7 ms·
I really don't get the hate this is receiving considering the context of what is going on in Los Angeles. Traffic is a problem city wide, but it is particularl
by slg 8y ago
I really don't get the hate this is receiving considering the context of what is going on in Los Angeles. Traffic is a problem city wide, but it is particularly bad for events at Dodgers Stadium. Musk's plan won't fix all of that, but it won't hurt. I also don't see how the plan is any more outlandish than this [1] plan for gondolas to Dodgers Stadium which is closer to actually happening. Either way, both of those projects are using private money. If people want to try to fix traffic themselves and all they need from the public is permission, why should we stop them? That is an infinitely better approach that approving spending hundreds of millions of public dollars on a trolley system a few miles from Dodgers Stadium [2] or an even more massive investments into a subway system that most Angelenos never use and therefore are hesitant to support.
[1] - http://www.lamag.com/citythinkblog/gondola-proposal/ http://www.lamag.com/citythinkblog/gondola-proposal/
[2] - http://www.latimes.com/opinion/editorials/la-ed-downtown-streetcar-20180818-story.html http://www.latimes.com/opinion/editorials/la-ed-downtown-str...
- x0x0 8y agoElon's plan is very expensive and clearly won't help, if you're even mildly numerate (2400 whole people per hour at full capacity). It's also farcical to pretend this will happen without enormous piles of public money, both implicit in terms of right of way, and explicit via enormous subsidies. The proposed revenues are a dollar per ride! This thing is an enormous cash fire.
- stcredzero 8y agoclearly won't help, if you're even mildly numerate (2400 whole people per hour at full capacity) So you're defining "help" == "completely solve." Would you say that a program offering discounts to people who carpool to Dodger's stadium would not help unless it completely solved the problem? Would a gondola going to Dodger's stadium "not help?" It's also farcical to pretend this will happen without enormous piles of public money, both implicit in terms of right of way, and explicit via enormous subsidies. The whole point of the boring company is to get the tunnel boring infrastructure out of the government-laden, subsidy-heavy mode of operation. It's the same overall strategy as was behind SpaceX.
- tedunangst 8y agoIf our standard is every little bit helps, then how about a midfield helipad? Could probably deliver a dozen spectators and double as pregame entertainment.
- stcredzero 8y agoClearly "every little bit helps" is as much of a straw-man as "must completely solve." Replacing a part of the transport for 2500 people, in precisely the part of the trip that is most likely to be congested, using electric vehicles certainly sounds like it would be of more benefit with much reduced carbon footprint and noise pollution than a midfield helipad.
- mcguire 8y agoPlus, if you charge enough and supply champagne and caviar, people from the right social class will enjoy it very much.
- stcredzero 8y agoTake the proceeds from that, and put it to good use.
- gamblor956 8y agoYou could transport 2500 people for a few thousand bucks using a few buses and setting aside a game-day express lane for those buses. And the best part is, if the East Hollywood/Silverlake trips are popular, you can scale quickly and easily--and even on the fly--by simply using more buses. This is in fact what they already do for Dodgers fans taking public transportation to the game from Union Station.
- jcranmer 8y ago> The whole point of the boring company is to get the tunnel boring infrastructure out of the government-laden, subsidy-heavy mode of operation. ... I'm not sure I agree. Given that The Boring Company has spent most of its effort on selling its PRT (er, sorry, "Loop", since PRT is apparently so 20th century) technology, and has basically made no attempts to bid for any actual tunneling contracts, it's all about trying to make a new (well, new attempt at a never-successful old) transit mode and not about tunneling at all.
- takk309 8y agoA gondola has hardware that can be removed in the future, possibly even sold to another user. A tunnel would be very permanent and possibly cause problems in the future. As the article stated, it is very hard to expand the size of a tunnel once it has be constructed. This limited size means that it can not be upgraded in any meaningful way. Ultimately, for a plan like this to work, the tunnel should be constructed as large as possible so that there is room for future growth.
- stcredzero 8y agoThat's exactly the sort of logic that traditionally inflates tunnel infrastructure projects.
- takk309 8y agoHow is it that the logic is flawed? There are real-world examples of undersized tunnels limited the growth of a subway network. London was specifically called out in the article.
- stcredzero 8y agoHow is it that the logic is flawed? It's the exact opposite of YAGNI. It's attempting to build the ultimate end-all be-all up front. No wonder tunnel building is expensive, and all the projects wind up huge and bloated. There are real-world examples of undersized tunnels limited the growth of a subway network. London was specifically called out in the article. If a larger tunnel to Dodger stadium is needed, why couldn't it be dug below, with the old tunnel used to carry infrastructure for the new tunnel? That seems a solvable technical feat.
- discodave 8y agoIt sounds like you're trying to bring a software mindset to an infrastructure problem, which is somewhat laudable, but ultimately misguided in this instance. In this instance, as others have pointed out, it's already clear that the Tunnel Elon is proposing doesn't carry enough passengers to make a dent in the transportation load for the stadium.
- dboshardy 8y agoI agree, it's not more outlandish, but a subway system is a proven and much cheaper alternative. > If people want to try to fix traffic themselves and all they need from the public is permission, why should we stop them? Public safety, regulation/oversight of construction in city limits. It's also IMHO naive to think Musk will fund this himself and not ask the city to foot the bill.
- m3kw9 8y agoMusks methods are unproven, but there it’s moderate risk high reward situation he is creating.
- slg 8y agoA subway might be a more complete answer, but there is no Musk character throwing private money at the city hoping to build a subway. Also like I mentioned previously, there is little political capital to expand the subway. The subway system as it currently stands is simply ignored by a huge percentage of the population and adding a small extension to Dodgers Stadium wouldn't change that. So yes, this won't help that much, but we shouldn't make the perfect the enemy of the good. Musk is currently claiming that he will not need public funds for this. I don't have any reason not to take him at his word. My opinion of this project would change if there would need to be any non-trivial public investments. However if this is a serious concern of the city, there are obviously ways to structure the contract so the city doesn't find themselves on the hook if Musk changes his mind.
- gamblor956 8y agoAlso like I mentioned previously, there is little political capital to expand the subway Stop spreading FUD. LA literally just passed Measure M a few years ago to...vastly increase its rail network. Metro is currently in the process of extending 3 lines, building a new line, an airport PeopleMover, and multiple multi-line connecting stations. This doesn't include the nearly 100 miles of additional rail planned for construction over the next 2 decades. The subway system as it currently stands is simply ignored by a huge percentage of the population and adding a small extension to Dodgers Stadium wouldn't change that. Completely false. About 20-25% of the Dodgers crowd takes Metro to the game. Musk is currently claiming that he will not need public funds for this. I don't have any reason not to take him at his word. Elon has made numerous misrepresentations about nearly all of his businesses, his personal life, and other people...just in the last year. At this point, anything he said should be viewed with suspicion unless he can provide corroborating evidence of its veracity.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 8y ago> If people want to try to fix traffic themselves and all they need from the public is permission, why should we stop them? They need more than permission, they need the government to give them exclusive use of property (including, if necessary, acquiring property for them by way of eminent domain.)
- mcguire 8y agoDon't forget that it also effectively prevents any other similar solution: "The result is that the tunnel would have negative value to the region. As a transportation service based on how Musk wishes to construct and operate it, it has practically no value. But in the event of upzoning in West Los Angeles, the tunnel would complicate any possibility of rail under Sunset connecting Hollywood with Downtown. Metro may even need to acquire and demolish Musk's tunnel, or else dig under the tunnel, which would complicate intermediate stations in Silver Lake and Echo Park."
- slg 8y agoThere is already rail connecting Hollywood to downtown that doesn't see particularly high usage. I am not sure why this specific real estate needs to be reserved for a second Hollywood to downtown subway line that as far as I am aware has not made any progress in the decade or two since it was initially proposed.
- gamblor956 8y agoThe Red Line, which you are referring to, is one of the most used subway lines in the US. Combined with the Purple Line to Koreatown, the two are #9 of the list of most-used rail systems in the US...and that doesn't include the light rail systems (i.e., above-ground rails) of the Expo, Gold, and Blue lines.
- slg 8y agoLos Angeles is the 2nd biggest city in the US. Being number 9 on the list of most used railways in the US isn't exactly a huge accomplishment when much smaller cities like Boston appear above them on the list.
- Krasnol 8y ago> I really don't get the hate this is receiving It seems Musk went the usual hype wave way. Once it was cool to like things he does. Now it is cool to hate what he does. It's not helping that his behavior on twitter reinforced that trend but it was one already before that.
- dunpeal 8y agoPretty much. For a while he could do no wrong. Now he can do no right. Typical overhype/crash cycle.
- Fnoord 8y agoThat's akin to people saying the truth lies in the middle, a fallacy [1]. If you want to reach a conclusion you need to analyse all the situations, and figure out if the criticism is warranted yes or no. In case of the pedophile tweet my opinion is that, yes the criticism is warranted. YMMV.. ..but I'm not sure we should have this discussion in this very thread.. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation
- skybrian 8y agoUnderstanding the hype cycle doesn't tell you who is right. It just makes you more skeptical of going along with the hype cycle. In particular, Elon Musk's bad behavior on Twitter doesn't tell us very much about the technical feasibility of building a tunnel, any more than it tells us whether a SpaceX rocket will fly. Mood affiliation might make it seem like it's closely related, but logically it's not.
- stephengillie 8y agoIs it schadenfreude to hate hubris?
- Sangermaine 8y agoNo, it’s simply that the honeymoon is over and he’s starting to be treated like any other businessman. That means what was once glossed over as endearing or harmless foibles are now being recognized as the problems they were all along. Musk is having difficulty adjusting to this new situation where he’s not only receiving fawning adulation as some kind of technology messiah anymore.
- thecupisblue 8y agoAngelenos? Why not just "Angels"?
- stephengillie 8y agoThat would be almost as confusing as "Tacoman", the demonym for a resident of Tacoma.
- thecupisblue 8y agothis is hilarious
- jasonwatkinspdx 8y agoBecause the name of the city is "Los Angeles" not "The Angels".
- thecupisblue 8y ago> Los Angeles (US: /lɔːs ˈændʒələs/); Spanish for "The Angels";
- LyndsySimon 8y agoWait until they figure out what “The La Brea Tar Pits” translates to...
- jasonwatkinspdx 8y agoYou missed my point. We use the Spanish form for the city name, so we also use the Spanish form to refer to the people who live there.
- THE_PUN_STOPS 8y agoIt is derived from the spanish word Angeleño.
- thecupisblue 8y ago
- gamblor956 8y agoThe "hate" is because the Musk proposal would accommodate 2800 people per day, or less than 3% of the crowd of a typical game, most of which arrives within the space of the same 2-3 hours. (In comparison: the lowest-capacity trains in the LA Metro system can handle 2800 people in half an hour--about 4 trains--running on a regular schedule, or 6000+ running on special-event schedules.) In other words, its a solution to absolutely nothing. In fact, it's worse than nothing: it's just Elon bloviating another half-assed idea that he takes no responsibility for.
- curyous 8y agoIt's not supposed to solve the stadium problem, it's a test track.
- gamblor956 8y agoIt's a test track that would interfere with the future construction of any public transportation running through the area, including lines that are currently in the early planning stages. That doesn't include it's impact on utility lines, water mains, or future housing construction (the Elonrail would only be 30 feet deep as currently planned, so no building over 3 stories could be built over it).
- mcgarnagle 8y agoElonrail responsibilities are to offer a good negotiation position for themselves. It's up to the city to counteroffer, say....: 1. Burying slightly deeper to accommodate larger building for the future. 2. Demolish the "test rail" after the "test" is proven to work. 3. Expand the rail after success is proven to accommodate a larger attendance Elonrail/boring company is happy with the success of the test's outcome, the boring company will use this test as propaganda to further their goals and build larger projects, the boring company will not mind tearing down (or grandiosely upgrading) their tunnel with the new contracts it receives, and in the meantime: the region makes money from the project in the process.
- 8y ago