3 ms·
> The entire air force and navy are sitting ducks and totally obsolete in the face of a somewhat modern cheap drone air force and antiship missles That's a fan
by adventured 8y ago
> The entire air force and navy are sitting ducks and totally obsolete in the face of a somewhat modern cheap drone air force and antiship missles
That's a fantasy that might exist 30 years from now; one which nobody possesses today at a US-threatening level. Only China is close, and if it comes to sinking ships then we're at WW3. Currently China is entirely trapped inside of their borders and or very close proximity to those borders. There isn't a single country other than the US with global force projection, in which they can push their logistics, support, weapons and supply outside of their borders for an extended period of time or at a far distance.
How are cheap Chinese drones going to help, when everything in your country looks like Syria and you have no runways or infrastructure including electricity? You're entirely stuck within your own borders, while the US bombs your vital infrastructure from outside of it. When enough damage is done, it proceeds to traditional bombing runs.
There are only two adversaries to the US that that doesn't apply to: China and Russia, due to their scale.
Absolutely nothing changes until other nations achieve sustainable projection external of their own borders. Otherwise, everything inside of those borders becomes a captive target. The cost of projecting outside of your borders, is extremely high. More likely, only Russia and China will continue to possess that ability among traditional US foes.
- flukus 8y agoThey don't need global force projection, just about everything the need or hope to gain from war is on or near their borders. China doesn't need to blow up US carriers in the Atlantic, they just need to control the south china sea which is much easier and cheaper. They're happy to let the US bleed money on trying to maintain themselves as a global power. If they really want to cripple the US then a large scale cyber attack would be orders of magnitude cheaper and far more effective than any military one.
- AtlasBarfed 8y agoAnd you are pretending that the Chinese don't have nuclear ICBMs, and they also can take out the entire pacific fleet in hours with antiship ICBMs. As for the air force, drones will take them out, and any land forces then won't have mobility or logistical support in Asia or the Pacific. The air force and navy as currently constituted are just corporate welfare programs.
- mercutio2 8y agoDid you just skip the “if it comes to that we’re in WW3” part? It seems to me adventured is fully acknowledging that if China wants a shooting war, they can take out US Pacific carrier groups, after which Beijing and Shanghai will be smoking craters, and we’ll find out if US anti-missile defense is any good (I tend to think it’s snake oil, but I’d really rather avoid testing that). The goal of having a military is to encourage diplomatic ends. The US has many diplomatic goals that don’t involve combat on the Chinese mainland. It’s also not clear to me that in a shooting war scenario it’s a bad plan to have some manned fighters, assuming basically all EM channels for controlling drones will be jammed.