8 ms·
This title is incorrect. They are arguing over whether the presence of a competitor within 1/2 mile counts as competition even though the competitor has not ac
by ars 8y ago
This title is incorrect.
They are arguing over whether the presence of a competitor within 1/2 mile counts as competition even though the competitor has not actually started service to the customer.
i.e. does the customer actually need two services? Or is the presence of another one very close by, enough to be considered as competition? (The assumption being that they would/could expand to the customer.)
Better title:
FCC can define markets with only one ISP as “competitive,”, if there is another ISP within 1/2 mile, court rules
- noobermin 8y agoIn that case, I think the rational thing for ISP's to do is to carve out enclaves where they don't compete for customers. I suppose the new political FCC will find that competitive.
- Aloha 8y agoThe FCC IMO is no more political than its ever been. What we're ascribing to politics (which it may very well be) is in my opinion better ascribed to regulatory capture - which is a problem many regulatory agencies have had over time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture
- mindslight 8y agoRegulatory capture is the engine driving contemporary politics. You buy off the party whose biases align better with your own mission, then wait for theme to have their turn at the trough.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ghrifter 8y agoUnited States has been a financial oligarchy since the turn of the 20th century.
- bo1024 8y agoI think this is accurate but politics swirl around it or are used as smokescreens. For example I followed Net Neutrality quite closely and it was not initially painted as partisan, until the FCC realized that by calling NN an "Obama-era regulation" they could dogwhistle some republicans over to their side and make it seem like a traditionally partisan issue. (For some reason news sites played along and used this term all over the place.) But this all happened midway through the process as they cast around for justifications for what was really regulatory capture.
- plopz 8y agoThey already have, look at a map of isp coverage in new jersey comparing comcast and optimum. https://i.imgur.com/3oUUw7b.png https://i.imgur.com/3oUUw7b.png
- ABCLAW 8y agoOh look, it's an almost ideal market allocation scheme. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_allocation_scheme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_allocation_scheme Edit: I always find it interesting how when a FANG company is called out, an employee will provide a guarded defense, but when an ISP is called out regarding competition issues, the result is dead silence.
- im3w1l 8y agoI rarely see any ISP-employees discuss anything at all on hackernews.
- tylerhou 8y agoI don't think the definition is too unreasonable. Many areas would still be non-competitive according to the FTC: in order to guarantee that most of your customers are within 1/2 mile of another ISP, you'd have to significantly gerrymander your coverage areas into <2 mile wide strips. Or you'd have to ask another ISP to build in a certain fashion such that they have a bunch of isolated nodes or strips going through your large coverage area. For reference, most of the coverage area in the map in another comment (https://imgur.com/3oUUw7b https://imgur.com/3oUUw7b) would probably be considered non-competitive. I think 1/2 might be a bit too far, though. 1/4 seems maybe more reasonable.
- bo1024 8y agoIt's incredibly unreasonable. Economists roughly classify markets as monopoly (single seller), oligopoly (few, powerful sellers), and competitive markets. We are talking about a monopoly that's sort of close to being an oligopoly. A more accurate term would be "just barely not as far as possible from competitive".
- tylerhou 8y agoI'm not saying the current state of affairs is reasonable (i.e. I'm saying that ISPs are currently monopolies). I'm saying that the FTC's proposed definition to determine whether there is competition in a coverage area is reasonable. One heuristic I'm using to support my claim is that the FTC's proposed definition implies there is still an ISP monopoly in the area in the picture I linked.
- bo1024 8y agoIt might start making sense to me if they didn't use the word "competition" but that word means something else.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoIf I can't buy service from that other provider, then they don't count as competition. I can't threaten to leave my current ISP to get a better price, and you can be sure that they know that.
- dwheeler 8y ago100% agree. If I can't get service from someone else, it doesn't matter if it's 1/2 mile or 100 miles away - there is no competition. Even if there is "someone else" that may not be enough. It the "alternative" cannot support video (such as YouTube and Netflix), or can't upload my data at a reasonable speed, it isn't really a competitor.
- ars 8y agoIt's not about you as an individual, it's about the market and if it's realistic for the competitor to enter it. If it is, the incumbent will be more restrained in their prices, to avoid inducing the competitor to enter that market. That's basically the crux of the matter, and the judge rules both ways of looking at things are reasonable since no one knows the future.
- Dylan16807 8y agoFor last-mile infrastructure, anything between "just out of range" and "50 miles out of range" is of similar difficulty to expand into. It's realistic to imagine a competitor could expand, but it's a far cry from actual competition. These half-mile ranges shouldn't be lumped in with locations that have choices.
- paulddraper 8y ago> If I can't buy service from that other provider, then they don't count as competition. Right. Businesses are often currently wired for only one ISP. And the question is: "Can I buy future service from the other guy?" It's a fuzzy question, because you can essentially always buy service...for some amount of money. The evidence presented (and deemed credible by the court) is that ISPs will frequently build connections for businesses up to one mile away. And most of the businesses in question were less than half a mile away. And so the court ruled that the FCC could choose to call the market competitive, based on that evidence. It's an unsatisfyingly fuzzy question, with perhaps an equally unsatisfying answer.
- ajross 8y agoActually, the decision per se isn't even about that. It's about whether the FCC, being the regulatory body responsible for this stuff, is able to decide for itself whether or not a "nearby" service provider counts as "competition" in an abstract sense. The court held, basically, that the FCC's decision is reasonable enough to fit within its congressionally-mandaded charter, so making the decision is none of the legal system's business. If you don't like it vote in an administration which will staff the FCC with people who agree with you.
- rossdavidh 8y agoTruth. Really, I have to sympathize with the court on this, they're basically saying "The FCC knows more about communications technology and the economics associated with it than a judge does", which is undoubtedly true. Deciding this sort of thing is what the FCC is for. That doesn't mean they got it right, but short of creating a communication-technology centered appeals court, that's what we've got. The FCC is the correct (currently existing) government institution to be making that kind of decision. Just because they (arguably) made the wrong decision here, doesn't mean it makes sense to have appeals court judges deciding this, as the technology and economic background required to make that decision is not part of their training, nor something they could acquire in the course of a court case.
- trumped 8y agoif you pay extra to get hooked up to the other ISP, will they come the extra 1/2 mile? around here they won't if it's somebody else's territory...
- ryandrake 8y agoNew business idea! Become Comcast’s or Verizon’s Sock Puppet “ISP” who does nothing but “exist 1/2 mike away from people” so they can claim there’s competition. I can do that without leaving my house and wearing only a bathrobe.
- ars 8y agoReally? 1/2 a mile is not much - you'd need wires every 3 blocks or so. How do you plan to install those wires without leaving your house?
- apk17 8y agoWhat wires? You just need to provide internet service to someone, i.e. yourself and maybe your direct neighbours. Also, 1/2 mile distance covers about three quarter of a square mile.