3 ms·
I don't think you'll get that kind of security in this space-time continuum... If you send an open message to X, you just aren't going to keep X from sharing t
by joe_the_user 16y ago
I don't think you'll get that kind of security in this space-time continuum...
If you send an open message to X, you just aren't going to keep X from sharing that message with others.
-- There no real way around this. It's essentially the "problem" that DRM aimed to "solve". Thankfully, it couldn't. Only share things that are appropriate for a given friend or group of friends. This applies on Facebook or anywhere.
- bad_user 16y agoThen why bother with a Facebook alternative?
- joe_the_user 16y agoGood question. Reasons for a Facebook alternative: * While counting on your friends to not share your data is going to be dicey regardless, at least your data is not automatically going to be sold. * Facebook changes it's interface and terms of service at it's discretion. You should be in charge of any changes to a sharing process. * Facebook has the stated aim of forcing everyone on the net to use a single identity. This is a rather Orwellian position that we should avoid (goes with the problem of FB changing their interface and terms of service whenever they wish).
- bad_user 16y agoYes, I've been reading the other comments, and a distributed network would have some advantages, but also disadvantages, a strong analogy being email and smtp. About the FB identity, that's also very attractive to developers, and Appleseed should solve it somehow: if a website uses FB for user logins it gets almost-instant sign-up, user photo, user name, email (if requested) and access to a whole list of friends. That's a pretty powerful incentive for websites to get integrated with Facebook.
- joe_the_user 16y agoWell, One scheme would involve a system to merge multiple email and Facebook accounts into a single meta-view. I'll be making an announcement when the time is right...
- joe_the_user 16y agoFor identity, why not use OpenId? It really seems like Facebook itself offers any more services as such than the regular web does. It just packages them more nicely - that isn't to say the packaging important, it's clearly very important.
- bad_user 16y agoI do not like OpenID: 1) people have to remember their service's endpoints, and the interface is getting cluttered with buttons for the major suppliers, and personally I have OpenID accounts by multiple endpoints, and even I had trouble logging in to StackOverflow. There are 500 million people with an already existing Facebook account. Those people don't have to remember anything besides their Facebook login info. 2) On Facebook both the name and the email address is mandatory, and people want and do share their profile photo. Many people also have location info, which is quite useful for location-aware apps. This is sparing you from asking (I'm sick and tired of filling my profile info on various sites I visit, but my Facebook account is up to date). With OpenID you don't know what you're getting about that user. 3) You also get a little extra if you want: like the list of the user's friends, which is evil, but very attractive for me :)
- michaelchisari 16y agoAppleseed uses identities that look just like an email address. For instance, mine is: michael.chisari@developer.appleseedproject.org My public profile then is: developer.appleseedproject.org/michael.chisari When I'm logged into my home node, I can go to any other Appleseed node, and "remote login" with my Appleseed identity. From there, it uses the same flow as OpenID, just in a more user-friendly fashion. It's all quite painless for the end user.
- 16y ago
- qntm 16y agoI'm glad I'm not the only person who thinks this. Friendship is not an idempotent operation. Facebook connects up hundreds of millions of people and makes it extremely simple for them to share information. It's a social internet. To make any kind of attempt to preserve privacy is practically oxymoronic.