3 ms·
Sun, DEC, and so on were very successful until they weren’t. To say Sun was always a failure ignores the 90s when they weren’t.
by seanmcdirmid 8y ago
Sun, DEC, and so on were very successful until they weren’t. To say Sun was always a failure ignores the 90s when they weren’t.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI certainly agree with this, but both Sun and DEC started out very 'open' and then got more and more closed and vertical and then they died. I have a couple of custom chips in my PDP-8, perhaps a dozen in my PDP-11, and a whole bunch in the VAX. Similar pattern with Sun-2, Sun-3, Sun4, and then Sun 10/20/Ultra... It was the very success that they were experiencing that lead them to believe that they could capture more and more of the 'value chain' until they couldn't any more. I expect this will end badly for Apple but I am open to other ideas about why it won't.
- HankB99 8y agoI think one difference is that Sun and DEC were selling to enterprise/business markets whereas Apple sells to the consumer market. I think the former tend to make decisions more based on cost/benefit while the latter tend to be more emotionally driven. If Apple can continue to succeed with that I think they will continue to survive.
- _ph_ 8y agoWhat killed Sun and DEC and other RISC manufacturers (also PowerPC) was, that once the PC market grew to a certain size, they couldn't keep up with Intel as Intel could afford a magnitude more R&D costs with their processors and equally had lesser production costs. This shows, that going vertical won't work, if your production numbers drop below a certain threshhold, the economy of scale would work against you. For Apple, the combined range of iOS devices currently gives them enough scale. I think Sun could have had a much better chance, if they had pushed SPARC processors into the private market too, like offering a decent SPARC based ATX motherboard for all the PC enthusiasts setting up their Linux machines.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoI don’t think either Sun or DEC started out as very open, at least in hardware, and probably in software either. Much of their openness comes at the end of their reigns. At any rate, I don’t think this had very much to do with their downfalls.
- kbob 8y agoIn what way was early DEC not open? In the 1960s and 1970s, every DEC computer came with a full schematic. You could troubleshoot any signal on any board. Most of it was COTS components, and replacements were easily obtained. Also, by 1980 there was a thriving industry of 3rd party add-on boards. The operating systems were less open, but that had a lot to do with the cost of distributing megabytes of source code. It was possible and recommended to recompile RT-11, at least, from source to optimize for your hardware configuration.
- tluyben2 8y agoSun, DEC and SGI made the same mistakes imho; they ignored PCs for far too long. Apple too by the way. They thought people wanted custom hardware and software to render movie, run 3d software, do scientific computing etc and for a while that was very true (as someone who has many Sun, DEC and SGI machines still at home and they all still work perfectly, which you cannot say for PCs from that age, for me it is still true but alas), but PC hardware, software and economies of scale passed them by and they responded far too late. It went the same way with mainframes to minis, minis to workstations, home computers to pcs, so it was not like they did not have examples of this in their past. It was printing money in the 90s for them though, things were just too good.
- rbanffy 8y agoWhat killed SPARC, Alpha, and MIPS wasn't that they became worse than others, but that cheaper x86 boxes running Linux became good enough. There is a point where running your workloads on higher end hardware ceases to provide benefit and only cause lower hardware utilization. I'd love to be able to justify an IBM z14 or one of the higher end Sun (I refuse to call them Oracle) boxes, or even an 8-way Xeon Platinum, but more often than not, a couple VMs on your favorite cloud provider will solve the problem neatly with simpler accounting maneuvers. Apple is already using its own IP on iPhones and iPads (and, increasingly, in components for their x86 computers). They also have a good idea of what their hardware runs and that places them in a great position to optimize the hardware to their software - to the point they could implement OS-level functions into microcode or do some other types of highly specialized tuning other companies who make chips for the general market can't (or won't - see the PPC heat issue that made Apple go Intel). That said, Apple didn't abandon PPC because PPC couldn't be better than Intel. They abandoned PPC because their laptop volume didn't justify the investment needed to make PPC G5 have similar performance per watt to what Intel was achieving with their Core series (itself a direction change from the Pentium IV family's dead end). IBM offered Cell to them and Jobs didn't think it'd work (the Cell, with its crappy PPUs and memory-disconnected SPUs is probably the hardest thing to program I've ever seen) well. Intel, on the other hand, was looking for a huge PR win and Apple was it.