5 ms·
> In 2016, The Associated Press showed that candy makers funded a study showing that kids who eat candy weigh less than those who don’t. I don't understand how
by SketchySeaBeast 8y ago
> In 2016, The Associated Press showed that candy makers funded a study showing that kids who eat candy weigh less than those who don’t.
I don't understand how that level of absurdity can be offered up without assuming we'd be skeptical. I can see "kids who eat candy don't gain any more weight" as being a possibility, but thinner? What hubris.
- village-idiot 8y agoI mean, if I eat one piece of candy a year, I won't gain weight either. Somehow I don't think that's the story they're trying to sell.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoYeah, not gaining weight is possibly believable - losing weight is ridiculous.
- wolco 8y agoIt can be true. After antibiotics I lost so much weight rapidly. I can eat bags of sugar without gaining any weight. I can't breakdown fat at all so there is more to the story then sugar = weight increase. It really depends on the bacteria we have in our guts.
- village-idiot 8y agoTo be fair, there’s reason to worry about sugar consumption above and beyond weight gain. Advanced glycation endproducts come to mind. Also, if you’re worried about your gut bacteria, know that excessive amounts of sugar are well known to affect you negatively in that area.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoIf you can't break down sugar or fat, what are you living on? You must eat a heinous amount of protein each day.
- village-idiot 8y agoHumans really aren’t efficient enough at gluconeogenesis to live off pure protein. It’s one of the reasons why that last chicken breast can become revolting, your body has the ability to declare a hard stop on protein consumption. Well, for solid foods. Turns out our brains don’t think liquid calories “count”, which is why protein shakes are a thing. They let body builders massively over protein themselves. That shakes are now a cultural thing for weight loss is absolutely hilarious to me.
- wolco 8y agoI eat a ton of fruit based sugar, plant based food and some protein. No matter how much dried fruit I eat I can't seem to gain a pound. Quantities like 400 grams of raisins.
- nradov 8y agoThat could be partially due to the fiber in all that dried fruit acting as a laxative.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoIce cream comes in 1 gallon tubs. I believe in you.
- PavlikPaja 8y agoNot necessarily. I think it works like this: 1. Standard metabolism: You need certain amouns of calories, and a certain amount of it must come from carbs. If you need 1200kCal in carbs, you will feel hungry until you get that 1200kCal in carbs, no matter how much fat you eat. It might be 1250kCal in plain rice, or 2500kCal in fatty chips, but it must contain 1200kCal in carbs. 2. Keto metabolism: A part of the carb need can be fulfilled with fat, at the cost of lower efficiency. You won't be hungry, almost regardless of how little carbs you eat. It's easy to see how in 1. eating sugar could help you losing weight by making you eat less in general.
- maxxxxx 8y agoIf you eat only candy you will probably lose weight after a while....
- tzs 8y agoIf they were trying to imply that eating candy causes kids to weigh less, then it would indeed seem to be prima facie absurd. But if they are just claiming a correlation, that doesn't seem all that out of the question to me, because parents might include the weight and fitness of their kids as a factor when deciding how much, if any, candy to allow their kids. Suppose a parent has two kids. One greatly prefers spending his time indoors reading or using the computer, and gets almost no exercise except when forced to do physical chores. He's not fat, but he's on the high end of normal weight for his age and build. The other prefers to spend his time outside running around, climbing trees, playing basketball, and is pretty much constantly on the move except when sleeping. Assume both kids like candy. I could see that parent allowing them to have it if they remain fit and not overweight, but restricting it if they start to become unfit or overweight. Under such a rule the result is going to be that the second kid is allowed to eat a lot more candy than the first kid. That would result in a correlation between higher candy consumption and lower weight and better fitness.
- T-hawk 8y agoThe causation goes the opposite direction. If your kid is already fat, you won't give them candy. If your kid is thin, they can have some. Thinness causes candy intake, more so than candy intake causes thinness. The study cleverly misframes that.