. You get what you pay for, and most don’t want to pay a subscription fee to watch random cat videos whenever the feeling strikes.
- tokai 8y agoCan't we just use Gopher?
- kodablah 8y ago> This is how centralization and sweeping censorship/fascism seems to work in the new modern era we live in With thunderous applause. It's amazing if we take a retrospective look at how big web tech became the enemy, how the feeling was derived, our ideas of perceived harms, and our perception of helplessness of both the masses and existing laws. It reminds me of terrorism a generation before, drugs a generation before that, communism a generation before that, etc. There's little comfort knowing we cannot grow beyond our sheparded-sheep ways.
- nkkollaw 8y agoThese clickbaity, overdramatic headlines are getting kind of tiring.
- quotemstr 8y ago"Build your own platforms if you don't like your censorship", they said. "Private companies can do what they want. Go make your own." Bwahahahahahaahahaahahahahahahaahahahahahahahahah. When I was young and stupid, I thought tech would be an unfettered, unassailable force for individual liberty. Now, I realize that people like Evgeny Morozov were right all along and that the internet is a tool for totalitarian thought control like the world has never seen.
- _visgean 8y ago"Private companies can do what they want. Go make your own." I mean have you heard of this thing called laws? Like its not a new thing... This is a stupid regulation but it was never the case of "Private companies can do what they want".
- polemic 8y agoCar makers support safety regulation because it further entrenches their position and increases barriers to entry. That does not mean that safety regulations are wrong, or that they need to be rolled back in the name of innovation. The mantra that any imposition on innovation is bad just does not hold true. There will be services that challenge YouTube's dominance, and there will be innovation in the copyright protection space to enable that. You might believe that the increased cost to market entry is detrimental, but you have to actually explain why the inability for garage-startups to compete with YouTube is materially bad for artists, rather than taking it as an article of faith.
- binmanthrowaway 8y agoIt is not that a website can run over people...
- betterunix2 8y agoCar makers were vehemently opposed to seatbelt requirements, and actually sent women after Ralph Nader in an attempt to discredit him when he was advocating for it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unsafe_at_Any_Speed#Industry_response https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unsafe_at_Any_Speed#Industry_r... Auto makers are also far less vulnerable to being unseated by startups than tech companies, due to the capital intensive nature of their business and the maturity of their market.
- phyller 8y agoThe author of this article is a genius, able to express the problem so clearly. These types of regulation that have been coming through the EU are good for the biggest of businesses. Complex and difficult to follow regulation allows the big companies to build a big moat, they have the money to build systems to satisfy the regulations, even to game the regulations. And no new companies will be able to disrupt them. Who's going to risk $60 million dollars on your startup before they get anywhere, just so they can comply with regulations? EU, get ready for Google, Apple, Amazon, Disney, and Coca-Cola to choose what services and products you get, and how much you pay for them.
- jasonkostempski 8y agoIf a law is going to require an algorithm, the algorithm should be supplied by the government, open and free for all to use and they should be responsible for the correctness of the results.
- thecleaner 8y agoEU where innovation goes to die. However industry 4.0 and other initiatives are rather exciting. Wonder why they keep sucking at consumer tech.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoI did this a weird / specious argument 1. Youtube, right now, flagrantly violates copyright - search for Peppa Pig - oh look dozens and dozens and dozens of videos on crappy channels. Same goes for pretty much anything. Maybe Disney does a good job 2. As such attribution is shit. youtube kiddies regularly strip something and post it for the "hey look" value. Trying to find the original creator of day an animated short you find on youtube is frankly impossible. This in a world wide web designed explicitly to be attribute friendly is crazy 3. However, having one, government mandataed IP database is an even bigger crazy and Article 13 shoukd die. The point of the web and domain names is to solve this - surely? /rant Edit: What I have realised is that I think content publishers should be liable for the content on their platforms... Senator :-) Frankly that solves pretty much everything. Want free speech? sure fine no one is stopping it.