10 ms·
Can anyone suggest a wireless router that someone can buy today that either ships with or can be flashed with OSS firmware? I've been trying to shop around for
by kibwen 8y ago
Can anyone suggest a wireless router that someone can buy today that either ships with or can be flashed with OSS firmware? I've been trying to shop around for one compatible with DD-WRT or OpenWRT and been rather disheartened so far; every promising model I've found either requires you to play roulette with the specific hardware version of the router that you receive (which is never advertised on product pages), or is out of stock entirely, or costs upwards of $250 (which is tough to sell to my friends, when their ISP charges $10/mo to rent a router with much less hassle).
- Ahl4Gom6 8y agoI'm running openwrt on an R7800 and so far had no issues. But that's just the router, you'll still need a modem.
- ajayh 8y agoMaybe something like the PC Engines apu2? http://www.pcengines.ch/apu2.htm http://www.pcengines.ch/apu2.htm x86, can run OpenWRT.
- LambdaComplex 8y agoI'm currently using an apu4b4 running OpenBSD as a router; it's been a good way to (as a Linux guy) dip my feet into the BSD ecosystem. Later today (if all goes well) I'll be adding wifi to it!
- mrsteveman1 8y agoI have an APU2 and it's really the perfect router for any small office or house. Intel NICs, plenty of ram and an mSATA port make it quite capable. I have pfSense on it at the moment, which works very well. At one point I had an 802.11n card in my older ALIX2D router, but there were stability and performance issues so now I always use a separate access point, most recently a Unifi AC-PRO which has some quirks but works well in general. I've been happy enough with the x86 routing strategy that when it came time to replace my older Cisco 100mbps switch, I decided to do that with x86 hardware as well. All of the smaller/cheaper gigabit switches either didn't support VLANs, made way too much heat, or had reliability issues, and the ones that were suitable were quite expensive and had reliability issues of their own. So, I found a Supermicro Atom C2000 board (A1SRM-LN7F[1]) on sale for $90, which has 7 Intel NIC gigabit ports built-in and supports ECC ram. I put it in a Supermicro 1U[2] enclosure along with an Intel PCIe 4x gigabit NIC, for a total of 11 gigabit ports on the switch. I installed Debian on it and set up open-vswitch, which worked but was soon replaced by "vlan-aware" Linux bridging. It's easily capable of switching gigabit traffic between multiple machines at the same time, ping shows an average latency of 0.310ms, has very low power usage and makes very little heat. Note that those C2000 Atoms do have a "sudden death" hardware flaw, but Supermicro should have fixed it on more recent inventory, and they will send a "patched" board to replace any that are affected before they fail. The Atom C3000 doesn't have that issue, but I don't think Supermicro (or anyone, really) make any C3000 boards with that many built-in gigabit ports. [1] http://www.supermicro.com/products/motherboard/Atom/X10/A1SRM-LN7F-2358.cfm http://www.supermicro.com/products/motherboard/Atom/X10/A1SR... [2] http://www.supermicro.com/products/chassis/1U/510/SC510T-203B http://www.supermicro.com/products/chassis/1U/510/SC510T-203...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- isatty2 8y agoYou can build your own router with inexpensive hardware and run pfsense on it. You can find many guides for that online. Otherwise, get an edgerouter.
- sokoloff 8y agoI just last weekend retired a pair of Asus RT-AC66U routers/access points. They ran stable for years on Tomato (version tomato-RT-AC66U_AT-RT-AC6x-3.4-140-AIO-64K.trx) and I think all the hardware revisions work, but confirm that yourself. I retired them mostly because the Ubiquiti management is much easier and that hardware also affordable (though the software is not open, so not a fit for your use case).
- discreditable 8y agoSame case for me. I had an AC88U. I got tired of it because the 5GHz 802.11ac radio seemed like it'd be forever broken in OSS firmwares. I felt asuswrt was pretty crappy too. I went ubiquiti. Their management is nice, and they actually seem interested in fixing bugs in their firmware.
- sokoloff 8y agoOn the AC66U, 5GHz radio seemed to work well and I got consistent 105-ish Mbps in the same room as the AP. (I'm not disputing your experience, but don't want other readers to conclude that 5GHz doesn't work on any of them.)
- discreditable 8y agoI could be wrong or things may have changed. I think the core issue was the 88u used a different broadcom wireless chipset which has very poor Linux support.
- bscphil 8y agoIs that the expected rate on an AC66U? I'm getting close to 300 Mbps real-world speeds in a very noisy environment on my Unifi lite.
- sokoloff 8y agoSorry. I certainly should have been clearer, especially with this crowd. That test was rate-limited by my cable modem. I was on a 100-down package at the time. I did not do a intra-house speed test.
- linuxlizard 8y agoSo far, I've had very good luck with the ASUS AC1300 (asus_rt-ac58u) and OpenWRT. I still need to add to the openwrt wiki but it was pretty easy. (Luck == I've bought two so far, plan to buy more)
- CallMeZach 8y agoI like Mikrotik hap ac(at work) or hap ac lite (at home). they simply work. always.
- dboreham 8y agoAlthough RouterOS is based on OSS (Linux kernel), parent wanted to flash the unit with software they built themselves from source. This afaik isn't possible with Mikrotik hardware. Edit: actually, it is possible at least for some MT hardware : https://wiki.openwrt.org/toh/mikrotik/common https://wiki.openwrt.org/toh/mikrotik/common
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoI know this doesn't help friends and non-technical folks, but I finally gave up and bought an APU[0], installed Debian, and configured dnsmasq+hostapd+iptables. With unattended updates, it was the most secure thing I could think of. Well, I suppose using openbsd would have been potentially more secure, but there were driver issues with the wireless card that I wanted. [0] https://pcengines.ch/apu2.htm https://pcengines.ch/apu2.htm
- kuon 8y agoI second that. I don't use wireless and know OpenBSD well, so I went the OpenBSD route, but I am sure linux can be made to be very secure if configured properly. It can sustain 500mbit/s with no issue. As this is my internet connection speed, I don't know if it can go any higher.
- dsr_ 8y agoI highly recommend this sort of roll-your-own, with Debian or OpenBSD depending on your skill set.
- LeoPanthera 8y agoI'm running pfSense on an APU2. Works great. A good option if you don't want the effort of configuring things manually - pfSense has a nice web UI.
- bscphil 8y agoI really, really love these machines. I'm using one with OPNsense myself. They're just fast enough to get gigabit throughput, but no faster (or more power hungry). Personally I like to separate switching from the firewall and so I've got everything attached to an unmanaged switch or a Unifi AP. My one complaint about this approach is that there are so many interactions happening at the software level that any time I set up a network stack, I always feel as though the whole thing is very fragile and only works because everything is precisely configured. Since I like to tinker, I want a system that feels more reliable, and so I go for the router-in-a-box approach of pfsense or opnsense. I wish it was easy to get a network configuration that "just works".
- pingec 8y agoYou can take a look here https://forum.openwrt.org/c/hardware-questions-and-recommendations https://forum.openwrt.org/c/hardware-questions-and-recommend... There are many brands and models that are compatible with OpenWRT. I have good experience with tp-link wr1043nd, wdr3600 but they are a bit old by now. I just ordered ZyXEL NBG6617 to test out.
- rando444 8y ago(1) Ask the manufacturer (2) If you get the wrong router, just return it and get another. (3) Buy a router at a brick and mortar store so you know what you're getting.
- pbasista 8y agoThere are a lot of them, but depending on which features you need and where you live, it might be difficult to get one. Take a look e.g. at OpenWrt's list of devices "Ideal for OpenWrt": https://openwrt.org/toh/views/toh_available_864 https://openwrt.org/toh/views/toh_available_864 Consider TP-Link Archer C7, for instance. It is an older one, but has reasonably fast hardware, supports IEEE 802.11ac and is available on Amazon. New costs ~75 USD, a "certified refurbished" version costs ~50 USD.
- EmmEff 8y agoSadly, the Archer C7 cannot exceed 60Mbit/s without hardware offload when running OpenWRT. I had to replace mine with a Ubiquiti wireless access point and a dedicated pfSense box.
- pbasista 8y agoSource? Are you talking about wireless speed or wired speed? I am asking because I have never experienced such a huge limitation caused by the CPU bottleneck. I have performed some simple tests using `iperf` tool on Archer C7 with OpenWrt and it was able to sustain wired network speeds of around 750 Mb/s and wireless speeds (IEEE 802.11ac) of around 300 Mb/s (maybe even more, but I do not remember exactly).
- gruez 8y agoWere you using stock firmware or openwrt
- rubatuga 8y agoThere are newer firmwares that allow me to get WAN to LAN ~500 Mbit over 5ghz, and WAN to LAN 950 Mbit over Ethernet
- pjmlp 8y agoHere in Germany there is the Fritz brand. If I am not mistaken FRITZ!OS is a Linux distribution.
- gsich 8y agocorrect. But I don't know how much customization is possible after AVM disabled telnet (on the newer boxes).
- alias_neo 8y agoFor something with hardware offload, get a Ubiquiti EdgeRouter. I run one at home, it's debian based, I have lots of tools I've written in Go compiled and running on it for various purposes and you can install debian packages for things you need. The other option I've heard good things about are the PCEngines devices. They don't, as far as I'm aware, have hardware offload, so make sure their performance suits, but they use OSS U-Boot and you install the OS of your choice. It's one of the most open devices in a router form factor I've come across. Depending on the number of ports you need, you could also use one of the Jetway devices. They make them with varying numbers of ports as SBCs in a case and you add RAM/M.2 SSD. I got a Celeron one with 2 ports and run it as a Suricata IPS. It performed just fine with my 100M pipe.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoI am curious what type of things you're running on your router. I have an ER-X, but haven't ever thought to run software on it (aside from some of the obvious packages like VPN and such).
- yumraj 8y agoWhich VPN do you run on it? Wireguard? How's the performance, I ask as I too have an ER-X.
- msh 8y agoI have ipsec on my er-x, it's build in. They have a bug in the ipsec offloading in the last few firmware releases so that can't be enabled. So speeds are kind a slow, around 50-90 megabits (i have gigabit fiber, that the er-x otherwise can fill out completely).
- chooseaname 8y agoNot OP, but, I use the built in IPSec vpn. I have been looking into WireGuard though.
- zamadatix 8y agoI have an EAP Proxy Python script running. It allows me to easily and permanently bypass my ATT fiber modem. Speed and service quality went way up when I did that.
- bipson 8y agoInterestingly enough, MikroTik routers are mostly well supported by OpenWrt it seems. At least that's what my search for something that is beefier than regular OTS Routers has yielded. Flashing OpenWrt is a little cumbersome though. TP-Link, the former manufacturer of my choice, unfortunately has become a version roulette it seems. If power consumption does not bother you, maybe banana pi? Or something atom based?
- arminiusreturns 8y agoUbiquiti EdgeOS based edgerouters are what I prefer as a greybeard sysadmin type who has dealt with everything under the sun. It's VyOS (Vyatta) based, they are now complying with gpl afaik, and their hardware is really good for the price/performance ratio. The edgerouter-x or lite can be found for ~$99 and is a great piece of gear. Another option would be your own hardware with pfsense (bsd) or ipfire(linux). Even further would be your own hardware with linux and write your own nftables or bpf.
- nvarsj 8y agoThe ERL family is pretty bad as a router, in my experience. There is a longstanding firmware issue that introduces packet loss for routed packets (it doesn't multiplex across the dual cores correctly, which leads to out of order packets). If you really want to use Ubiquiti, I would suggest using an ER-X which is cheaper, doesn't have this problem, and is quadcore. The best option in my opinion is something Intel based running a well known Linux distro with automated security updates that is fully in your control. Shorewall can do everything needed for a home router. This option is a lot more expensive though.
- Bluecobra 8y agoInteresting that the more expensive router has this problem. I've been really happy with my ER-X, it works great with my internet service (500Mbs up/500Mbs down). I had some speed issues at first but this was solved by upgrading to the latest firmware and making sure hardware offloading was enabled.
- larkost 8y agoI was a bit annoyed that hardware routing is not automatically enabled for setups that can use it. It is not hard, but you have to stumble upon the fact that that setting exists (only on the command line).
- Kadin 8y agoMy recollection is that it's not enabled by default because there were (are?) some features that don't work once you enable it. I assume it's the Deep Packet Inspection and advanced routing type stuff. (Sadly my home internet connection is too slow to make hardware offloading on the edge router matter...)
- paulcole 8y agoI just pay the $10/month. The complete lack of hassle makes it worth it to me. Of all the things in the world I want to do, futzing with some OSS firmware is pretty close to the bottom of the list. What’s your reason for suggesting friends buy a modem/router beyond the cost?
- erikdared 8y agoI've had good luck running OpenWRT on this TP-Link model: https://www.tp-link.com/us/products/details/cat-9_Archer-C2600.html https://www.tp-link.com/us/products/details/cat-9_Archer-C26.... I believe there's only one hardware version so no gamble there.
- fegul 8y agoSame here. Just picked one up a few weeks back and used the stock web-gui to upload the newest OpenWRT. Worked without a hitch.
- jsjohnst 8y agoI personally love pfSense and there’s tons of hardware for $100-250 that supports it.
- technofiend 8y agoUntil very recently I would just go to Microcenter and purchase a cheap refurbished small form factor PC plus two Intel NICs and run OpenBSD. For less than $200 you have a fully functional router albeit at a higher power cost than a true appliance. If you really need a small / low power usage appliance then some Ubiquiti devices run OpenBSD as I mentioned in another reply below. Anecdotally OpenBSD also supports wireguard if that's a concern. https://www.openbsd.org/octeon.html https://www.openbsd.org/octeon.html https://marc.info/?l=openbsd-ports&m=152712417729497&w=2 https://marc.info/?l=openbsd-ports&m=152712417729497&w=2
- letmeaskaq7532 8y agoAnything that you can install OpenWRT on :)
- tempuser24 8y agoHere's a list of recommended ones from OpenWRT https://openwrt.org/toh/recommended_routers https://openwrt.org/toh/recommended_routers. I would assume that they are easy to flash and high compatible.
- tga 8y agoHow about a $15.88, small but surprisingly capable, NEXX WT3020? [0] [0] https://www.aliexpress.com/item/Wifi-Router-NEXX-WT3020H-300Mbps-Portable-Mini-Router-802-11-b-g-nwifi-Repeater-Wifi-Bridge/32740552501.html https://www.aliexpress.com/item/Wifi-Router-NEXX-WT3020H-300... [1] https://wiki.openwrt.org/toh/nexx/wt3020 https://wiki.openwrt.org/toh/nexx/wt3020
- doctorpangloss 8y agoThe Netgear Nighthawk series is almost always available on Amazon and is generally well supported by dd-wrt. Specifically, the best deals can be had on the oldest model, the R6700v3, from an Amazon warehouse deal for $70. This is what I use, and it works without issue with dd-wrt. You'll need to flash it 3 times. The best device is probably the R7800 model. It uses a very fast, non-Broadcom (OpenWRT-supported), modern chip. The only way this matters in practice is if (1) you have a gigabit Internet connection and (2) if you need QoS turned on for scoring an A+ in "bufferbloat" on speedtest.net--i.e., you play games. If you don't use QoS, you will be able to serve 1 gigabit with dd-wrt's "Shortcut Forwarding Engine," which is an accelerated "in-Linux-kernel IP packet forwarding engine." If you don't have a gigabit connection, the typical Linux routing stuff that dd-wrt uses is fine. With regards to model roulette, you can always buy it off eBay for the specific model. These routers are so common I see listing for them in Craigslist in the Bay Area right now. I would argue the two main reasons to do this are for improved security/stability and QoS. If you're not interested in these features, buy something that Wirecutter recommends in your price range. But compared to $70, I believe a truly decent router can be had for $50 (the Archer series others have mentioned) that is also truly ancient. The Apple Airport devices run ARM NetBSD and you can SSH into them. The last generation ran NetBSD 7 and executed binaries from NetBSD userspace when compiled statically. OpenWRT does not ship closed-source Broadcom drivers, so it tends to have worse support across the board. I don't think their OSS-related reasons for doing so are material to you.
- willangley 8y ago+1 to OpenWRT 18.x / Netgear R7800. It's one of the only WiFi routers I've ever worked with that has a fallback flash mode in the bootloader, and the only one that I know you can buy today. This is invaluable when you're not sure if something you're doing could make it fail to boot, like installing an upgrade without knowing whether it uses the same partition layout as you had. When it does you can just try again. (I've needed this once already.)
- ThatSmell 8y agoQuick word of caution on the r6700 series: Be careful to avoid the r6700v2 if interested in third-party firmwares. v2 is incompatible for chip-related reasons I don't fully understand, or was as of just a couple months ago. Easy to miss the v2 part when shopping on Amazon, which is how I ended up with my current doorstop.
- tomatocracy 8y agoI have one of the Linksys WRT-AC series (WRT-1900ACS but they are all pretty similar I think) - they're very well supported by OpenWRT (stock firmware is a derivative of OpenWRT in fact at least on some of them). Hardware specs are good, including reasonably fast CPUs (good enough to saturate a VPN at 100Mbit at least which is the uplink I have here). The open source wireless chipset support is towards the better end too - not perfect but a lot better than some others. If you're flashing your own images of OpenWRT, there are a few conveniences which are a bit more uncommon in the hardware which are useful if you ever need to debrick - eg easily openable case, UART header comes pre-installed (you don't need to solder your own), etc.