3 ms·
Should we also tax people living in earthquake-prone and tornado-prone areas? How about blizzard-prone areas? Keep going with this and we will run out of places
by ryandrake 8y ago
Should we also tax people living in earthquake-prone and tornado-prone areas? How about blizzard-prone areas? Keep going with this and we will run out of places (in the USA) where it’s ok to live.
Also, as someone who lived in south Florida, flood insurance is a joke and unavailable near the coast anyway. Nobody expects it to pay out enough in a major catastrophe, including hurricanes and flooding.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- closeparen 8y agoBlizzards don’t typically level buildings, and a tornado’s path of destruction is narrow enough that the lucky homeowners can sufficiently subsidize the unlucky ones through insurance. Neither of those risks are comparable to earthquakes and hurricanes/flooding, which can be relied upon to thoroughly destroy huge swaths of cities, regularly.
- WkndTriathlete 8y agoYou mean like blizzards like this: https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Sports/2010/1212/Vikings-Metrodome-roof-collapses-for-the-fifth-time https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Sports/2010/1212/Vikings-Metro... ?
- gamblor956 8y agoCalifornia regularly survives 6.0 earthquakes with minimal damage, because our building codes require earthquake-safe construction. For example, the 2008 Chino Hills quake, at 5.5 intensity, caused almost no damage other than the unsecured contents of store shelves falling onto the floor. In contrast, a slightly stronger quake in DC (5.8) caused hundreds of millions of dollars in damage to structures, including to the Washington Monument, because the local building codes did not contemplate earthquakes.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoSome risks are not insurable since they're guaranteed to happen. That's why no private insurance company will offer flood insurance, but since these owners of capital have enough political clout, they are able to secure a taxpayer funded bailout fund (nation flood insurance program).
- hanbura 8y agoI am guaranteed to die at some point. Yet (at least in Germany) I can go to a private insurance company, agree to pay a few euros each month and in return they pay out 10000€ when I die to cover my funeral, no questions about cause of death asked. It's an insurance that is guaranteed to pay out, but it still insures against uncertainty because I don't know when I will die. Flood insurance is fundamentally the same, the payouts are just not well spread, requiring a large geographically diverse insurance company.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoIn order for the insurance company to pay you 10,000 euros when you die, they have to collect that much from you plus their operating expenses minus the investment gains expected over your expected lifetime. This is whole life insurance, and it's usually a better idea to stick the money into index funds and avoid paying the insurance company for their operating expenses. And we're not talking about a 10,000 euro loss here, when a home gets flooded, the loss is likely six figures or more since houses aren't cheap. Most people can't afford insurance for a likely loss of $100,000. There are many large geographically diverse insurance companies, and there is a reason all of them stay away from flood insurance. There's no buyer for the amount of premium they would have to charge.
- cbm-vic-20 8y ago> Should we also tax people living in [...] blizzard-prone areas? We already do; municipalities in blizzard-prone areas factor snow removal costs into their annual expenditures, which show up in residents' taxes.
- growlist 8y agoOne theory I've heard is that the prevalence of natural hazards in the US explain the comparatively lower level of development prior to arrival of Europeans - basically any time the locals were getting somewhere some kind of catastrophe would befall them, and destroy their progress. Does make one think about the long term, especially with a more extreme climate expected to be on the way.
- maxerickson 8y agoPrivate insurance works for earthquakes and tornadoes.
- sizzzzlerz 8y agoUntil a massive quake wipes out an entire region, at which point, the insurance carriers declare bankruptcy because they won't be able to pay off all the policies. And that is already factoring in the exorbitant premiums being paid and high deductibles on the policies. With tens of thousands of claims, home owners will get pennies on the dollar if they get anything at all.
- maxerickson 8y agoDo you have insider knowledge or are you just expressing cynicism?
- blang 8y agoTypically insurance companies buy insurance against this, it's called reinsurance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinsurance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinsurance
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nradov 8y agoYes homeowners should bear the full cost of their choices. It's entirely possible to build a modern house strong enough to survive earthquakes, tornadoes, and hurricanes with only minor damage. Flooding is more difficult to design around.
- sigstoat 8y ago> Keep going with this and we will run out of places (in the USA) where it’s ok to live. plenty of places that don't see earthquakes, tornados, floods, hurricanes, or much of anything else. blizzards might sound apocalyptic to a floridian, but generally just damage above-ground electrical, and maybe knock a few trees into a few roofs.
- adrianN 8y agoStrict building codes increase the cost of buildings but make them safe in case of earthquakes. You can see that as a form of tax for living in an earthquake-prone area.