3 ms·
Japan's problem is multi-faceted. What the facets are and which one had more impact, I don't know. From the top of my head: Low pop growth, high savings-low d
by mc32 8y ago
Japan's problem is multi-faceted. What the facets are and which one had more impact, I don't know. From the top of my head: Low pop growth, high savings-low domestic consumerism (low investment), reliance on exports, reliance on economic intermediaries (friction), relatively closed markets (reducing competitiveness), recent-graduate hiring system, private-public industry ties (misallocation), gender bias in labor (low labor part by one gender), political system which does not foster long-term strategies from gov't., etc.
- adventured 8y ago> high savings Japan has an extremely low savings rate. They had a high savings rate 20 years ago. The broader economic decline has coincided with their savings rate dropping to nearly zero. https://i.imgur.com/j4jZPIb.jpg https://i.imgur.com/j4jZPIb.jpg That's also why the Japanese Government had to shift to debasing the Yen instead of continually borrowing from domestic savings to fund their debt. There is no domestic savings to buy up the debt issuance. The whole process is resulting in the wipe out of the Japanese standard of living. It's their debt that is entirely responsible, it's plundering their ability to invest in the private economy effectively. There's no reason the Japanese shouldn't be capable of a GDP per capita on par with Sweden, the Netherlands or Denmark. Instead they're continually falling further behind. When all of your money is going to service debt, you can no longer properly invest into growth opportunities. We see this effect at the household level, at the corporate level, and at the national level. Japan already had nice infrastructure when they went on a debt-laden public works bonanza to try to prop up their flailing economic growth, so the return on that investment in real terms is plausibly extremely negative. Not only did they make the mistake of massively over-investing into infrastructure right when their population was set to begin declining, not only did they use debt to do it (which they'll never stop paying for), but now they have to try to maintain it. Put simply, they misallocated their wealth to extravagant public works spending that they didn't actually need, and did so at exactly the wrong time.
- Camillo 8y agoInteresting post, thanks. Was the investment in infrastructure considered a Keynesian policy at the time?