4 ms·
I don't understand the "bar publishing in 85% of journals" part; presumably they mean "exclusively". That actually means that papers (and research data hopeful
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
I don't understand the "bar publishing in 85% of journals" part; presumably they mean "exclusively".
That actually means that papers (and research data hopefully?!) can be published for the people who bought the research to be able to legally access it; but journals have opportunity to prove their added value still. And if they do add value, the market can provide a price for it.
So non-OA journals can still curate, review, typeset, index, etc., just not lock the publicly funded research itself away.
- IanCal 8y agoIt depends on how you read part of the EU statement, but there's a note about not accepting "the hybrid approach". If this refers to hybrid journals, then that would be the barring of publishing in large numbers of journals.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoSo if commercial services can add something -- on top of full, open disclosure of research findings -- they're going to make that unlawful? That seems strange: what does the public gain from that?
- IanCal 8y agoNo. There can still be commercial services, commercial for-profit publishing, etc. What they're saying is that simply they don't want to publish findings in subscription journals. > what does the public gain from that? The public and researchers gain permanent access to the research output regardless of which publisher, what deals are in place, where they are or whether their library has a current subscription. It allows researchers to do work analysing the content itself too as they'll then have a licence to do so (useful if you want to analyse, say, 10M papers). Research output reported in the news will be available for any interested party The downside is that instead of publishing for free and then the readers paying, the payment model will be flipped to upfront payment for services and then free access.
- Vinnl 8y agoResearchers funded by the participating funds are not allowed to publish in journals that do not make all of their research freely available, which indeed excludes many a popular journal today - unless they change their business model, which this plan appears to aim for.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoYou can require all footpaths to be mapped, and make those maps publicly accessible (for free), without having to make it illegal to sell a footpath map. That means the public can find all the footpaths, but if someone creates an innovative map, or a useful compendium they can still sell that.
- Vinnl 8y agoThey're not making it illegal to sell a footpath map, they're just disallowing you from paying a footpath map seller for giving your map away for free. Instead, you have to give them to people who are already giving away maps for free.