9 ms·
Electric planes still have a few challenges ahead but basically technical progress seems to make short haul electrical flight feasible within the next decade.
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
Electric planes still have a few challenges ahead but basically technical progress seems to make short haul electrical flight feasible within the next decade.
The reason this is being pursued by so many companies is that electric planes solve a lot of problems and represent an enormous disruption to the aviation industry. Modern air planes are very complex and expensive to operate and need a lot of maintenance. The cost of operating them is completely dominated by fuel cost, maintenance overhead, and expensive taxes and fees at airports related to noise and pollution.
With electrical engines, all of this changes. They are light and simple and tend to have a long operational life with very low maintenance requirements. Recharging batteries is extremely cheap compared to burning tons of fuel (literally). Filling up an A321, which takes 24K liters of kerosene, will take you somewhere between 10 and 15K and gets you a range of around close to 8000 km. Most flights are much shorter than that meaning a lot of their weight and range is redundant. Also, you burn a lot of fuel on takeoffs and most planes need to get up high to get to an economical fuel burn rate to cruise. So you pay a huge price for getting all that weight up on every take off.
Electrical planes don't need to get up that high and can cruise efficiently at both low and high altitudes. Once cruising, operating them as a glider is actually feasible as well because you can safely turn the engines off and on again (unthinkable with a jet).
- emptyfile 8y agoI really don't get it, if batteries are too expensive and bulky to get +500 km out of a car, what kind of range can you get with a plane?? Wouldn't it add a ridiculous amount of weight compared to kerosene.
- Arnt 8y agoRead the article. Key quote. “A lot of the flights here are only 15 to 30 minutes.” Those planes don't go 500km. They go up, fly a short stretch over some complicated terrain, down. That's it. As to why: Kerosene isn't really an option any more. We have a climate problem, and in this generation, not some future generation.
- outworlder 8y ago> A lot of the flights here are only 15 to 30 minutes. And yet you need to keep at least that flight time as a minimum safe reserve.
- microcolonel 8y agoYes, and the physics of it are even worse than you imagine. If you don't mind a voice/video explanation of this, I found this one worked for people I know [0]. In the air, there is a cascading relationship between the requirements for lift, and the weight of the fuel (batteries). Batteries being, by weight, at least between 40 and 100x times less energy dense than Kerosene, the weight of batteries competing with Kerosene multiplies the real amount of energy required to transport aircraft. This relationship doesn't hurt so much on the road, since there is generally not much need for lift, and also since there is a straightforward way of recovering the increase in inertia. [0]: https://youtu.be/VNvzZfsC13o https://youtu.be/VNvzZfsC13o
- aerodude 8y agoGonna comment on your last statement here. The reason aircraft cruise so high is because 1) it's efficient. Flight paths are heavily optimized, and while you spend energy getting up there, you don't spend much getting down. Energy is a conserved quantity. 2) We want to fly above the weather. In the early days of flight, we actually did fly at low altitudes, and we lost a lot of aircraft in the process. Low altitude flying is dangerous, and not really an advantage. Generally, you want more altitude, not less, because the more altitude you have, the more energy you have. This let's you trade height for speed, keeps you away from weather patterns, and means that in the event of a failure, you have time to plan and execute.
- outworlder 8y agoI can see electric planes disrupting the general aviation industry. However, we are not anywhere near close of achieving the performance of jet engine aircraft, be it speed or range. Passengers are not going to want to fly much slower than they are now. > Most flights are much shorter than that meaning a lot of their weight and range is redundant This is wrong. Most of the weight is fuel, which you can reduce by not topping off the tanks. In fact, airliners will do these calculations multiple times a day for every aircraft. On the other hand, you can not make a battery go lighter by charging it less. > electrical planes don't need to get up that high and can cruise efficiently at both low and high altitudes This is wrong. While they don't have to fiddle with the fuel mixture, they are still subject to air resistance. Unless you are flying slow, but then take out the Airbus from the discussion. And you can still fly slow at high altitudes with larger wings. > So you pay a huge price for getting all that weight up on every take off. That you do. But the weight actually * decreases * over time. Not so with a battery. > nce cruising, operating them as a glider is actually feasible as well because you can safely turn the engines off and on again Noone is going to book a flight on a glider to go anywhere except for leisure. As a part-time glider, you still want as much altitude as you can get (energy, in other words). Even for GA it's a stretch. Many pilots (and the AOPA) recommend landing when you have less than one hour of fuel left. One hour is more than the entire range of most electrical aircraft in development. I can see hybrid GA aircraft getting used (to save on maintenance), and maybe even electric trainers. I am all for electric engines, but the challenges are not just "a few".
- ulrikrasmussen 8y agoYou seem to know a lot more about this than me, so pardon my ignorance, but how come cruising at low altitude is more economical with an electric plane? I thought that the primary reason for wanting to go high was because of the decreased air density and thus resistance, and I reckon that that would not change for an electric plane. Is it just because the energy is cheaper so the extra overhead is less significant?
- gruturo 8y agoProbably because fuel is so much more expensive than electricity. You avoid having to climb all the way up just so you're using up less of this very expensive fuel, which especially on short haul flights is a huge % of the whole flight. Not actually economical in terms of energy used per distance covered, but more practical and likely to be appreciated by passengers? Less stress on the airframe too, probably.
- mikepurvis 8y agoNoise could be an issue too— no one wants a passenger jet flying over their city at <5000ft, but maybe it wouldn't such a big issue if it was a lot quieter.
- Tuxer 8y agoBecause he/she doesn't know what he's talking about. Jets will always cruise at their maximum allowed altitude except for some really short flights. In cruise the only thing you're fighting is aerodynamic drag (no ground friction) and climbing is the best way to reduce that. If anything electric planes using their higher thrust will even climb quicker.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoFor short haul what matters is balancing how much energy is spent getting up high vs. how much benefit you are getting from being there. With an electrical engine you'll go as high as needed to maximize your range. The energy cost is not really a consideration here, it's all about the range. With a jet you will instead be optimizing fuel flow since that fundamentally drives your cost. That means taking the minimum amount of fuel you can get away with and the maximum number of passengers to ensure you actually recover the cost of the fuel you are burning.
- montenegrohugo 8y agoI understand the advantages of an electrical motor to an ICE, but I have doubts regarding your third paragraph. The energy density of Li-Ion batteries best-case scenario is around 1 MJ/kg, whilst Kerosene is 42.8-42.6 MJ/kg. That's a 40x !!! difference in energy/weight. Of course the electric engine will have a big efficiency advantage (think 80% vs 40% for ICE), but the gap in energy density is still enormous. The other (huge) advantages in flight safety and reduction in noise and overhead costs still apply, but I don't believe electrical planes will be as disruptive as portrayed without significant advances in battery technology.
- anonymous5133 8y agoAgree. I think the big breakthrough is going to be with figuring out some sort of replacement for the li-ion battery in terms of eletrical powered aircraft. Batteries are just way too heavy for how much energy they hold. There has to be a better way. I think we need some out of the box thinking for this one. I know solar energy is advancing, what about if we put thin-film solar cells on the exterior of the body of the aircraft? That might allow greater distance travel without much additional weight. There is already solar powered aircraft that traveled around the globe called the solar one. It is experimental but still a good concept to look at.
- antocv 8y agoPut kerosene in a tank to drive a generator to provide electricity when taking off, and as backup to generate DC for charging batteries when necessary. Now instead of kerosene burning in a jet engine, "we are all fucked if it doesnt work", its burning in a simple compact, "fuck it if it doesnt work", generator.
- consumer451 8y agoBoeing-backed startup Zunum is doing exactly that and is planning on delivering their first 12 seat aircraft to JetSuite in 2022. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zunum_Aero https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zunum_Aero
- 8y ago
- ericpauley 8y agoWhat is the basis for this? Fuel is extremely energy dense, we do not yet have battery tech even close to its energy density by mass [1]. Most of the weight and aerodynamic footprint of a plane is not fuel weight but airframe and contents. You seem to be implying that electric planes will have substantially different aerodynamic properties (high speed cruising at low altitude, no more takeoff expense, "gliding" at reasonable cruise speed) Further, in terms of wasted weight batteries seem perhaps worse than fuel, because while you can fly a plane on shorter flights with tanks partially empty, it is much harder to reduce battery weight per flight. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density
- Arnt 8y agoFYI the relevant flights are low-altitude flights anyway. https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/wf784#1daa9d35 https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/wf784#1daa9d35 is typical.
- usrusr 8y agoAnd that kind of flight profile is truly the only reason electric planes are can ever be worth any consideration. Even in an all-electric future (e.g. one with abundant fusion power), long distance flights would be served by burning synthetic fuels. For those short electric hops, how much of the total battery capacity required would already be used up at liftoff? Maybe catapults/winches/detachable power tethers could make a real difference here?