5 ms·
The US has a lot of experience - both successful and unsuccessful - at nation building, actively and passively via trade and investment, over the last ~70 years
by adventured 8y ago
The US has a lot of experience - both successful and unsuccessful - at nation building, actively and passively via trade and investment, over the last ~70 years or so. When you get it right, the results are spectacular.
If China can invest half a trillion dollars plus into Africa over two decades and it turns out really well, and they can help lift hundreds of millions of people out of poverty, then that will be a tremendous outcome. They'll be contributing back to the virtuous cycle that their own development over the last few decades has been part of. More and more countries become net contributors and the pace of eradicating extreme poverty quickens.
The debt trap concerns are legitimate, ignoring the propaganda side of that for a moment. That's a pretty obvious potential problem for very poor countries when taking on massive development loans etc.
Ghana for example has a $40-$50 billion GDP, and China recently agreed to lend them $15 billion to try to develop their natural resources (bauxite mining for one) for China's use. When you're borrowing that large of an amount of capital vs the size of the economy that has to repay the debt, it's obviously risky. Ghana's vice president optimistically referred to it as a Marshal plan for Ghana. The pessimistic retort by a member of their parliament:
> "How much of our natural resource are they leveraging in that agreement for the $15 billion facility? If you’ll remember, former President Kufuor did the same thing when we were constructing the Bui dam. He went to China and mortgaged our cocoa for a loan agreement. Today we ship the country’s cocoa to China to service the debt,” he said.
All of these examples come with that double sided risk/reward concern, with debt and what you put up in exchange for the development capital.
The other giant issue I rarely see these articles discuss, is practical sustainability. That's every bit as important as the debt concern. The US could hand Albania an advanced, $11 billion nuclear aircraft carrier, that doesn't mean it's a good idea matched to their level of development and what they can afford to maintain. Skyscrapers are very expensive to maintain across decades. Ethiopia has a GDP per capita of $700.
To be clear, I'm not saying what does or doesn't make sense for Ethiopia. Rather, it'd be interesting to see an analysis of what a country like Ethiopia can support economically. There's a sustainable process to economic development. You can accelerate it a bit, if you try to leap too far you run the risk of causing dramatically worse problems than the nation otherwise would have experienced had it developed more organically or at a more measured pace. If it goes south, you not only have the debt to deal with, you have expensive infrastructure you can't afford to maintain, a double blackhole. China can dump immense sums of capital into trying to leap a country like Ethiopia forward. If they get that wrong, Ethiopia is stuck with trying to upkeep that infrastructure. It makes me wonder if there are elaborate studies done by Ethiopian authorities before allowing major projects funded by China to go forward, when it comes to estimated 30-50 year type maintenance costs.
- baybal2 8y ago>Ghana for example has a $40-$50 billion GDP, and China recently agreed to lend them $15 billion to try to develop their natural resources (bauxite mining for one) for China's use. When you're borrowing that large of an amount of capital vs the size of the economy that has to repay the debt, it's obviously risky. Ghana's vice president optimistically referred to it as a Marshal plan for Ghana. The pessimistic retort by a member of their parliament Bauxite mine is not a unpredictable source of future income. Much like crude oil, even if it is the end of the world tomorrow, it is really, really hard to not to make any money out of it. Another like these are their electric station projects in Pakistan: a very populous country, but their British era grid is beyond repair. Loans given for these stations had high interest, but at the same time Chinese put in sensible conditions like force-majeure insurance, and that the project will largely be done by Chinese state companies guaranteeing that not a single Pakistani bureaucrat had opportunity to steal the funds. Given current electricity prices, there is no chance that they will ever be under water for on loan. A lot of projects are said to be financially engineered to be self-repaying. Effectively, these are not loans, but misnamed leasing agreements. The concern should be over ones that aren't. Saying that China just litters money around without hoping to get anything in return, is simply beyond naive. I can admit, Chinese officials are inept at it. Lots of bureaucrats working on those projects do look for making a name for themselves over having the project succeed. Their competence is being questioned. Every time I'm seeing a watercooler talks of officials during industry events, it always comes to "facepalm manoeuvre" when their talks cross over "a yet another multi-gigabuck loan to another god forsaken country." I assure you, even within the party itself, these projects, at least, make people scratch their heads.
- toyg 8y agoThe US, France and other Western countries have used debt as a leash on poorer countries for a century. If “we” reduced this strategy in the last few years, it’s mostly for our own benefit (there is less money to spare, and debt-aid has become an internal political issue). Resenting China for following in our footstep is a bit disingenuous. I think the onus, now, is on the receiving countries, that hopefully have learnt how these faustian pacts work. The problem is not China financing poorer countries for its own benefit, but rather Western inability or unwillingness to give them a better deal. We bribed quite a few governments during the Cold War, but recently the only thing we seem to be doing is “violent peacekeeping”, if you catch my drift.