5 ms·
>> Such a thing does not exist because machines think like humans in the same way that planes fly like birds. Could we please lay this empty platitude to reast
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> Such a thing does not exist because machines think like humans in the same way
that planes fly like birds.
Could we please lay this empty platitude to reast? "Planes don't fly by
flapping their wings like birds, so why should computers think like humans?".
Well, except that we were only able to built flying machines (rather than
floating ones) when we figured out why birds can fly [1].
And then, the whole of our computer science is based on the idea that a
computer is, actually, the same kind of system as a human mind- a
computational device, a machine that can compute everything and anything that
can be computed. This is the deep insight that informs the ambition to create
artificial intelligence: that brains are a kind of computer, computers are a
kind of brain, and they can both compute the same kind of program, in other
words- intelligence.
Though we may not know how human minds work exactly and therefore we can't
readily copy them, it is thanks to Turing's and Church's insight that we even
have computers today. And so, in a very real sense, we can only ever create
thinking machines that do intelligence in the same way that humans do
intelligence [2].
_______________________
[1] I mean, a boomerang is really an airfoil so I guess Australian Aborigines
had figured out flight long before the Wright brothers, but I gues they didn't
need flying vehicles back then?
[2] Unless there is a paradigm shift and we figure out a better way to do it
etc etc disclaimer disclaimer.
- jimbokun 8y agoBrains are not computers, and brains were not the model for computers. Formal logic and the Turing machine were the model for computers. Turing and Church did not invent computers based on their careful study of human biology and physiology.
- jorgemf 8y agoNeural networks are based on human brains. So, how are they both different? It is a very hard question, because if we would understand better the brain we will simulate it better in the computers, how do we know we are not already doing a good simulation of the brain? Any answer to this question would be a step forward to improve our artificial intelligence systems.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoThe point is that human minds and computers are both computational devices of equivalent power and that we believe that creating artificial intelligence is possible because intelligence is a program that can be computed by a Turing machine just as it is computed by a human mind. Obviously, the Turing-Church thesis didn't have anything to do with brains. It does, however, have very important implications about our ambition to create human-like artificial minds.
- Isinlor 8y agoThere may be an issue with running a "brain" program on a non-brain hardware depending on what the program is. We don't know what the program is so it's hard to speculate but, it is possible that brain program is not well fitted to silicon based architectures. It may turn out that low-level physical and chemical processes that are crucial to brain functioning are prohibitively expensive to simulate. Brains after all operate in the perfect simulator and evolution had no reason to avoid expensive to simulate solutions. I would guess that it is rather unlikely, but it is possible since even a single cell chemistry, well even a single organelle chemistry is complex. Simulating processes involving RNA may turn out to prohibitively expensive. Also, I'm sure that theoretically optimal "intelligence program" on silicon processors is vastly different from organic ones. They may share a lot, but the constraints are just so vastly different including the most important ones like energy efficiency or space availability.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> There may be an issue with running a "brain" program on a non-brain hardware depending on what the program is. That's not impossible! For example, it's easy to find algorithms that a computer can carry out without error that a human mind would really struggle with. Although this is a case of computational resources, rather than the expressive power of the computational apparatus, it's still the case that it's not always possible to find programs that both humans and computers can compute in practice. So it may even be that, while computers can run some programs very efficiently, that humans can't, it's the other way around also and computers can't efficiently run the programs that humans can. In which case of course, either the entire AI enterprise is doomed to failure, or we get lucky and there is some other way to do intelligence that is available to computers but not humans. Who knows!
- kjeetgill 8y ago> Well, except that we were only able to built flying machines (rather than floating ones) when we figured out why birds can fly [1]. > [1] I mean, a boomerang is really an airfoil so I guess Australian Aborigines had figured out flight long before the Wright brothers, but I guess they didn't need flying vehicles back then? What? I'm not sure anyone would count a boomerang as "figuring out" flight let alone how birds fly. I'm no historian but I'm pretty sure flight was first figured out mechanically through trial and error well before we had a good theoretical model for flight, let alone figuring out how birds fly. Either that or we have drastically different meaning for what it means to figure something out. It took ages for us to fully understand how flight worked, well after we could fly. That's the basis of the apocryphal story: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/bumblebees-cant-fly/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/bumblebees-cant-fly/ https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Bumblebee_argument https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Bumblebee_argument