3 ms·
Skimming, that paper says there's no support for it, rather than there being evidence to falsify the idea that different people learn better in different ways.
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
Skimming, that paper says there's no support for it, rather than there being evidence to falsify the idea that different people learn better in different ways.
I seem to learn best when I write stuff down; I've assumed this wasn't true for everyone.
Presumably a basic test like presenting new subjects to a group in 3 different ways (lecture, reading material, activity -- say) and test the group, see if subject matter uptake is identical in each case. Could someone link that, it seems to be like the first thing you'd test?
94% of UK teachers think their pupils learn better through individualised learning methods (according to your first link), but you contend their belief is false ... even though there's no formalised support (again according to the link) why do you think teachers feel there is. Surely they see a portion of their pupils are giving better responses if they present knowledge in one way vs another? Any thoughts on how nearly all teachers are mislead in this way?
It also says, roughly, a third say they'll continue to present according to personalised methodologies even if there's no evidence (yet!) to support that pedagogy. That seems natural; if something appears to work when you do it, even if someone else has no evidence that it works you'll keep doing it.
So which method of information is best for all people, as the contention is this isn't variable: all people learn best by ...? (hearing, seeing, taking part, watching, ...)?
- Kalium 8y ago> Skimming, that paper says there's no support for it, rather than there being evidence to falsify the idea that different people learn better in different ways. Yes. That's the phrasing you get when researchers mean "As far as we can tell it's bullshit". Generally coupled with data that shows them looking for effects and finding zilch - which is the negative evidence you're looking for. Do you think there's something lacking here?
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoThe part that's always deliberately ignored in these studies is, that people may have a preference for different presentations and processes. So while, if you force people (in an experimental environment) to use one techinique, and they end up learning about as well, it ignores the idea that they would have resisted learning that thing at all if it was only presented that way?
- Kalium 8y agoI'm not sure I understand your point. Are you saying that the idea of Learning Styles, which are about how effectively an individual student learns a subject depending on presentation style, ignores personal preferences of students that don't have an impact on instructional efficacy? Or that it ignores the preferences of teachers?
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoIt ignores the fact that one student will ignore the reading if not forced to do it, while another prefers the reading and completes it. Etc. So we see, in practice, different outcomes for different students depending on how the material is presented.
- Kalium 8y agoThank you for clarifying! As I understand them, these studies of Learning Styles are focused entirely on pedagogical methods and their efficacy at teaching material to students. The implication, as near as I can tell, is that a student's personal preferences for how they might do things outside an instruction environment is not relevant to efficacy inside an instructional environment. You seem to be contending that a person's preferences for how to learn can and should be expected to impact the efficiency of their learning process - which sounds a lot like the Learning Styles idea! After all, if a student might have resisted an approach in a counterfactual scenario but did learn successfully and as efficiently as a student who would not have resisted that same approach, then the same outcome is achieved in both theory and practice. Have I missed something? Perhaps I have failed to understand your point?
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoNo I contend nothing nothing about efficiency of each process- its the choice to participate at all that can make the difference. And I read that first link, which seems to survey teachers and their opinions, with vague questions and no hard data. Not very damning at all? Which paper was nailing which coffins? I missed it.
- alxlaz 8y ago> Skimming, that paper says there's no support for it, rather than there being evidence to falsify the idea that different people learn better in different ways. There is also no evidence to falsify the idea that there is a magical teapot orbiting Mars, and that if you rub it with your left hand in a certain rhythm, the Goddess of Tea herself will emerge and grant you three wishes, as long as they involve tea. But we're not rushing to put a manned spacecraft on the orbit of Mars the way we've rushed to adopt the learning styles theory -- even though enough money has been sunk into it that it might have at least paid for a decent launch pad :-). Indeed, people prefer to receive information in one manner or another, there's nothing surprising here (like you, it seems to me that I learn best when I write stuff down), and there is plenty of evidence for it. However, there is no evidence to suggest that adjusting teaching methods based on these preferences leads to better student outcome. There have been attempts to "rescue" this stuff by claiming that well, it doesn't necessarily make students learn better, but at least it makes school seem more palatable, friendlier and so on, so it's more interesting and so it indirectly does produce better results. But it turns out that, especially when groups and standard curriculae are involves, several studies have shown that it actually leads to worse results (https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00220270210141891 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0022027021014189... is the most cited, but there are others as well), because there are pedagogical difficulties in adjusting content and teaching styles. It may look surprising at first, but if you've ever had to teach, it's almost disappointingly obvious. Adjusting topics that inherently lend themselves to a teaching style to a different teaching style produces vastly inferior results -- and, anecdotally, it turns out to be even less interesting than it would have been in the first place. > Any thoughts on how nearly all teachers are mislead in this way? The same way that, 150 years ago, nearly all teachers were misled to think that we were created just like we are today 7,000 years ago. At one point, there was a (more or less) scientific consensus that This Is How Things Are, and if you wanted to pass the exams that you need to pass in order to be allowed to teach, then this is what you had to say. The consensus was abandoned, of course, but the misconception stuck for a long time. This is especially problematic in volatile and fashion-inducing fields (like psychology): practicing psychologists keep in touch with these things. They were taught this theory in the 1980s, but they stayed in the field and understand that we now know it's bollocks. Teachers don't. If you teach anything except for psychology, you probably took a few classes on psychology and pedagogy back in university and that was it (that's certainly how it went in my case). Unless you're keenly interested in this matter (or, like me, you have a psychologist in your family), you don't follow these developments.