3 ms·
"Insider trading of securities is illegal....The problem is that it drives people away. This is an interesting observation in light of some conversations I've
by nostrademons 8y ago
"Insider trading of securities is illegal....The problem is that it drives people away.
This is an interesting observation in light of some conversations I've had with 20-somethings who have abandoned the stock market in favor of cryptocurrencies.
For a couple decades now, the message has been "you can't beat the stock market. You're competing against top mathematicians who do this for a living and colocate boxes in the exchange so they can execute trades faster than you. Why even try when you're just going to be the sucker for some finance professional? Go invest in index funds instead." (Note that this advice is quite self-serving for a fund manager: it justifies the huge fees they charge. It's also quite self-serving for index funds, which compete on price.)
It seems like the youngest generation - the ones just leaving college now - took this to heart and figured "Well, if there's no point for us even trying in the stock market, let's just throw the whole thing away and invent a new asset class", cheerfully ignoring that they are also throwing out all the regulatory protections that protect against insider trading.
Even with all the SEC's insider trading laws, the existence of vast computer systems capable of crunching terabytes of data and executing a trade in microseconds now creates such an information imbalance that people are leaving the market anyway.
It makes me wonder if all markets have a natural death. As they get more efficient, liquidity dries up. Fewer and fewer people bother playing when they know that someone else is just going to get rich off them. Eventually the winner becomes like the kid on the playground who insists on winning every game; all the other kids refuse to play with him, and he's left shooting hoops perfectly alone. Meanwhile they go off and create a new game that is fresh enough that new entrants might actually have a chance - at least until somebody becomes really good at that, and the cycle repeats itself.
- dillondoyle 8y agoYeah but stock market isn't zero sum... I can't tell if you're actually arguing don't invest in stock market because some HFT might get higher returns or some index fund will get .05% (somehow forgetting your 7% or even higher recently annual gains). Or perhaps you're trying to illustrate someone else's (wrong) mindset.
- bluecalm 8y agoI think you are over-estimating thinking process of people who buy crypto-currencies. I think vast majority buy them because of greed and ignorance about technology (they believe it's really the next big thing because that's what this or that popular blogger or video maker said). It's like buying a lottery ticket but it's easier to believe the chance to get rich is bigger. >>It makes me wonder if all markets have a natural death. As they get more efficient, liquidity dries up 100% efficient markets is dream come true for individual investor. Stocks represent equity in something that produces value. You want to put your money there at some point in your life and you want to sell that for cash at a different point in your life. There will always be people in accumulation phase and there will always be people in cash-out phase. The more efficient market gets the less likely you are to make a bad decision. Market efficiency cause by very good fast traders is fantastic for individual investors. Imagine you hold for example AMD stock before recent earnings. You want to sell because you need cash. If the market weren't fast to react you (unaware of the results) might have sold for much less than the stock was worth. Those fast reacting traders just saved you whole bunch of money and you got a better price. Sure, it's more difficult to buy something dirty cheap but remember that only happens if the other side is uninformed. The more efficient the market the less losses caused by information asymmetry and the more time saved which would otherwise be needed for research. That being said I think the markets are far away from being efficient today.
- imh 8y agoIt seems to have a natural equilibrium. The issue is that it's too popular and valuable, there are people putting too much effort in, so a casual investor won't get into it. If it were less popular and valuable, it wouldn't be worth putting so much effort in, so people wouln't, making it more appealing to a casual investor. The feedback loop seems to be stable.